Game 7 of WS, series tied 3-3, who is your SP?
-
Chris Carpenter or Jose Fernandez
-
Bob_Loblaw1984wrote on Oct 15, 2020, 1:19 AM last edited by Bob_Loblaw1984_PSN Oct 15, 2020, 1:24 AM
From what I remember Maddux and Glavine were worse than Smoltz in the playoffs.
I’d give it to Koufax, Gibson, or Doc Gooden.
-
Bumgarner or Randy and im feeling pretty good
-
The correct answer is probably Bob Gibson or Sandy Koufax.
Under the radar choices are Smoltz, El Duque, or Dave Stewart.
-
@allmustfall16 said in Game 7 of WS, series tied 3-3, who is your SP?:
All-time : Greg Maddux in his dominant years.
not in playoff time. I'd pick glavine or smoltz before him.
-
Duplicate
-
Hubijerkreplied to Guest on Oct 15, 2020, 2:52 AM last edited by Hubijerk_PSN Oct 15, 2020, 2:54 AM
@Hubijerk said in Game 7 of WS, series tied 3-3, who is your SP?:
Randy Johnson or Pedro in their prime. Not only were their numbers outstanding but they were just intimidating and nasty. Plus they pitched in a time when everyone was juiced to the [censored]'s, even the hot dog guy was on the sauce.
-
You give it to the greatest that ever threw a baseball and his name is Sandy Koufax!
-
2014 Madison Bumgarner
-
Mis_Ter_Bulldopswrote on Oct 15, 2020, 11:34 AM last edited by Mis_Ter_Bulldops_PSN Oct 15, 2020, 11:42 AM
Pedro Martinez. As long he's not facing the Yankees. There's actually a handful of pitchers that I would trust. But once again as long as they're not face in the Yankees in the playoffs.
And I hate the Yankees....But usually all good pitchers don't fare well...... in the post season
-
Can I over think it and use a opener.
-
Put in Pedro, work your way through the 3rd, then get in Maddux to the 6th, then bumgarner 6-8, the big unit closing everything out
-
I would consider: Bumgarner, Maddux, Gibson.
-
1 - Pedro Martinez
2 - Greg Maddux (Expos fan here, this is painful to admit)
3 - Fernando Valenzuela
4 - Nolan Ryan
5 - Steve Rodgers (dark horse, I know) -
Pat Venditte...The other team would see him stroll out to the mound with lefty & righty gloves...Game over
-
BodamEscapePlanwrote on Oct 15, 2020, 4:39 PM last edited by BodamEscapePlan_PSN Oct 15, 2020, 4:49 PM
I'm going to assume you mean in the actual game, The Show 20:
Greg Maddux (Signature Series) or Orel Hershiser (TA3 - FOTF)
In real-life? It's too tough to narrow it down to just one.
Bob Gibson, Andy Pettitte, Mark Buehrle, David Cone, Roy Halladay.
As for guys still playing? Give me Lucas Giolito in a pressure situation just about every time. The man has proven that he can handle the big game. I just hope he gets to pitch in a World Series soon. Honorable mention to Jacob deGrom.
-
@BodamEscapePlan said in Game 7 of WS, series tied 3-3, who is your SP?:
I'm going to assume you mean in the actual game, The Show 20:
Greg Maddux (Signature Series) or Orel Hershiser (TA3 - FOTF)
Why would you assume that since there is no game 7 in the game?
Anyhow, the real answer is Orel Hershiser
-
If it was live players in a real game I’d take degrom or Bauer. On the game I’m taking hershiser
-
@Nanos_McGregor said in Game 7 of WS, series tied 3-3, who is your SP?:
Chris Carpenter or Jose Fernandez
You beat me to it. My favorite game of all time was the 1-0 Cards/Phillies classic!
-
I gotta agree that Gibson or Koufax likely get the nod, but honorable mentions to Satchel Paige, Randy Johnson and Greg maddux. Also, I’m definitely bringing Mo out to close here
23/37