MLB The Show 26 New Legends Request List
-
Any list without David Andrew Stieb on it is no list at all. We all make mistakes. Revise. Repent. Revel in baseball greatness! That is all from Blue Jays world!
-
@Blujfan1992_XBL
I added Stieb. My bad. -
For the Cardinals I would like to see
MVP (or AS, Gold Glove or Silver Slugger) - Willie McGee
Cy Young - Chris CarpenterRed Schoendienst is a Cardinal legend but not the most desirable for the game especially if Hornsby is also in the game. I mean, I am old and I remember him as the manager of the team.
With Pujols and McGwire and with the ability to play Simmons or Musial at first then I am not sure we need Hernandez.
And on the selfish side I would like Wainwright back in the game. He did have 4 top 3 Cy Young finishes, 200 wins, holds the record (with Yadi) for most wins and most games started as a battery,
2009 he was 3rd (behind Tim Lincecum and previously mentioned Chris Carpenter)
2010 he was 2nd (Behind Roy Halladay)
2013 he was 2nd (Behind Kershaw) He also led the league in Wins, Starts and IP
2014 he was 3rd (Behind Kershaw and Cueto) -
@TheBigPapa55_PSN Please add Ken Caminiti and Kevin Brown to the Padres.
-
@GoozeFn_PSN
I added Kevin Brown to the Rangers since he hit the 20-win club with them and I figure that would warrant more of a card. -
so they took my favorite player out of the game, Ryne Sandberg. I get it that he passed away recently and SDS probably had licensing issues, but [censored] this one hurts. nice to see they added Santo, Grace, and Banks back into the game though
-
@Cubsfan217_XBL Where is this information coming from?
-
@TheBigPapa55_PSN said in MLB The Show Legends List:
SP Kevin Brown (#41) 99 Overall Milestone
I'd love a Kevin Brown as much as anyone, but exactly which Milestone would his Rangers card be?
My Rangers list:
Juan Gonzalez (Postseason)
Charlie Hough (All-Star)
Kenny Rogers (Milestone/Perfect Game)
Rusty Greer (Standout)
Julio Franco (Awards [ASG MVP])
Ruben Sierra (Awards [**** YOU ROBIN YOUNT!!!])
Kevin Brown (All-Star) -
@Cubsfan217_XBL said in MLB The Show Legends List:
so they took my favorite player out of the game, Ryne Sandberg. I get it that he passed away recently and SDS probably had licensing issues, but [censored] this one hurts. nice to see they added Santo, Grace, and Banks back into the game though
where'd you hear this? He had a program last season.
-
Add me to the list of wondering where all that Cubs info came from. Adding three players from any single team seems like a pipe dream for that team's fans.
-
@SaveFarris_PSN
They wont add Charlie Hough because hes a knuckleballer -
@SaveFarris_PSN
20 win season. -
I think the Cubs dude misinterpreted the list somehow as legends in the game when it's the exact opposite. Some people just don't read
-
@TheBigPapa55_PSN said in MLB The Show Legends List:
I think the Cubs dude misinterpreted the list somehow as legends in the game when it's the exact opposite. Some people just don't read
Now that I think about it you are probably right. To be fair your thread title and then just a list of players for every team could be confusing, making people believe it was an official list.
-
@Dolenz_PSN
Yeah, I only noticed that mistake after my dumb [censored] posted it
Edit: oh wait, you can change it. Alright then. -
@thebigpapa55_psn Idk why, but I feel like there's another Dodgers legend you are missing, but I can't name him, maybe like Dusty Baker? Also unrelated, but im surprised Marcell Ozuna is still in the sport since the player ban rules are for PEDs, corked bats, DV, and abuse but not battery or harassment AS FAR AS I KNOW because Marcell did something really horrible to his wife but you can look up that situation in "Incidents" on his wikipedia page.
-
@Christuffer_NSW
Ron Cey, Hideo Nomo? -
@Christuffer_NSW
Doing bad stuff doesnt exclude you from MLB.
