New Catcher

SDS

Been using Foxx who I crush the ball with, but might move him to 3B. I’m between Pudge, finest JT, and finest Salvy. What do y’all think?

SDS

@SaldanaBros5 said in New Catcher:

Been using Foxx who I crush the ball with, but might move him to 3B. I’m between Pudge, finest JT, and finest Salvy. What do y’all think?

JT's contact can hurt you when u go for a WS/HOF run. It really could. If u cherish defense, Pudge is your guy. If you like a balanced dude, most certainly pick up Salvy.
My choice would be Salvy out of those 3

SDS

CAP is your best option. Hands down

SDS

@mr_pin_em_down07 said in New Catcher:

@SaldanaBros5 said in New Catcher:

Been using Foxx who I crush the ball with, but might move him to 3B. I’m between Pudge, finest JT, and finest Salvy. What do y’all think?

JT's contact can hurt you when u go for a WS/HOF run. It really could. If u cherish defense, Pudge is your guy. If you like a balanced dude, most certainly pick up Salvy.
My choice would be Salvy out of those 3

Thanks for the insight man!

SDS

Cavan's Dad

SDS

In all star JT is a beast. But as mentioned above, Salvy is the man when playing HOF, gold defense with a good arm and has a great swing

SDS

@SaldanaBros5 said in New Catcher:

@mr_pin_em_down07 said in New Catcher:

@SaldanaBros5 said in New Catcher:

Been using Foxx who I crush the ball with, but might move him to 3B. I’m between Pudge, finest JT, and finest Salvy. What do y’all think?

JT's contact can hurt you when u go for a WS/HOF run. It really could. If u cherish defense, Pudge is your guy. If you like a balanced dude, most certainly pick up Salvy.
My choice would be Salvy out of those 3

Thanks for the insight man!

No problem Bro!

SDS

Salvador Perez crushes the ball. He hits everything hard!

SDS

I really enjoyed using all three you're considering. I think Salvy is my fav of the bunch. easy prestige too.

SDS

I wanted to like Pudge but his lack of power makes him, generally, an easy out. I don’t fear him at all when I face him either.

Perez is an absolute stud.

I found with JT that I prestiged him pretty easily, but never felt like I got much out of him. He did most of his damage on a few games. Had a 4 hr game and a 3 hr game with him. The problem though, was that he had so many games where he didn’t do much of anything.

SDS

Salvy and once you prestige him he is unreal

SDS

I liked both salvy and pudge..pudge for me has played way above his power attributes, and the run game against me is basically shut down

SDS

@lvega127 said in New Catcher:

Salvador Perez crushes the ball. He hits everything hard!

Salvy was the first "Finest" card I prestiged, and he hasn't left my lineup since.

SDS

Another vote for Salvy. Pudge is crushing for me in the current event but even with all that he won't unseat Perez in my lineup,

SDS

Yup. Salvy is the man.

SDS

Ironically, I've had Sal let a bucnh of balls go by lately... for whatever reason Foxx has been solid for me. Pudge swings a pool noodle for me. has enough power to line out consistently. My only hits with Pudge tend to be just late oppo field gappers or nothing.

Personally I think Pudges speed helps cause for me he hits below his numbers. Torre is an underrated do it all option that cal also play 3rd, Biggio's speed and bunting ability is a plus and Pablo has had some streaky good runs for me. I still think Foxx is the best option with Posey and, Pudge, and Finest Sal just below. Then Weiters, Pablo, Biggio and Torre.

SDS

Perez is the best overall/ balances option but I cant stand how slow he runs. He has the unfortunate ability to stretch a double into a long single. JT is a power beast though and he has speed. For several stretches he was much better than Perez. For a while I was using Foxx with Pudge on the bench as a defensive replacement. This was my favorite setup although it used up a bench spot. If you ran up against a bunt heavy guy or steals heavy just sub in Pudge and he shuts it down. You can either sub out Foxx then or move Foxx to 1st or 3rd and take out one of those guys for Pudge.

SDS

Man, am I the only person using PS Grandal? He's the only catcher I've been able to hit with. His only flaw is that he's slow as dirt.

SDS

Doesn’t Grandal have like zero speed?

SDS

@halfbutt said in New Catcher:

Doesn’t Grandal have like zero speed?

I think it's 6. Ha ha!