Community Forum

Hello! I am a lifelong MLB THE SHOW fan with an ardent passion for baseball. The intersection of the sport and video games has been a fascinating aspect of my journey. I invite you to subscribe to and follow my channel for roster updates on MLB The Show 25. You can find me @ YaNkEeSdIeHaRd on PSN, Twitch, and YouTube. My goal is to make the rosters for each one of the 30 teams as accurate as can be throughout the entire season. My focus will be less on ratings, as I would prefer to leave that to MLB THE SHOW themselves. However, each update that they make regarding players ratings and attributes, I will be certain to make those same edits to my daily uploads. That said, my focus will be more on the franchise aspect of each teams roster, ensuring that their overall DEPTH (MLB/MILB), 40 Man, Active 26, Lineup, Rotation, Bullpen, PAYROLL/CONTRACTS, EQUIPMENT/STANCE/MOTIONS and possibly more if the game has added new features. I would really appreciate your honest support throughout the season, and please feel open to provide any feedback, suggestions, and insight for your favorite teams, players,etc.

YaNkEeSdIeHaRd

So, I'm assuming now that Wandy Peralta has signed with another team (besides NYY) you guys will give him the respectable overall he deserves...? Wandy spent three seasons with the Yankees and was extremely reliable and efficient on a constant basis. However, they never rated him over 69. Wandy just got a 4 year 16.5-million-dollar deal with incentives at the age of 32 as a relief pitcher. He should be min 75 overall next year.

93 to 78 in just 10 starts?? Knowing he was coming off an injury? I feel like that's a bit much

I don't ask for a whole lot when it comes to the show...but if not this season...I would love to see a 2014 Version of Jacoby Ellsbury. (his best season as a Yankee) He is one of my favorite players/yankees and I would like for them to do it. In my unbiased opinion, I would put him as 85 overall.

@PAinPA_PSN again, you are being as direct as you can be, and I respect that... However, it just seems to be a bit more consistent with Cole compared to other guys... He is also still on pace for 200 plus K for a third straight season and when you sim a franchise he finishes with like 120 now that he is 70.

@PAinPA_PSN let’s go honest, the guy has broken records for Ks the last 3 seasons and is at 70

@PAinPA_PSN I just think it’s ridiculous being 70, when he started 80 and he is a top strikeout pitcher in the game. They have bums with higher K attributes

Fair. However, it’s still top in baseball and usually they don’t update guys so dramatically during the season, but with Cole it’s gone down 80 points in like 4 updates.

Cole continues to lead baseball or be in the top 5 for strikeouts each season. However, the game continues to lower his attribute. ( 80 - now 70..)

Why is this???

Top 10 Players (Overall)

1. Shohei Ohtani SP/DH - LAA (99)
2. Aaron Judge RF - NYY (98)
3. Mike Trout CF - LAA (98)
4. Jose Altuve 2B - HOU (97)
5. Bryce Harper DH - PHI (97)
6. Yordan Alvarez DH - HOU (96)
7. Manny Machado 3B - SD (96)
8. Nolan Arenado 3B - STL (95)
9. Edwin Diaz CP - NYM (95)
10. Jacob DeGrom SP - TEX (95)
11. Jose Ramirez 3B - CLE (94)
12. Mookie Betts RF - LAD (94)
13. Justin Verlander SP - NYM (94)
14. Paul Goldschmidt 1B - STL (94)
15. Max Fried SP - ATL (93)
16. Max Scherzer SP - NYM (93)

FYI - Trevor Bauer will not be in any of my updates until the Dodgers decide what they’ll do with him. They have 14 days. Others should do the same. Just my opinion

FYI - I won’t be adding Trevor Bauer to any roster until the Dodgers decide what they’re going to do. They have 14 days.

Hey guys,
Hope everyone is enjoying the Holidays and getting ready to spend Christmas with their friends and family.

I just wanted to say, my roster updates are almost full on complete. Meaning, 40 mans, minors, contracts, lineups, bullpens, rotations, and now 23 ratings have been put in for each team. My next go is to go through each team today and be sure I didn’t miss 1 single thing. After that, I will continue to update transactions daily for you.

Today, I can’t be on until this afternoon so the Conforto trade to SF won’t be there for my most recent. Please don’t abuse rate it because of that

Lastly, thank you all for the support so far. I love seeing how many times you guys are using my uploads, and now for the most part rating them fairly. ( As always, please feel free to message if you would like me to look into something different )

you sure that's right? We need one more player, I invited a few but they haven't answered yet so if you know 1 more on top of him lmk.

Ok I'll invite him

UPDATE: Carlos Correa is a NYM.

Good morning to you too (lol)

Would love to start one up. @Y3kn0m772 @Y3kn0m772_MLBTS

@TEXAS10PT_PSN Yeah man, unfortunately I found that out... Sucks! Would still like to do one though.

Does anyone else feel when your team's budget is in a deficient, your team will end up losing more games than it actually should, given their roster/overalls?

YouTube link to see a message regarding my Roster Updates.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4F4HpidQpMo&t=1s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JOemo38274