Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential
-
this is hilarious.
in a good way.
-
I like everybody except x-wife. But this is a different type of forum and fans. We are passionate about baseball and we fight tooth and toenail in hopes that SDS stays true to who they are. Alot of us "Veteran fans" don't want to witness this franchise follow footsteps of other sports games that don't listen to fans.
While new ideas from other games are always a possibility i think majority want the game to be great regardless what mode you play. But we do have to be able to have civil discussions in order to reach that goal. I have read alot of your posts and can definitely see your passionate with your viewpoints.
I think it takes a big man to admit when they are wrong and takes a big man to forgive as well. Congrats on your nutsack finally dropping.
-
@grizzbear55_psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
I like everybody except x-wife. But this is a different type of forum and fans. We are passionate about baseball and we fight tooth and toenail in hopes that SDS stays true to who they are. Alot of us "Veteran fans" don't want to witness this franchise follow footsteps of other sports games that don't listen to fans.
While new ideas from other games are always a possibility i think majority want the game to be great regardless what mode you play. But we do have to be able to have civil discussions in order to reach that goal. I have read alot of your posts and can definitely see your passionate with your viewpoints.
I think it takes a big man to admit when they are wrong and takes a big man to forgive as well. Congrats on your nutsack finally dropping.
Now some lady is gonna grab em and do the ratatouille.
-
@ikasnu_psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
I like everybody except x-wife. But this is a different type of forum and fans. We are passionate about baseball and we fight tooth and toenail in hopes that SDS stays true to who they are. Alot of us "Veteran fans" don't want to witness this franchise follow footsteps of other sports games that don't listen to fans.
While new ideas from other games are always a possibility i think majority want the game to be great regardless what mode you play. But we do have to be able to have civil discussions in order to reach that goal. I have read alot of your posts and can definitely see your passionate with your viewpoints.
I think it takes a big man to admit when they are wrong and takes a big man to forgive as well. Congrats on your nutsack finally dropping.
Now some lady is gonna grab em and do the ratatouille.
Lol
-
I’m not sure they really did too much. On pitching it looks like it’s the same, they just showing you now the margin of error. Hitting doesn’t appear to have changed besides check swings. Fielding will probably be the biggest difference with added animations. Need new engine to do much more.
-
@sean_87__psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
I’m not sure they really did too much. On pitching it looks like it’s the same, they just showing you now the margin of error. Hitting doesn’t appear to have changed besides check swings. Fielding will probably be the biggest difference with added animations. Need new engine to do much more.
Did you play the beta? The hitting is much better with input being a huge deciding factor in what you get out of your hit. Breaking down the pitching and explaining why it was doing what it was doing was fairly huge though not changing the game so much. The main thing I liked about pitching is when I missed, it wasn't 100% a meatball. It was all over the place which is what should happen if you miss your spots really badly. I'm practicing the pitching in the beta every night trying to get better at it for the new game when it drops. I'd like to be really good at the pinpoint pitching on launch but it's getting me on some pitches.
-
@sean_87__psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
I’m not sure they really did too much. On pitching it looks like it’s the same, they just showing you now the margin of error. Hitting doesn’t appear to have changed besides check swings. Fielding will probably be the biggest difference with added animations. Need new engine to do much more.
Every year it feels like the fielding stream is the longest and that it has been revamped. Now that the OF being sucked into hugging the wall animation and the INFs and especially catchers are not lollygagging towards a weak grounder, the D is pretty good as is.
-
@sean_87__psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
I’m not sure they really did too much. On pitching it looks like it’s the same, they just showing you now the margin of error. Hitting doesn’t appear to have changed besides check swings. Fielding will probably be the biggest difference with added animations. Need new engine to do much more.
They def did a lot. The pitching was way better no forced misses down the middle well I had one but I REALLY missed so I kind of deserved it. But the hitting was way more fluid.
-
Yeah here's my image of MLB 21 becoming the best Show ever. Take out DD and online stuff, only Franchise...make the game more of a simulation instead of gimmicks like Perfect/Perfect. Put in Stride timing so it simulates a full follow through like actually swinging a bat, instead of aiming with a target and pressing X like playing a baseball game in the mid 90s. Take out the silly nooby instant homerun cam, I hate that S*^%. Add in about 10 more minor leagues and spring training stadiums. Make it default Legend hitting with pitch speeds at 10 so casual noobs are forced to get better. And put it on PC!!!
-
@joshjays44_psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
Yeah here's my image of MLB 21 becoming the best Show ever. Take out DD and online stuff, only Franchise...make the game more of a simulation instead of gimmicks like Perfect/Perfect. Put in Stride timing so it simulates a full follow through like actually swinging a bat, instead of aiming with a target and pressing X like playing a baseball game in the mid 90s. Take out the silly nooby instant homerun cam, I hate that S*^%. Add in about 10 more minor leagues and spring training stadiums. Make it default Legend hitting with pitch speeds at 10 so casual noobs are forced to get better. And put it on PC!!!
gotta have lower difficulties my friend, learning to hit at that level takes practice/experience.
people wouldn't actually learn to hit if forced to play at high difficulties because they'd never learn the basics.
but i agree with stride analog. if people want a true skill based baseball game than that's really the way to play but it's never gonna happen.
-
@veganmeatbawls said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@joshjays44_psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
Yeah here's my image of MLB 21 becoming the best Show ever. Take out DD and online stuff, only Franchise...make the game more of a simulation instead of gimmicks like Perfect/Perfect. Put in Stride timing so it simulates a full follow through like actually swinging a bat, instead of aiming with a target and pressing X like playing a baseball game in the mid 90s. Take out the silly nooby instant homerun cam, I hate that S*^%. Add in about 10 more minor leagues and spring training stadiums. Make it default Legend hitting with pitch speeds at 10 so casual noobs are forced to get better. And put it on PC!!!
gotta have lower difficulties my friend, learning to hit at that level takes practice/experience.
people wouldn't actually learn to hit if forced to play at high difficulties because they'd never learn the basics.
but i agree with stride analog. if people want a true skill based baseball game than that's really the way to play but it's never gonna happen.
Yeah I know, we live in a world of instant gratification.....casual noobs are the norms with sports gaming now...whatever happened to spending 100s of hours learning to get good at something? :). I mean my F1 2016 play time is approaching 500 hours and I still have lots to learn :).
-
@a_perfectgame said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
But I didn’t mean it that way. It was more so feeling like I had to defend my position with credibility.
@A_PerfectGame , I respect your opinions out here. Always "thought-provoking", and I appreciate your passion.
Also... I can't wait until April 16th...
-
@joshjays44_psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
Yeah here's my image of MLB 21 becoming the best Show ever. Take out DD and online stuff, only Franchise...make the game more of a simulation instead of gimmicks like Perfect/Perfect. Put in Stride timing so it simulates a full follow through like actually swinging a bat, instead of aiming with a target and pressing X like playing a baseball game in the mid 90s. Take out the silly nooby instant homerun cam, I hate that S*^%. Add in about 10 more minor leagues and spring training stadiums. Make it default Legend hitting with pitch speeds at 10 so casual noobs are forced to get better. And put it on PC!!!
If i am not mistaken pitching wasn't easy either. Only time you hit the button was to select pitch, you had to aim it while in the air with directional button if my cob webbed memory serves me right. Or you had to hold button while using directional?
-
Servers will be the issue like every year for the first few weeks. Especially with added players and cross platform
-
@officer-kirby_xbl said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
Servers will be the issue like every year for the first few weeks. Especially with added players and cross platform
I am expecting massive issues for launch server side. It's always a problem but this year could be setting up for disaster. I truly do hope I'm wrong though as this could be a great year for the show!!
-
Its got a chance after the bugs are fixed & the servers are fine tuned, then there will be the annual pitch speed debate that has become a right of spring on these forums.
Once thats all done it could be one of the best games SDS has made in a while.
-
@veganmeatbawls said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@joshjays44_psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
Yeah here's my image of MLB 21 becoming the best Show ever. Take out DD and online stuff, only Franchise...make the game more of a simulation instead of gimmicks like Perfect/Perfect. Put in Stride timing so it simulates a full follow through like actually swinging a bat, instead of aiming with a target and pressing X like playing a baseball game in the mid 90s. Take out the silly nooby instant homerun cam, I hate that S*^%. Add in about 10 more minor leagues and spring training stadiums. Make it default Legend hitting with pitch speeds at 10 so casual noobs are forced to get better. And put it on PC!!!
gotta have lower difficulties my friend, learning to hit at that level takes practice/experience.
people wouldn't actually learn to hit if forced to play at high difficulties because they'd never learn the basics.
but i agree with stride analog. if people want a true skill based baseball game than that's really the way to play but it's never gonna happen.
If you only do stride it takes away from user skill and adds too much RNG. That would be more of a simulation style game. If I had to learn stride plus analog I’d accept that as skill based — but not having to place the bat on the ball is too random. Because then we are basing everything off just timing and then from there where do you go? It has to go random.
Stride and directional are very similar interfaces
As are stride plus analog and zone.
-
@a_perfectgame said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@veganmeatbawls said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@joshjays44_psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
Yeah here's my image of MLB 21 becoming the best Show ever. Take out DD and online stuff, only Franchise...make the game more of a simulation instead of gimmicks like Perfect/Perfect. Put in Stride timing so it simulates a full follow through like actually swinging a bat, instead of aiming with a target and pressing X like playing a baseball game in the mid 90s. Take out the silly nooby instant homerun cam, I hate that S*^%. Add in about 10 more minor leagues and spring training stadiums. Make it default Legend hitting with pitch speeds at 10 so casual noobs are forced to get better. And put it on PC!!!
gotta have lower difficulties my friend, learning to hit at that level takes practice/experience.
people wouldn't actually learn to hit if forced to play at high difficulties because they'd never learn the basics.
but i agree with stride analog. if people want a true skill based baseball game than that's really the way to play but it's never gonna happen.
If you only do stride it takes away from user skill and adds too much RNG. That would be more of a simulation style game. If I had to learn stride plus analog I’d accept that as skill based — but not having to place the bat on the ball is too random. Because then we are basing everything off just timing and then from there where do you go? It has to go random.
Stride and directional are very similar interfaces
As are stride plus analog and zone.
LOL. this drives me nuts. no offense to you but I am talking about zone plus analog with the stride.
That is: you still have to place your PCI on the ball with the left stick while using the stride with the right analog stick. It's the most skill based hitting interface which hardly anyone uses. -
@veganmeatbawls said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@a_perfectgame said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@veganmeatbawls said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@joshjays44_psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
Yeah here's my image of MLB 21 becoming the best Show ever. Take out DD and online stuff, only Franchise...make the game more of a simulation instead of gimmicks like Perfect/Perfect. Put in Stride timing so it simulates a full follow through like actually swinging a bat, instead of aiming with a target and pressing X like playing a baseball game in the mid 90s. Take out the silly nooby instant homerun cam, I hate that S*^%. Add in about 10 more minor leagues and spring training stadiums. Make it default Legend hitting with pitch speeds at 10 so casual noobs are forced to get better. And put it on PC!!!
gotta have lower difficulties my friend, learning to hit at that level takes practice/experience.
people wouldn't actually learn to hit if forced to play at high difficulties because they'd never learn the basics.
but i agree with stride analog. if people want a true skill based baseball game than that's really the way to play but it's never gonna happen.
If you only do stride it takes away from user skill and adds too much RNG. That would be more of a simulation style game. If I had to learn stride plus analog I’d accept that as skill based — but not having to place the bat on the ball is too random. Because then we are basing everything off just timing and then from there where do you go? It has to go random.
Stride and directional are very similar interfaces
As are stride plus analog and zone.
LOL. this drives me nuts. no offense to you but I am talking about zone plus analog with the stride.
That is: you still have to place your PCI on the ball with the left stick while using the stride with the right analog stick. It's the most skill based hitting interface which hardly anyone uses.I just said it’s skill based. Regular stride isn’t. Regular stride is as skill based as directional
I find pure analog slightly easier to not jam pci a certain way so that’s cool. I just prefer zone
-
@a_perfectgame said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@veganmeatbawls said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@a_perfectgame said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@veganmeatbawls said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
@joshjays44_psn said in Mlb 21 greatest baseball game of alltime potential:
Yeah here's my image of MLB 21 becoming the best Show ever. Take out DD and online stuff, only Franchise...make the game more of a simulation instead of gimmicks like Perfect/Perfect. Put in Stride timing so it simulates a full follow through like actually swinging a bat, instead of aiming with a target and pressing X like playing a baseball game in the mid 90s. Take out the silly nooby instant homerun cam, I hate that S*^%. Add in about 10 more minor leagues and spring training stadiums. Make it default Legend hitting with pitch speeds at 10 so casual noobs are forced to get better. And put it on PC!!!
gotta have lower difficulties my friend, learning to hit at that level takes practice/experience.
people wouldn't actually learn to hit if forced to play at high difficulties because they'd never learn the basics.
but i agree with stride analog. if people want a true skill based baseball game than that's really the way to play but it's never gonna happen.
If you only do stride it takes away from user skill and adds too much RNG. That would be more of a simulation style game. If I had to learn stride plus analog I’d accept that as skill based — but not having to place the bat on the ball is too random. Because then we are basing everything off just timing and then from there where do you go? It has to go random.
Stride and directional are very similar interfaces
As are stride plus analog and zone.
LOL. this drives me nuts. no offense to you but I am talking about zone plus analog with the stride.
That is: you still have to place your PCI on the ball with the left stick while using the stride with the right analog stick. It's the most skill based hitting interface which hardly anyone uses.I just said it’s skill based. Regular stride isn’t. Regular stride is as skill based as directional
I find pure analog slightly easier to not jam pci a certain way so that’s cool. I just prefer zone
YOU ACTUALLY DON'T GET IT. this is unbelievable.
zone plus analog is when you use the left stick. THE LEFT STICK as your PCI.
You use the Right Stick. RIGHT stick as the stride and swing.
YOU USE BOTH SIMULTANEOUSLY.
It's the most skill based hitting interface the game offers but no one uses it because no one even knows it exists as proven by your posts.
i'm shocked. i truly am.
