Wish I saw these players in the game.
-
Top 2 guys on my wishlist:
David Wright
Johan Santana -
Top 10:
Josh Gibson, Frank Robinson, Sandy Koufax, Tim Raines, Pete Rose, Kevin Brown, Lou Whitaker, Roy Campanella, Doc Gooden, Thurman Munson.
-
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Top 10:
Josh Gibson, Frank Robinson, Sandy Koufax, Tim Raines, Pete Rose, Kevin Brown, Lou Whitaker, Roy Campanella, Doc Gooden, Thurman Munson.
Would love to see a 99 Doc Gooden card
-
@TheNinjaRaven_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Top 10:
Josh Gibson, Frank Robinson, Sandy Koufax, Tim Raines, Pete Rose, Kevin Brown, Lou Whitaker, Roy Campanella, Doc Gooden, Thurman Munson.
Would love to see a 99 Doc Gooden card
@TheNinjaRaven_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Top 10:
Josh Gibson, Frank Robinson, Sandy Koufax, Tim Raines, Pete Rose, Kevin Brown, Lou Whitaker, Roy Campanella, Doc Gooden, Thurman Munson.
Would love to see a 99 Doc Gooden card
That would be a fantastic card. I also wouldn't mind a Daryl Strawberry card.
Top wishlist:
Roger Hornsby (I know he use to be in the game), Josh Gibson, Doc Gooden, Roger Clemens, Sandy Koufax, Maury Wills, Scott Rolen and of course Barry. -
@Ericulous1_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@TheNinjaRaven_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Top 10:
Josh Gibson, Frank Robinson, Sandy Koufax, Tim Raines, Pete Rose, Kevin Brown, Lou Whitaker, Roy Campanella, Doc Gooden, Thurman Munson.
Would love to see a 99 Doc Gooden card
@TheNinjaRaven_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Top 10:
Josh Gibson, Frank Robinson, Sandy Koufax, Tim Raines, Pete Rose, Kevin Brown, Lou Whitaker, Roy Campanella, Doc Gooden, Thurman Munson.
Would love to see a 99 Doc Gooden card
That would be a fantastic card. I also wouldn't mind a Daryl Strawberry card.
Top wishlist:
Roger Hornsby (I know he use to be in the game), Josh Gibson, Doc Gooden, Roger Clemens, Sandy Koufax, Maury Wills, Scott Rolen and of course Barry.One of Clemens cards needs to be him throwing the bat at Piazza.
-
@Kovz88_MLBTS said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@TheNinjaRaven_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Top 10:
Josh Gibson, Frank Robinson, Sandy Koufax, Tim Raines, Pete Rose, Kevin Brown, Lou Whitaker, Roy Campanella, Doc Gooden, Thurman Munson.
Would love to see a 99 Doc Gooden card
@TheNinjaRaven_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Top 10:
Josh Gibson, Frank Robinson, Sandy Koufax, Tim Raines, Pete Rose, Kevin Brown, Lou Whitaker, Roy Campanella, Doc Gooden, Thurman Munson.
Would love to see a 99 Doc Gooden card
That would be a fantastic card. I also wouldn't mind a Daryl Strawberry card.
Top wishlist:
Roger Hornsby (I know he use to be in the game), Josh Gibson, Doc Gooden, Roger Clemens, Sandy Koufax, Maury Wills, Scott Rolen and of course Barry.One of Clemens cards needs to be him throwing the bat at Piazza.
Clemens was a steriod user so not sure he'd make the game.
-
@Kovz88_MLBTS said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Not trying to hate on the guy, he was a great clutch player and very consistent but never the best at anything. They have made fantasy cards for worse players to make them 99 so I'm not saying it won't happen one day, it just wouldn't be a realistic card.
This horrible take gets old but get it in while you can. When Jeter is finally in the game he will be a 99 overall. And he will be one one of the better ones. 99 SS 99 MVP 99 3000 hit club 99 1200 rbi club 99 5x GG, literally take your pick it doesn’t matter.
-
@DeleteyourTTVBTW_MLBTS said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@Kovz88_MLBTS said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Not trying to hate on the guy, he was a great clutch player and very consistent but never the best at anything. They have made fantasy cards for worse players to make them 99 so I'm not saying it won't happen one day, it just wouldn't be a realistic card.
This horrible take gets old but get it in while you can. When Jeter is finally in the game he will be a 99 overall. And he will be one one of the better ones. 99 SS 99 MVP 99 3000 hit club 99 1200 rbi club 99 5x GG, literally take your pick it doesn’t matter.
I have to agree. Yes, its documented that he was not the greatest defensive ss, but he brought allot to the table. I feel that that they will give him his props when his card ever comes out.
-
@TheNinjaRaven_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
They can manipulate numbers lol..they just have to go by his best year..1999 .349 avg and 24 homers 102 rbis 19 sb...
Yeah, seeing as how they just released cards for Jackie and Mazeroski with each having mid/high 80s power - despite both guys never hitting more than 19 home runs in a single season - you can see how they would be able to finagle the stats.
There are 99 overall cards of widely unknown minor leaguers who might not even make a dent in the majors so I'm not sure why people would suddenly be so offended if Jeter ever got a 99.
-
Nintendo switch did leak a derek jeter thing at the beginning of the year and the tweet was taken down so I could see it being a big collection but Cutch was a big L for the amount of stubs it takes to get him. Would love to see a Koufax card
-
You have 3 or 4 guys on there that could never have a 99 no matter how inflated. Paul O Neil? lol.
-
@DeleteyourTTVBTW_MLBTS said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@Kovz88_MLBTS said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Not trying to hate on the guy, he was a great clutch player and very consistent but never the best at anything. They have made fantasy cards for worse players to make them 99 so I'm not saying it won't happen one day, it just wouldn't be a realistic card.
This horrible take gets old but get it in while you can. When Jeter is finally in the game he will be a 99 overall. And he will be one one of the better ones. 99 SS 99 MVP 99 3000 hit club 99 1200 rbi club 99 5x GG, literally take your pick it doesn’t matter.
Horrible take? What year was Jeter the best SS in the league? Like I said, guy was a great player, deserves all the praise in the world but as far as how good people make him out to be you could argue he is the most overrated player in baseball history. Not because he was bad but because you would think the guy won 10 batting titles, lead the league in HRs every year and never made an error with the way people talk about him.
-
@Boneman05_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Nintendo switch did leak a derek jeter thing at the beginning of the year and the tweet was taken down so I could see it being a big collection but Cutch was a big L for the amount of stubs it takes to get him. Would love to see a Koufax card
That wasn't a leak. It was a photoshop.
-
@chuckclc_MLBTS said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
You have 3 or 4 guys on there that could never have a 99 no matter how inflated. Paul O Neil? lol.
You can make a case for anybody really, but Paul O'Neill isn't the biggest stretch. A Signature Series based on 1994 when he won the batting crown by hitting .359 or Retro Finest based on his stretch from 1995-99 when he averaged .300+ AVG/20+ HR/100+ RBI with nearly a .400 OBP. He also played a solid right field and although he was slow the guy had an absolute cannon.
Not a stretch at all especially when immortals such as Jordan Walker have a 99 overall.
-
@SakAttack87_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@chuckclc_MLBTS said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
You have 3 or 4 guys on there that could never have a 99 no matter how inflated. Paul O Neil? lol.
You can make a case for anybody really, but Paul O'Neill isn't the biggest stretch. A Signature Series based on 1994 when he won the batting crown by hitting .359 or Retro Finest based on his stretch from 1995-99 when he averaged .300+ AVG/20+ HR/100+ RBI with nearly a .400 OBP. He also played a solid right field and although he was slow the guy had an absolute cannon.
Not a stretch at all especially when immortals such as Jordan Walker have a 99 overall.
I guess that is true. And a 99 Mussina.
-
@the_dragon1912 said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
75 Michael Jordan maybe. Say what you want about how future stars but all of them still have had better minor league careers than Jordan did
Would be good for BR
-
@TheNinjaRaven_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
@Kovz88_MLBTS said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Derek Jeter and Michael Jordan would be pretty tough to make 99s unless they are just complete fantasy cards. It would be fun to see them make a high gold/low diamond series for multi sport guys. Deion Sanders, I saw someone mention a while ago the idea of a FS/ prospect Kyler Murray etc.
How would a 99 Jeter be fantasy?
Idiot
-
Give me Koufax, Steve Sax ( I know I’m the only guy who wants him), and Lincecum.
-
@OreoRockstar_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
Give me Koufax, Steve Sax ( I know I’m the only guy who wants him), and Lincecum.
I'll second Sax along with Garvey, Guerrero, and Dusty.
-
@TheNinjaRaven_PSN said in Wish I saw these players in the game.:
They can manipulate numbers lol..they just have to go by his best year..1999 .349 avg and 24 homers 102 rbis 19 sb...
That was 1999. Damien Easley, Rich Aurelia, and Ed Taubenese (WHO?!?) hit 20+ homers that year. Jeter’s statistically best seasons were when EVERYONE was having their best seasons.
Jeters best skill was his ability to stay in the lineup and compile stats. Nothing wrong with that. A lot of players made it to the Hall using precisely that skill (looking at you, Harold Baines). But let’s not pretend he was anything more than a slightly above average player that just happened to play for the right team at the right time.
-
A admin locked this topic on
