-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@dolenz_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
I am not a Yankees fan but given the game situation as described earlier in this thread it seemed like a good move to try and win the game. Miggy even said this before the game.
“I know history is very important,” Cabrera said before the game, “but we need to win first. It's not about me. It's about the team.”
If it had been a blowout and they did this I could understand it but in this case with a runner on 2nd and first base open in a one run game the move makes sense, regardless of whether it worked out or not.
It would've made more since if they did it with less than two outs. They walked him on TWO outs. It just makes the whole thing stink.
it only stinks for the fans that is it, the move was right. he will get his hit. Be happy with the win
I'm happy with the win, but Boone had to leave it with a bitter taste
-
@raesone_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@jogger171717_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
1 run game, 1B was open, a lefty was on the mound, and a lefty was on deck. The move makes perfect baseball sense. Cabrera should’ve just gotten a hit earlier in the game lmao.
What happened after the IBB makes your argument pointless. For the sake of respect Miggy should've been allowed to try for a hit. Besides there were two outs anyway and he'd already struck out twice. It's called sportsmanship.
The Yankees got MLB The Showed 22
The Tigers got showed 22. The moment is get a hit in one ab and win the game. The cpu pitcher throws you no pitches over the plate. Walks you. Moment failed.
-
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@dolenz_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
I am not a Yankees fan but given the game situation as described earlier in this thread it seemed like a good move to try and win the game. Miggy even said this before the game.
“I know history is very important,” Cabrera said before the game, “but we need to win first. It's not about me. It's about the team.”
If it had been a blowout and they did this I could understand it but in this case with a runner on 2nd and first base open in a one run game the move makes sense, regardless of whether it worked out or not.
It would've made more since if they did it with less than two outs. They walked him on TWO outs. It just makes the whole thing stink.
I could be mad at Roberts for pulling Kershaw when he had a perfect game going against MIN but the dodger won the game and do not need any injury to Kershaw. It is not about Accolades but is about winning. We fans may not like it but winning should be first.
-
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@capt_awesome34 said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@jogger171717_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
1 run game, 1B was open, a lefty was on the mound, and a lefty was on deck. The move makes perfect baseball sense. Cabrera should’ve just gotten a hit earlier in the game lmao.
What happened after the IBB makes your argument pointless. For the sake of respect Miggy should've been allowed to try for a hit. Besides there were two outs anyway and he'd already struck out twice. It's called sportsmanship.
Sportsmanship are you serious ---its called you're a Manager of Major League Team you do what's best for your team - you're making it sound like that was his last at bat for the season. I know Detroit doesn't have much to look forward to but seriously it was the right move.
"Right" move or not, it was a [expletive] move and the world knows it, except you apparently.
Ha. The world knows it? Even the majority of the people in this thread doesn't agree with it.
-
Baseball move, even if Miggy is pedestrian now.
The worst I've seen is the 1993 AS Game in Baltimore where Cito Gaston (huge a**hole) put his own closer in a 9-3 game instead of Moose.
-
@dolenz_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@capt_awesome34 said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@jogger171717_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
1 run game, 1B was open, a lefty was on the mound, and a lefty was on deck. The move makes perfect baseball sense. Cabrera should’ve just gotten a hit earlier in the game lmao.
What happened after the IBB makes your argument pointless. For the sake of respect Miggy should've been allowed to try for a hit. Besides there were two outs anyway and he'd already struck out twice. It's called sportsmanship.
Sportsmanship are you serious ---its called you're a Manager of Major League Team you do what's best for your team - you're making it sound like that was his last at bat for the season. I know Detroit doesn't have much to look forward to but seriously it was the right move.
"Right" move or not, it was a [expletive] move and the world knows it, except you apparently.
Ha. The world knows it? Even the majority of the people in this thread doesn't agree with it.
This thread and forum is a small sample size compared to the millions of baseball fans out there.
-
@yankblan_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
Baseball move, even if Miggy is pedestrian now.
The worst I've seen is the 1993 AS Game in Baltimore where Cito Gaston (huge a**hole) put his own closer in a 9-3 game instead of Moose.
Forgot about this one. That was slimy 100%.
-
I’m a tigers and huge miggy fan but I would’ve done the same thing as Boone to try and win
-
Thursday day game. Lots of kids there because they're off from school. As fans, it's ridiculously disappointing. Could he have gotten the hit earlier? Yeah. I'm sure there were scoring decisions during the previous 2999 hits as well.
The FANS in person on a sunny day game were let down by Boone not pitching to Miggy. Even trying to pitch around him would have shown some brass.
I'm mad as a fan of the sport. My kids are off too, and tuned in on this as well. Sure you can watch it on YouTube in a few days whenever he gets it. Not quite the same.
I'm done here. I apologize for caring. I'm certainly not a Boone fan, but we'll see what gets said by him, Miggy, MLB Network etc.
-
Kind of related, but in an RTTS I was doing in MLBTS20, Miggy retired on 2999 hits and 497 homers:
https://twitter.com/red_ted_is_back/status/1261869773836521472?s=21&t=z9m2ISWD5E_FgpZyrWBJIw
Now that’s a cheap move
-
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@capt_awesome34 said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@jogger171717_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
1 run game, 1B was open, a lefty was on the mound, and a lefty was on deck. The move makes perfect baseball sense. Cabrera should’ve just gotten a hit earlier in the game lmao.
What happened after the IBB makes your argument pointless. For the sake of respect Miggy should've been allowed to try for a hit. Besides there were two outs anyway and he'd already struck out twice. It's called sportsmanship.
Sportsmanship are you serious ---its called you're a Manager of Major League Team you do what's best for your team - you're making it sound like that was his last at bat for the season. I know Detroit doesn't have much to look forward to but seriously it was the right move.
It was an at-bat where he could have gotten his 3,000 hit. A major milestone that not a lot of players reach. And we actually do have a lot to look forward to, including shutting you out of the postseason again. "Right" move or not, it was a [expletive] move and the world knows it, except you apparently.
wrong...what if the Texas leaguer ended up an out and the yankees won 2-1....it was the right call. Ask yourself, would have wanted Barry Bonds to try for number 756 when it was a 1 run game and an open base bc "sportsmanship"? no...and I know he was roided out but still, same concept.
-
Miggy went 0-3. He got a chance. Just because you want him to get 3000 today doesn’t mean Boone or the Yankees had it out for the guy. Late in the game you make tough decisions to win the game or put your team in a better situation.
Now if Boone worked around Miggy or intentionally walked him in the beginning of the game then you’d have a case.
This is udder lunacy. This ain’t the last AB of Miggys career. He’ll get it.
-
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@jogger171717_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
1 run game, 1B was open, a lefty was on the mound, and a lefty was on deck. The move makes perfect baseball sense. Cabrera should’ve just gotten a hit earlier in the game lmao.
What happened after the IBB makes your argument pointless. For the sake of respect Miggy should've been allowed to try for a hit. Besides there were two outs anyway and he'd already struck out twice. It's called sportsmanship.
Uhh no he shouldn’t be allowed. Are you serious? He’s not above the sport. Yankees were trying to make a baseball move and win the game. That’s like saying an NFL team should punt the ball back to Tom Brady so he can have a chance to at a TD pass milestone. You must be apart of the participation trophy era.
-
@hoboadam_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
Thursday day game. Lots of kids there because they're off from school. As fans, it's ridiculously disappointing. Could he have gotten the hit earlier? Yeah. I'm sure there were scoring decisions during the previous 2999 hits as well.
The FANS in person on a sunny day game were let down by Boone not pitching to Miggy. Even trying to pitch around him would have shown some brass.
I'm mad as a fan of the sport. My kids are off too, and tuned in on this as well. Sure you can watch it on YouTube in a few days whenever he gets it. Not quite the same.
I'm done here. I apologize for caring. I'm certainly not a Boone fan, but we'll see what gets said by him, Miggy, MLB Network etc.
Why should Boone care about what Tigers fans think? Why should anyone other than the Tigers care what Tigers fans think? If you actually were a fan of the sport, you’d applaud Boone for making the correct managerial call and not pandering to fans and going against the best interests of his team.
-
@balsamicarrow88 said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@jogger171717_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
1 run game, 1B was open, a lefty was on the mound, and a lefty was on deck. The move makes perfect baseball sense. Cabrera should’ve just gotten a hit earlier in the game lmao.
What happened after the IBB makes your argument pointless. For the sake of respect Miggy should've been allowed to try for a hit. Besides there were two outs anyway and he'd already struck out twice. It's called sportsmanship.
Uhh no he shouldn’t be allowed. Are you serious? He’s not above the sport. Yankees were trying to make a baseball move and win the game. That’s like saying an NFL team should punt the ball back to Tom Brady so he can have a chance to at a TD pass milestone. You must be apart of the participation trophy era.
I am not. Are you trying to be a troll by saying that? Cute. I'm not saying it was illegal for Boone to do that, but it was terrible of him to do that. By the way an entire stadium in Detroit disagrees with you.
-
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@dolenz_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@capt_awesome34 said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@jogger171717_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
1 run game, 1B was open, a lefty was on the mound, and a lefty was on deck. The move makes perfect baseball sense. Cabrera should’ve just gotten a hit earlier in the game lmao.
What happened after the IBB makes your argument pointless. For the sake of respect Miggy should've been allowed to try for a hit. Besides there were two outs anyway and he'd already struck out twice. It's called sportsmanship.
Sportsmanship are you serious ---its called you're a Manager of Major League Team you do what's best for your team - you're making it sound like that was his last at bat for the season. I know Detroit doesn't have much to look forward to but seriously it was the right move.
"Right" move or not, it was a [expletive] move and the world knows it, except you apparently.
Ha. The world knows it? Even the majority of the people in this thread doesn't agree with it.
This thread and forum is a small sample size compared to the millions of baseball fans out there.
So you speak for the millions of baseball fans out there, which none of us here are.
That's good to know because I thought you were just an overly disappointed Tigers fan
-
@jogger171717_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
@hoboadam_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
Thursday day game. Lots of kids there because they're off from school. As fans, it's ridiculously disappointing. Could he have gotten the hit earlier? Yeah. I'm sure there were scoring decisions during the previous 2999 hits as well.
The FANS in person on a sunny day game were let down by Boone not pitching to Miggy. Even trying to pitch around him would have shown some brass.
I'm mad as a fan of the sport. My kids are off too, and tuned in on this as well. Sure you can watch it on YouTube in a few days whenever he gets it. Not quite the same.
I'm done here. I apologize for caring. I'm certainly not a Boone fan, but we'll see what gets said by him, Miggy, MLB Network etc.
Why should Boone care about what Tigers fans think? Why should anyone other than the Tigers care what Tigers fans think? If you actually were a fan of the sport, you’d applaud Boone for making the correct managerial call and not pandering to fans and going against the best interests of his team.
Why would I applaud Boone for the IBB? I tuned in to see a hit, not a walk.
How'd that walk work out? Good decision? You are arguing for the sake of arguing.
Fans are allowed to choose who or what to root for. Enjoy congratulating Boone on his IBB. I'm disappointed that I didn't get to watch a 3000th hit live on TV.
-
@hoboadam_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
Thursday day game. Lots of kids there because they're off from school. As fans, it's ridiculously disappointing. Could he have gotten the hit earlier? Yeah. I'm sure there were scoring decisions during the previous 2999 hits as well.
The FANS in person on a sunny day game were let down by Boone not pitching to Miggy. Even trying to pitch around him would have shown some brass.
I'm mad as a fan of the sport. My kids are off too, and tuned in on this as well. Sure you can watch it on YouTube in a few days whenever he gets it. Not quite the same.
I'm done here. I apologize for caring. I'm certainly not a Boone fan, but we'll see what gets said by him, Miggy, MLB Network etc.
Weird hill to die on
-
@dolenz_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@dolenz_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@capt_awesome34 said in YANKEES SUCK:
@ladyswampfox_xbl said in YANKEES SUCK:
@jogger171717_psn said in YANKEES SUCK:
1 run game, 1B was open, a lefty was on the mound, and a lefty was on deck. The move makes perfect baseball sense. Cabrera should’ve just gotten a hit earlier in the game lmao.
What happened after the IBB makes your argument pointless. For the sake of respect Miggy should've been allowed to try for a hit. Besides there were two outs anyway and he'd already struck out twice. It's called sportsmanship.
Sportsmanship are you serious ---its called you're a Manager of Major League Team you do what's best for your team - you're making it sound like that was his last at bat for the season. I know Detroit doesn't have much to look forward to but seriously it was the right move.
"Right" move or not, it was a [expletive] move and the world knows it, except you apparently.
Ha. The world knows it? Even the majority of the people in this thread doesn't agree with it.
This thread and forum is a small sample size compared to the millions of baseball fans out there.
So you speak for the millions of baseball fans out there, which none of us here are.
That's good to know because I thought you were just an overly disappointed Tigers fan
Lol. You must be overanalyzing what I said. I never said I speak for all the baseball fans out there, I was merely pointing out that this forum is a fraction of the baseball community and the majority opinion of the forum may or may not necessarily reflect the same opinion of the forum.
It's called statistics.
-
Disagree with this... the manager did exactly what he should have done to give his team the best chance to win. Sportsmanship is one thing, but it's not giving the opposing team a better chance at beating you. It's not like it was the last game of the year... he has all year to get his hit.
