Your MVP, Cy Young, Reliever of the Year

[txbizman_PSN]

MVP: Rollins
CY: Randy Johnson - perfect game card, but there were a lot of good pitchers. Wood is great as well.
CP: Too many to narrow it down. I trusted Chapman, Wagner, Gagne, my cap, Helsley, etc.
Good surprises: Foxx and Freeman
Honorable mention: Ruth, Mantle, George Brett, J-Ram
Disappointment: All catchers not named Jorge Posada

[SaveFarris_PSN]

MVP: Brett, FotF Seager, Lightning Mook, Anime Foxx
CY: Sig Randy, MS Nolan (shocker!)
Rolaids Reliever: Helsley … any of ‘em
Surprise: Clemente … both of ‘em
Dispointment: all the Sizzling Summer cards (Honus, Piazza, Musial, Fingers)

[SchnauzerFace_MLBTS]

MVP: Brooks Robinson, Yoelqui, and Griffey
Cy Young: Finest Cease, Walter Johnson, Lefty Grove
Reliever: Goose, Wagner, Gagne

Disappointment: I hate to say it, but I didn’t hit with Carew this year. Usually one of my favorite cards. But….

Surprise: … Joe Morgan is my new favorite left-handed 2B.

[jesstradamis_PSN]

Mvp = Trout
Cy young = kershaw
Cp = Hoffman

[RazorForte45_XBL]

Mvp - early Reward K Gibson. / late Rollins

Pitcher - all star tom seaver / late Milestone Randy. (Cheat code)

Reliever - Finest Sutter.

Disappointment - Playoff Trea Turner. Ugh… I wanted this to work.

Surprise - 99 E Martinez - best PH by far!!

Great thread BTW…

[TheGoaler_PSN]

Early MVP: Ely de la Cruz/ Milestone Longoria. Late: Retro Brett/Cutch
Cy Young: Retro Leiter, MA Zac Gallen. Was a great hitter as well!
Reliever: Takashi Wagner
Disappointment: Babe Ruth AGAIN, but his Gold card was good, which is weird. Also, Awards Frank Thomas. I don't see what many saw in him!

[Ericulous1_PSN]

These are my favorite types of threads. Thanks.

MVP- Andrew McCutchen- Retro Finest.
Runner up- Albert Pujols- Milestone

Cy Young- Corbin Burnes- Finest
Runner Up- Randy Johnson- Both

Reliever- Billy Wagner- Takashi
Runner Up- Ryan Helsley- ASG

Surprise- Hunter Renfroe - Finest
Gary Carter- 2nd Half and Retro Finest

Disappointment- the lack of Team Affinity. I mean…. Frank Thomas and Mike Piazza

[Ericulous1_PSN]

@SchnauzerFace_MLBTS said in Your MVP, Cy Young, Reliever of the Year:

MVP: Brooks Robinson, Yoelqui, and Griffey
Cy Young: Finest Cease, Walter Johnson, Lefty Grove
Reliever: Goose, Wagner, Gagne

Disappointment: I hate to say it, but I didn’t hit with Carew this year. Usually one of my favorite cards. But….

Surprise: … Joe Morgan is my new favorite left-handed 2B.

Yeah, his swing is amazing. I loved Cano and Utley too but Morgan was my favorite.

[arvcpa_MLBTS]

Keep in mind that almost all of my games are played at the All-Star level. These favorites were a surprise to me, if I base these awards simply off of stats and not "feel".

SP: Online - Takashi Mussina
CP: Online - Breakout Andrew Miller
Position: Online - Finest McCutchen (I would have sworn I would have put a switch hitter here)

SP: Offline - FotF Stroman
CP: Offline - Finest Chapman
Position: Offline - Takashi Foxx. The only player with over 100 ABs where I hit over .500. No one else comes close. I have no idea why, as I haven't hit well with him in past years.

[TEXAS10PT_PSN]

MVP....No doubt George Brett

Cy Young....Nolan Ryan

Closer....Billy Wagner

Surprises...99 Austin Riley-Card rakes
99 700 HR Pujols

Biggest Disappointment....He is still at P5 but Willie Mays got shat on this year

[worm91_NSW]

Interesting topic.
Keep in mind almost all my games are offline and mix of Rookie, Veteran and some All Star when I need it for a mission. And when I P5 a player I pretty much put him away and try other cards.
MVP: Early-MA Devers Now-Takashi Griffey
Cy Young: Finest Zack Greinke though MA Zac Gallen was more dominant for me. I reached P5 with him so quickly he did not accumulate the stats compared to Greinke
Rolaids Relief: I could pick Finest Sutter or Takashi Wagner. They are just about a tie in stats as well as my feeling for who was most effective

Biggest surprise. When I started the game, pretty early on I acquired a rather modest Topps Now 90 OVR Josh Rojas and back when I was still learning hitting I raked with him. It seemed like he hit a home run every swing; it was almost comical. I eventually put him away for MA Devers, but it killed me to do it. Looking back, I still don't know why he hit so well for me.

Biggest disappointment. Other than me not improving my hitting over the course of the year as much as I wanted, I would say it is the glut of amazing players at certain positions. Early on my best hitters were TN Rojas, MA Devers, and MA Austin Riley and they were all 3B so I had to be creative to keep them in my lineup. Now my outfield is so stacked with players I hit well with I cannot put all my best hitters in the lineup.

[Misfits_138_1_PSN]

@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in Your MVP, Cy Young, Reliever of the Year:

MVP....No doubt George Brett

Cy Young....Nolan Ryan

Closer....Billy Wagner

Surprises...99 Austin Riley-Card rakes
99 700 HR Pujols

Biggest Disappointment....He is still at P5 but Willie Mays got shat on this year

Great point about Mays.
You can make a very valid argument that he is the GOAT-- 600+ HR's, speed, great glove.
They finally did Kaline right.
Now give Mays his due.

[YOSHI24_MLBTS]

MVP: George Brett
Cy Young: Kershaw
Reliever: 90 Chapman (in my bullpen since day 1)

[virusts_XBL]

1st half of Season (No 99's)
MVP: Rafael Devers FOTF
Cy Young: Randy Johnson Takashi
Special Mention Cy Young: Common Aaron Slegers with his small head and giant body. Best pitcher in moonshot events
Reliever: Topps Now Duran

2nd Half
MVP: Hank Aaron (Most of stats were on Ranked Seasons on HOF or a couple game on Legend) Other players stats were inflated because of Events with many hitters batter .450 or higher.
Cy Young. Randy Johnson Milestone
Reliever: Finest Duran

Surprise of the year:
Batting: FOTF Mitch Haniger and Finest Don Mattingly
Pitching: FOTF Casey Mize and Topps Now Bumgarner

Disappointment:
Batting: I still can't hit with a Mookie Betts card....
Pitching: Finest Bob Gibson. I got his 90 card P5, but have his FInest card with a ERA above the 10's

[pfcorporate_PSN]

Mvp Foxx
Cy. Either randy version
Reliever. Surprisingly I would go with Joe Nathan. Didn’t expect much.

Surprise Jose Ramirez. Normally don’t do much with his cards but this year has been a beast.

Disappointment probably trea turner. I usually do better with his cards.

[worm91_NSW]

After going back to Mini Seasons over the weekend I want to change my Biggest Disappointment. I was cruelly reminded of hearing Chris Singleton nonstop say "Man, that is one of those at bats where you have to reminded yourself it's about the process" is definitely the biggest disappointment in the game all year.

[Ryan92780_MLBTS]

Swisher, DeGrom, Mariano

[CookieMonster64_NSW]

MVP: MA Matt Carpenter - This dude hit around .420 for me basically ever since I got him and he's been my 6 hole hitter for what feels like forever.

Cy Young: FOTF Bobby Miller - Though he is a little outdated; in his heyday he was awesome. Work a lot of splitter/slider then come back with a fastball and they aren't gonna touch that.

Reliever: Topps Now Jhoan Duran - Back when I almost never saw this guy he was nasty, but now that everyone uses his finest everyone can read him easily.

Disappointment (kinda) - Clemente - I never hit well with this guy so its not really much of a disappointment but I hit .130 so...

Suprise: Brandon Marsh - There was no way he was getting a 99 but his swing is just sexy.

[Bubba-j1130_PSN]

MVP: finest Miggy. Can’t tell you the number of game winning homers (events and ranked) he has hit for me.
Cy: Kershaw
CP: Rollie Fingers

[skywalker_25_PSN]

MVP:

1. Jorge Polanco
2. Bryan Reynolds
3. Ken Griffey Jr.

Cy Young:

1. Kerry Wood
2. Randy Johnson
3. Sandy Alcantara

Reliever:

1. Eric Gagne
2. Jhoan Duran
3. Gregory Soto

Surprise:

1. 93 Ketel Marte
2. 96 Elly De La Cruz
3. 97 Chase Utley

Disappointment:

1. 96 Joe Mauer
2. Trea Turner
3. Orel Hershiser