You R2 holders
-
@buddyhightower_xbl said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@buddyhightower_xbl said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@tear4eddy_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@kovz88_psn said in You R2 holders:
5 second timer between pitches seems a bit excessive. Also not everyone wants to sit there and take over an hour for a game so try to understand why people try not to take long between pitches? You can't ask people to try and understand your side without extending the same courtesy
Then live with R2 holding. I’m not going to let someone throw 10 pitches in 3 seconds like it’s a machine gun. If you don’t want a timer, R2 is the best way to make both sides happy.
What exactly is wrong with a pitcher working quickly and how is that anything but a good thing? I use R2 a bit because there’s some useful info there, but once you’ve gathered that info, let’s play the [censored] game. It’s not like you’re a real hitter in an actual MLB game. What are you possibly doing with that extra time when you’re holding R2?
Exactly and in a real game the pitcher does not have to wait for a hitter to be ready. They can quick pitch all the want as long as the batter is in the box and ump is ready.
Then allow me to stand outside the batter box like in real life.
press down on the pad it calls timeout like in real life
Give me the ability to do it with every pitch just like you have the ability to quick pitch with every pitch.
You should already be ready to hit. When pitcher is ready to pitch that is the bottom line it is baseball, It is a video game. There is no need to hold R2 to the fullest time every pitch of the game. I am bad a hitting in this game but I am good enough this year to be above 500. You must be really bad at hitting if you have to hold R2 using directional. At least those who use analog explained why they do it. You have no excuse except you are not ready to hit.
No your wrong, it’s when the batter is ready in real life, not the pitcher. You really ended your argument with your ignorance on that one.
Do you watch baseball, The pitcher pitches when ump is ready, The batter has to call time and even if batter calls time the ump does not have to grant. The pitcher controls the tempo of the game.If the batter is in the box and not ready the pitcher can pitch the ball. the batter does not have to be ready for a pitcher to pitch.
The official rule says the batter has to be ready.
They have to be in the box not actually have to be ready, The ump is ready the pitcher ready then the pitcher can pitch, some batter are in the box but not actually ready and the ump will call the pitch.
Rule 8.05(e) Comment: A quick pitch is an illegal pitch. Umpires will judge a quick pitch as one delivered before the batter is reasonably set in the batter's box. With runners on base the penalty is a balk; with no runners on base, it is a ball. The quick pitch is dangerous and should not be permitted.
How many times have you seen this rule actually be called.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@buddyhightower_xbl said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@buddyhightower_xbl said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@tear4eddy_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@kovz88_psn said in You R2 holders:
5 second timer between pitches seems a bit excessive. Also not everyone wants to sit there and take over an hour for a game so try to understand why people try not to take long between pitches? You can't ask people to try and understand your side without extending the same courtesy
Then live with R2 holding. I’m not going to let someone throw 10 pitches in 3 seconds like it’s a machine gun. If you don’t want a timer, R2 is the best way to make both sides happy.
What exactly is wrong with a pitcher working quickly and how is that anything but a good thing? I use R2 a bit because there’s some useful info there, but once you’ve gathered that info, let’s play the [censored] game. It’s not like you’re a real hitter in an actual MLB game. What are you possibly doing with that extra time when you’re holding R2?
Exactly and in a real game the pitcher does not have to wait for a hitter to be ready. They can quick pitch all the want as long as the batter is in the box and ump is ready.
Then allow me to stand outside the batter box like in real life.
press down on the pad it calls timeout like in real life
Give me the ability to do it with every pitch just like you have the ability to quick pitch with every pitch.
You should already be ready to hit. When pitcher is ready to pitch that is the bottom line it is baseball, It is a video game. There is no need to hold R2 to the fullest time every pitch of the game. I am bad a hitting in this game but I am good enough this year to be above 500. You must be really bad at hitting if you have to hold R2 using directional. At least those who use analog explained why they do it. You have no excuse except you are not ready to hit.
No your wrong, it’s when the batter is ready in real life, not the pitcher. You really ended your argument with your ignorance on that one.
Do you watch baseball, The pitcher pitches when ump is ready, The batter has to call time and even if batter calls time the ump does not have to grant. The pitcher controls the tempo of the game.If the batter is in the box and not ready the pitcher can pitch the ball. the batter does not have to be ready for a pitcher to pitch.
The official rule says the batter has to be ready.
They have to be in the box not actually have to be ready, The ump is ready the pitcher ready then the pitcher can pitch, some batter are in the box but not actually ready and the ump will call the pitch.
Rule 8.05(e) Comment: A quick pitch is an illegal pitch. Umpires will judge a quick pitch as one delivered before the batter is reasonably set in the batter's box. With runners on base the penalty is a balk; with no runners on base, it is a ball. The quick pitch is dangerous and should not be permitted.
You left out the part that that rule is in place only for the safety of the hitters.
No, it's there. I don't have an opinion on the R2 debate. I pitch slow, and if someone starts fast pitching too much, I might hit pause on them. After all, that's what I want them to do, pause.
-
If you want this game to be played like MLB then each game should take at least 3 hours to play. This is a Video game. You should be ready to hit and if you are not ready to hit then why even play the game. When I pitch I select my pitch select location takes less then 2 seconds and then still have to wind up to pitch. If you can not be ready in that amount of time and have to hold R2 that just sad. If you push R2 for other information and not doing it every pitch of every battter then no need to discuss this topic. This is for those who do it to the full amount of time for every pitch to every batter.
-
@mjfc_363_psn said in You R2 holders:
So can you step off the rubber an unlimited amount of times now? Im 110% positive there used to be a limit of how many times a pitcher was allowed to step off the rubber. In regard to quick pitching, I have absolutely no problem with that. If I’m in the box and haven’t called time.....then it’s on me! What I don’t appreciate for example, is when my pitcher is up and my opponent knows I’m gonna pinch hit and they smash a button and don’t give me an opportunity to pinch hit. This really happens and it’s not cuz I’m slow. I’m also smashing the pause button to try and get my hitter in the game. In regard to using R2 to “see where I’m being pitched”? I’m a former WS player and consistently over 700. I’m not great but I’m not terrible. I have NEVER ONCE in 5 years of playing this game used R2 to see where I’m being pitched. If you don’t know where you’re being pitched just pack up and quit! Find another game.
When do we see the thread for runners taking extra lead and pitcher stepping off mound repeatedly to counter?
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
If you want this game to be played like MLB then each game should take at least 3 hours to play. This is a Video game. You should be ready to hit and if you are not ready to hit then why even play the game. When I pitch I select my pitch select location takes less then 2 seconds and then still have to wind up to pitch. If you can not be ready in that amount of time and have to hold R2 that just sad. If you push R2 for other information and not doing it every pitch of every battter then no need to discuss this topic. This is for those who do it to the full amount of time for every pitch to every batter.
Maybe I need to pick my controller back up after throwing it through the TV? lol
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@buddyhightower_xbl said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@buddyhightower_xbl said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@tear4eddy_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@kovz88_psn said in You R2 holders:
5 second timer between pitches seems a bit excessive. Also not everyone wants to sit there and take over an hour for a game so try to understand why people try not to take long between pitches? You can't ask people to try and understand your side without extending the same courtesy
Then live with R2 holding. I’m not going to let someone throw 10 pitches in 3 seconds like it’s a machine gun. If you don’t want a timer, R2 is the best way to make both sides happy.
What exactly is wrong with a pitcher working quickly and how is that anything but a good thing? I use R2 a bit because there’s some useful info there, but once you’ve gathered that info, let’s play the [censored] game. It’s not like you’re a real hitter in an actual MLB game. What are you possibly doing with that extra time when you’re holding R2?
Exactly and in a real game the pitcher does not have to wait for a hitter to be ready. They can quick pitch all the want as long as the batter is in the box and ump is ready.
Then allow me to stand outside the batter box like in real life.
press down on the pad it calls timeout like in real life
Give me the ability to do it with every pitch just like you have the ability to quick pitch with every pitch.
You should already be ready to hit. When pitcher is ready to pitch that is the bottom line it is baseball, It is a video game. There is no need to hold R2 to the fullest time every pitch of the game. I am bad a hitting in this game but I am good enough this year to be above 500. You must be really bad at hitting if you have to hold R2 using directional. At least those who use analog explained why they do it. You have no excuse except you are not ready to hit.
No your wrong, it’s when the batter is ready in real life, not the pitcher. You really ended your argument with your ignorance on that one.
Do you watch baseball, The pitcher pitches when ump is ready, The batter has to call time and even if batter calls time the ump does not have to grant. The pitcher controls the tempo of the game.If the batter is in the box and not ready the pitcher can pitch the ball. the batter does not have to be ready for a pitcher to pitch.
The official rule says the batter has to be ready.
They have to be in the box not actually have to be ready, The ump is ready the pitcher ready then the pitcher can pitch, some batter are in the box but not actually ready and the ump will call the pitch.
Rule 8.05(e) Comment: A quick pitch is an illegal pitch. Umpires will judge a quick pitch as one delivered before the batter is reasonably set in the batter's box. With runners on base the penalty is a balk; with no runners on base, it is a ball. The quick pitch is dangerous and should not be permitted.
How many times have you seen this rule actually be called.
Balks are a rule too and should be in the game
-
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@buddyhightower_xbl said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@buddyhightower_xbl said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@tear4eddy_psn said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@kovz88_psn said in You R2 holders:
5 second timer between pitches seems a bit excessive. Also not everyone wants to sit there and take over an hour for a game so try to understand why people try not to take long between pitches? You can't ask people to try and understand your side without extending the same courtesy
Then live with R2 holding. I’m not going to let someone throw 10 pitches in 3 seconds like it’s a machine gun. If you don’t want a timer, R2 is the best way to make both sides happy.
What exactly is wrong with a pitcher working quickly and how is that anything but a good thing? I use R2 a bit because there’s some useful info there, but once you’ve gathered that info, let’s play the [censored] game. It’s not like you’re a real hitter in an actual MLB game. What are you possibly doing with that extra time when you’re holding R2?
Exactly and in a real game the pitcher does not have to wait for a hitter to be ready. They can quick pitch all the want as long as the batter is in the box and ump is ready.
Then allow me to stand outside the batter box like in real life.
press down on the pad it calls timeout like in real life
Give me the ability to do it with every pitch just like you have the ability to quick pitch with every pitch.
You should already be ready to hit. When pitcher is ready to pitch that is the bottom line it is baseball, It is a video game. There is no need to hold R2 to the fullest time every pitch of the game. I am bad a hitting in this game but I am good enough this year to be above 500. You must be really bad at hitting if you have to hold R2 using directional. At least those who use analog explained why they do it. You have no excuse except you are not ready to hit.
No your wrong, it’s when the batter is ready in real life, not the pitcher. You really ended your argument with your ignorance on that one.
Do you watch baseball, The pitcher pitches when ump is ready, The batter has to call time and even if batter calls time the ump does not have to grant. The pitcher controls the tempo of the game.If the batter is in the box and not ready the pitcher can pitch the ball. the batter does not have to be ready for a pitcher to pitch.
The official rule says the batter has to be ready.
They have to be in the box not actually have to be ready, The ump is ready the pitcher ready then the pitcher can pitch, some batter are in the box but not actually ready and the ump will call the pitch.
Rule 8.05(e) Comment: A quick pitch is an illegal pitch. Umpires will judge a quick pitch as one delivered before the batter is reasonably set in the batter's box. With runners on base the penalty is a balk; with no runners on base, it is a ball. The quick pitch is dangerous and should not be permitted.
How many times have you seen this rule actually be called.
Balks are a rule too and should be in the game
Amen all these pitchers never coming set lol
-
@kovz88_psn said in You R2 holders:
I dont spam it but I do use it at the beginning of every at bat on the 2nd/3rd time through the lineup to see the last pitch sequence the batter saw. I also like the fact they added the ability to see when your opponent is holding r2.
Why do you need to do this? push pause and see it that way.... BTW you should probably know by the 3rd time through the lineup what they are throwing and how.
-
@halfbutt_psn said in You R2 holders:
You guys that are holding R2 the entire time your opponent is trying to pitch are really a special kind of bad person.
Maybe learn how to win a game without cheating? You might find it actually feels good.
They put an indicator in the game this year during the person is accessing either R2, R3, etc... So there's a stop sign showing you you can't pitch. It's not cheese anymore.
-
@hustlinowl_psn said in You R2 holders:
keep quick pitching expect to see R2 as a counter
r2 isn't a counter. It's a cheat. I'll agree that the balk move needs to be eliminated from the game but r2 isn't the answer. It messes the input on the other side....
-
@bwheel1977_psn said in You R2 holders:
@hustlinowl_psn said in You R2 holders:
keep quick pitching expect to see R2 as a counter
r2 isn't a counter. It's a cheat. I'll agree that the balk move needs to be eliminated from the game but r2 isn't the answer. It messes the input on the other side....
How is it a cheat? They have a giant stop sign logo that pops up when someone does it now.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@grizzbear55_psn said in You R2 holders:
@buddyhightower_xbl said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@kovz88_psn said in You R2 holders:
5 second timer between pitches seems a bit excessive. Also not everyone wants to sit there and take over an hour for a game so try to understand why people try not to take long between pitches? You can't ask people to try and understand your side without extending the same courtesy
Then live with R2 holding. I’m not going to let someone throw 10 pitches in 3 seconds like it’s a machine gun. If you don’t want a timer, R2 is the best way to make both sides happy.
How does holding down R2 / RT (on xbox) keep them from fast pitching? I don't get it....
They can't go into windup as fast. Quick pitching is the problem not R2 majority of players that R2 Is b/c quick pitching is the cheating method R2 is the preventer. People are trying to flip it around and blame R2. It's simple if they don't quick pitch i don't hold R2.
The counter to R2 is stepping off the mound every time
The problem is, depending on the timing, sometimes you cannot step off. Players that use R2 as an exploit know this and do it to mess up their opponent’s timing so they get meatballs.
-
@notoriousheb_psn said in You R2 holders:
@bwheel1977_psn said in You R2 holders:
@hustlinowl_psn said in You R2 holders:
keep quick pitching expect to see R2 as a counter
r2 isn't a counter. It's a cheat. I'll agree that the balk move needs to be eliminated from the game but r2 isn't the answer. It messes the input on the other side....
How is it a cheat? They have a giant stop sign logo that pops up when someone does it now.
Probably trying to do it so fast they don’t even notice it
-
If you use it all the time you're a douche
If you think it should never be used you are also a doucheAcceptable times are - At the start of an inning to quickly look at pitch selections, energy and/or pitch confidence
-When someone is pitching as quickly as possible from the stretch
-When someone is just being an all round douche and you wish to retaliate with douche like equality -
Holding R2 and pressing R2 at the right time especially vs pinpoint pitching to screw up the pitcher is two separate things.
There needs to be just one click of R2 per at bat. My two cents Problem solved.
-
@spc_garza_psn said in You R2 holders:
Holding R2 and pressing R2 at the right time especially vs pinpoint pitching to screw up the pitcher is two separate things.
There needs to be just one click of R2 per at bat. My two cents Problem solved.
No problem not solved sorry. You left out the part where pitcher only gets 1 quick pitch per at bat as well. Now problem solved
-
@halfbutt_psn said in You R2 holders:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in You R2 holders:
@grizzbear55_psn said in You R2 holders:
@buddyhightower_xbl said in You R2 holders:
@sean_87__psn said in You R2 holders:
@kovz88_psn said in You R2 holders:
5 second timer between pitches seems a bit excessive. Also not everyone wants to sit there and take over an hour for a game so try to understand why people try not to take long between pitches? You can't ask people to try and understand your side without extending the same courtesy
Then live with R2 holding. I’m not going to let someone throw 10 pitches in 3 seconds like it’s a machine gun. If you don’t want a timer, R2 is the best way to make both sides happy.
How does holding down R2 / RT (on xbox) keep them from fast pitching? I don't get it....
They can't go into windup as fast. Quick pitching is the problem not R2 majority of players that R2 Is b/c quick pitching is the cheating method R2 is the preventer. People are trying to flip it around and blame R2. It's simple if they don't quick pitch i don't hold R2.
The counter to R2 is stepping off the mound every time
The problem is, depending on the timing, sometimes you cannot step off. Players that use R2 as an exploit know this and do it to mess up their opponent’s timing so they get meatballs.
Yeah, I had this problem last night, I did not have that issue over the weekend. I played two people last night back to back just holding and pressing R2 every pitch. I was not even QP. I do take a few second to get my location set.
-
@grizzbear55_psn said in You R2 holders:
@spc_garza_psn said in You R2 holders:
Holding R2 and pressing R2 at the right time especially vs pinpoint pitching to screw up the pitcher is two separate things.
There needs to be just one click of R2 per at bat. My two cents Problem solved.
No problem not solved sorry. You left out the part where pitcher only gets 1 quick pitch per at bat as well. Now problem solved
What do you consider a QP?
-
@notoriousheb_psn said in You R2 holders:
@bwheel1977_psn said in You R2 holders:
@hustlinowl_psn said in You R2 holders:
keep quick pitching expect to see R2 as a counter
r2 isn't a counter. It's a cheat. I'll agree that the balk move needs to be eliminated from the game but r2 isn't the answer. It messes the input on the other side....
How is it a cheat? They have a giant stop sign logo that pops up when someone does it now.
People do it to throw off the timing of the pinpoint control making the pitches less accurate. It's definately a cheat. Get better at the game. Lay off pitches and crush mistakes like the normal decent players.
-
I'm not completely certain everyone is talking about exactly the same thing when 'quick pitching' is referenced, but whether it's a snap throw to the plate (impossible in the game but probably what's meant in real life) or a relatively speedy turnaround between pitches (due to no balks) at least both of those things are grounded in some kind of reality. In other words, baseball could decide to do away with balks and you could have real life pitches without pitchers coming fully set. My problem with R2 is that it's so artificial. The batter freezing the pitcher? I'm ok with it against the CPU if the pause button is too far away, but human vs human competition, it's too weird of a factor. The pause button is bad enough but at least that's both people temporarily immobilized even if one person started it. R2 is just so blatantly one-sided. As a pitcher in online matches, I don't love it much when the batter steps off or shows bunt a lot or whatever, but I deal with it. The batter should also have to deal with it (step off etc) if the pitcher is quick. Both sides equal. R2 is just too skewed to one side for me to ever get behind it, even if I completely get the stuff R2 supporters are talking about. Because you know something? I do get it! Do you think I've never faced someone online who didn't come set and fired some pitches in with runners on base? Of course I have. It sucks. But purposefully holding down R2 over and over still seems super weird. The only baseball solution would be to turn balks back on, if we're keeping things somewhat in the realm of this being a baseball simulation.
