MLB The Show 26 New Legends Request List
-
8 Yankees Legends for MLB The Show
CP Mariano Rivera (#42) 99 Overall G.O.A.T.
CF Joe DiMaggio (#5) 99 Overall Incognito - Joltin’ Joe
C. Yogi Berra (#8) 99 Overall Awards
3B Alex Rodriguez (#13) 99 Overall Milestone
C. Thurman Munson (#15) 99 Overall Cornerstone
RF Roger Maris (#9) 99 Overall Milestone
2B Willie Randolph (#30) 99 Captain
SP Ron Guidry (#48) 99 Overall Awards
10 Rays Legends
3B Evan Longoria (#3) 99 Overall Finest
SP David Price (#14) 99 Overall Awards
CF Kevin Kiermaier (#39) 99 Overall Payday
LF Carl Crawford (#13) 99 Overall Signature
SP Scott Kazmir (#19) 99 Overall Incognito - “Kazmanian Devil”
SP James Shields (#33) 99 Overall Finest
LF Delmon Young (#26) 99 Overall Runner-Up
CP Roberto Hernandez (#39) 99 Overall Milestone
CP Fernando Rodney (#56) 99 Overall League Leaders
C. Toby Hall (#44) 99 Overall Signature
8 Red Sox Legends
LF Carl Yastrzemski (#8) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
2B Dustin Pedroia (#15) 99 Overall Awards
SS Nomar Garciaparra (#5) 99 Overall Runner-Up
SP Lefty Grove (#10) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
RF Dwight Evans (#24) 99 Overall Incognito - Dewey
1B Kevin Youkilis (#20) 99 Overall Standout
CP Jonathan Papelbon (#58) 99 Overall Runner-Up
CF Fred Lynn (#19) 99 Overall Awards
8 Blue Jays Legends
2B Roberto Alomar (#12) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
3B Josh Donaldson (#20) 99 Awards
1B Edwin Encarnacion (#10) 99 Prime
SP David Wells (#36) 99 Finest
1B John Olerud (#9) 99 Overall Awards
SP Dave Stieb (#37) 99 Overall Cornerstone
CP Tom Henke (#50) 99 Overall League Leaders
2B Tony Fernandez (#1) 99 Cornerstone
CP Ken Giles (#51) 99 Overall Underrated
6 Orioles Legends
CF Adam Jones (#10) 99 Overall Cornerstone
1B Chris Davis (#19) 99 Overall Payday
3B Melvin Mora (#6) 99 Overall Finest
LF Mark Trumbo (#45) 99 Overall League Leaders
SP Erik Bedard (#45) 99 Overall One-Season Wonders
CP Zack Britton (#53) 99 Overall League Leaders
CP Gregg Olson (#30) 99 Overall Awards
5 Twins Legends
SP Walter Johnson 99 Overall Hall of Fame
CF Kirby Puckett (#34) 99 Overall Cornerstone
CP Pat Neshek (#17) 99 Overall Prime
1B Kent Hrbek (#14) 99 Overall Runner-Up
RP Francisco Liriano (#47) 99 Overall Finest
9 Indians Legends
2B Nap Lajoie 99 Overall Hall of Fame
CF Tris Speaker 99 Overall Incognito - The Grey Eagle
CF Kenny Lofton (#7) 99 Overall Awards
1B Travis Hafner (#48) 99 Overall League Leaders
LF Michael Brantley (#23) 99 Overall Standout
2B Asdrubal Cabrera (#13) 99 Overall Hyper
C. Victor Martinez (#41) 99 Overall All-Star Game
CP Cody Allen (#37) 99 Overall Underrated
RP Oliver Perez (#39) 99 Overall Finest
10 White Sox Legends
RF Harold Baines (#3) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
LF Minnie Minoso (#9) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
C. Carlton Fisk (#72) 99 Overall Cornerstone
2B Nellie Fox (#2) 99 Overall Awards
1B Paul Konerko (#14) 99 Overall Prime
SP Mark Buehrle (#56) 99 Overall Milestone
RF Jermaine Dye (#23) 99 Overall Awards
3B Robin Ventura (#23) 99 Overall Signature
SP Wilbur Wood (#28) 99 Overall Runner-Up
CP Bobby Thigpen (#37) 99 Overall League Leaders
10 Royals Legends
SP Zack Greinke (#23) 99 Overall Finest
SP Bret Saberhagen (#18) 99 Overall Finest
2B Frank White (#20) 99 Overall Cornerstone
CF Willie Wilson (#6) 99 Overall League Leaders
CF Johnny Damon (#18) 99 Overall All-Star Game
SS Alcides Escobar (#2) 99 Overall Awards
SP Danny Duffy (#41) 99 Overall Signature
CP Greg Holland (#56) 99 Overall Prime
RF Danny Tartabull (#4) 99 Overall Underrated
CP Ian Kennedy (#31) 99 Overall Finest
7 Tigers Legends
CF Ty Cobb 99 Overall Incognito - The Georgia Peach
SP Jack Morris (#47) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
1B Miguel Cabrera (#24) 99 Overall Milestone
RF Magglio Ordonez (#30) 99 Overall Runner-Up
2B Lou Whitaker (#1) 99 Cornerstone
SP Mickey Lolich (#29) 99 Overall Milestone
CP Todd Jones (#59 99 Overall League Leaders
6 Astros Legends
SP Mike Scott (#33) 99 Overall Milestone
LF Jose Cruz (#25) 99 Overall Cornerstone
CF Cesar Cedeno (#28) 99 Overall League Leaders
CF Jim Wynn (#24) 99 Overall Underrated
SS Marwin Gonzalez (#9) 99 Overall Incognito - “Margo”
CP Dave Smith (#45) 99 Overall Cornerstone
9 Athletics Legends
LF Reggie Jackson (#9) 99 Overall Awards
1B Jimmie Foxx (#3) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
RF Jose Canseco (#33) 99 Overall Awards
1B Eric Chavez (#3) 99 Overall Finest
SP Dave Stewart (#34) 99 Overall Cornerstone
RP Ricardo Rincon (#73) 99 Overall Signature
SS Bobby Crosby (#7) 99 Overall Awards
SS Miguel Tejada (#4) 99 Home Run Derby
SP Mark Mulder (#20) 99 Overall Prime
7 Rangers Legends
C. Buddy Bell (#25) 99 Overall Finest
RF Juan Gonzalez (#19) 99 Overall Home Run Derby
SS Elvis Andrus (#1) 99 Overall Cornerstone
CF Josh Hamilton (#32) 99 Overall Finest
1B Mark Texeira (#23) 99 Overall Finest
SP Kevin Brown (#41) 99 Overall Milestone
CP John Wetteland (#35) 99 Overall Underrated
8 Angels Legends
RF Tim Salmon (#15) 99 Overall Awards
CP Troy Percival (#48) 99 Overall Signature
CP Francisco Rodriguez (#57) 99 Overall Milestone
SP Chuck Finley (#31) 99 Overall Cornerstone
SS Andrelton Simmons (#2) 99 Overall Awards
SP Bartolo Colon (#40) 99 Overall Incognito - Big Sexy
LF Darin Erstad (#17) 99 Overall Milestone
2B Howie Kendrick (#47) 99 Overall Signature
7 Mariners Legends
RF Ichiro Suzuki (#51) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
SP Felix Hernandez (#34) 99 Overall Incognito - King Felix
RF Jay Buhner (#19) 99 Overall Cornerstone
2B Robinson Cano (#22) 99 Overall Payday
DH Nelson Cruz (#23) 99 Overall Incognito - Boomstick
SP Jamie Moyer (#50) 99 Overall Milestone
CP J.J. Putz (#20) 99 Overall League Leaders
6 Braves Legends
SP John Smoltz (#29) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
SP Phil Niekro (#35) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
CF Dale Murphy (#3) 99 Overall Cornerstone
CF Andruw Jones (#25) 99 Overall Runner-Up
SP Mike Foltynewicz (#26) 99 One-Season Wonders
1B Fred McGriff (#27) 99 Overall Incognito - Crime Dog
7 Nationals Legends
SP Stephen Strasburg (#37) 99 Overall Awards
SP Gio Gonzalez (#47) 99 Overall League Leaders
SP Livan Hernandez (#61) 99 Overall Underrated
1B Rusty Staub (#10) 99 Overall Incognito - “Le Grand Orange”
SP Steve Rogers (#45) 99 Cornerstone
3B Tim Wallach (#29) 99 Overall Awards
RP Tyler Clippard (#36) 99 Overall Prime
8 Mets Legends
1B Keith Hernandez (#17) 99 Overall Incognito - “Nex”
SP Dwight Gooden (#16) 99 Overall Awards
SP Jerry Koosman (#36) 99 Overall Cornerstone
LF Darryl Strawberry (#18) 99 Overall Home Run Derby
SS Jose Reyes (#7) 99 Overall Milestone
3B Edgardo Alfonzo (#13) 99 Overall Standout
LF Yoenis Cespedes (#52) 99 Overall Awards
3B Howard Johnson (#20) 99 Overall League Leaders
6 Phillies Legends
3B Mike Schmidt (#25) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
SP Jim Bunning (#14) 99 Overall Cornerstone
SP Cole Hamels (#35) 99 Overall Finest
SP Curt Schilling (#38) 99 Overall Awards
SP Grover Alexander 99 Overall Hall of Fame
CP Tug McGraw (#45) 99 Overall Finest
7 Marlins Legends
SS Hanley Ramirez (#2) 99 Overall Awards
SP A.J. Burnett (#34) 99 Overall Cornerstone
SP Josh Beckett (#21) 99 Overall Awards
SP Josh Johnson (#55) 99 Overall League Leaders
SS Edgar Renteria (#3) 99 Overall Awards
LF Cliff Floyd (#15) 99 Overall Finest
SP Jose Fernandez (#16) 99 Overall Awards
8 Cardinals Legends
2B Rogers Hornsby 99 Overall Milestone
1B Albert Pujols (#5) 99 Overall The Show Classics
C. Yadier Molina (#4) 99 Overall Cornerstone
SP Dizzy Dean (#17) 99 Overall Awards
RF Enos Slaughter (#9) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
2B Red Schoendienst (#2) 99 Overall League Leaders
SP Chris Carpenter (#29) 99 Overall Awards
CP Jason Isringhausen (#44) 99 Overall Incognito - “Izzy”
5 Brewers Lineup
3B Jeff Cirilo (#26) 99 Overall Signature
SP Ben Sheets (#15) 99 Overall One-Season Wonders
CF Carlos Gomez (#27) 99 Overall Awards
C. Jonathan Lucroy (#20) 99 Overall Finest
SP Yovani Gallardo (#27) 99 Overall Underrated
6 Cubs Legends
SS Ernie Banks (#14) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
SP Fergie Jenkins (#31) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
3B Ron Santo (#10) 99 Overall Cornerstone
1B Mark Grace (#17) 99 Overall Signature
SP Carlos Zambrano (#38) 99 Overall Finest
3B Aramis Ramirez (#16) 99 Overall Awards
1B Derrek Lee (#23) 99 Overall League Leaders
6 Reds Legends
1B Pete Rose (#14) 99 Overall Milestone
LF Frank Robinson (#20) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
LF George Foster (#15) 99 Overall Milestone
2B Brandon Phillips (#4) 99 Overall Milestone
SS Dave Concepcion (#13) 99 Overall Cornerstone
RF Ken Griffey (#30) 99 Overall Underrated
5 Pirates Legends
RF Paul Waner (#11) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
2B Josh Harrison (#5) 99 Overall Finest
CP Mark Melancon (#35) 99 Overall Prime
2B Freddy Sanchez (#13) 99 Overall League Leaders
RF Gregory Polanco (#25) 99 Overall Finest
7 Dodgers Legends
SP Sandy Koufax (#32) 99 Overall Incognito - The Left Arm of God
SS Pee Wee Reese (#1) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
SP Don Drysdale (#53) 99 Overall Awards
C. Roy Campanella (#39) 99 Overall Finest
SP Orel Hershiser (#55) 99 Overall Action Figure
1B Steve Garvey (#6) 99 Overall Milestone
CP Jesse Orosco (#46) 99 Overall Incognito - “Lefty”
5 Diamondbacks Legends
CF A.J. Pollock (#11) 99 Overall Awards
SP Archie Bradley (#25) 99 Overall Finest
LF Justin Upton (#10) 99 Overall Incognito “J-Up
SS Stephen Drew (#6) 99 Overall Signature
LF Eric Byrnes (#22) 99 Overall Finest
11 Giants Legends
LF Barry Bonds (#25) 99 Overall Milestone
C. Buster Posey (#28) 99 Overall Incognito - Hum Buss
SP Christy Mathewson 99 Overall Milestone
SP Madison Bumgarner (#40) 99 Overall Cornerstone
RF Mel Ott (#4) 99 Overall Incognito - Master Melvin
SP Tim Lincecum (#55) 99 Overall Awards
CP Brian Wilson (#38) 99 Overall Incognito - “The Beard”
SS Rich Aurilia (#35) 99 Overall Milestone
1B Will Clark (#22) 99 Overall Runner-Up
2B Jeff Kent (#21) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
CP Sergio Romo (#54) 99 Overall Finest
8 Rockies Legends
RF Charlie Blackmon (#19) 99 Overall Incognito - “Chuck Nazty”
SS Troy Tulowitzki (#2) 99 Overall Runner-Up
RF Dante Bichette (#16) 99 Overall Finest
RF Carlos Gonzalez (#5) 99 Overall Finest
CP Adam Ottavino (#0) 99 Overall Cornerstone
SP Jeff Francis (#10) 99 Overall Cornerstone
1B Andres Galarraga (#14) 99 Overall League Leaders
RP Manny Corpas (#60) 99 Overall Prime
8 Padres Legends
RF Dave Winfield (#31) 99 Overall Hall of Fame
SP Jake Peavy (#44) 99 Overall Awards
LF Greg Vaughn (#23) 99 Overall Finest
3B Ken Caminiti (#21) 99 Overall Awards
SP Andy Ashby (#43) 99 Overall Underrated
C. Benito Santiago (#9) 99 Overall Awards
3B Phil Nevin (#23) 99 Overall Prime
RF Brian Giles (#24) 99 Overall Cornerstone -
This is my updated list for big names not in The Show.
-
@TheBigPapa55_PSN said in MLB The Show Legends List:
This is my updated list for big names not in The Show.
Alomar is on mlb's restricted list or he might still be in the game.
-
@PAinPA_PSN
Sexual harassment. It's not abuse, it's not...the other unnamed thing, how did this get Alomar banned? This is just a question; you're right he won't be in the game but brother, that's wild. -
This would’ve taken me a week alone simply to type all of that! Kudos for the list. I’d love to see HoJo on here for my beloved Mets and Strawberry fielding RF would make it perfect
-
No Fred Lynn for the Red Sox?
-
@BxnnyMxn__MLBTS
How could I possibly forget HoJo as a Mets fan? Sue me.
@x-814-x-mafia-x_psn
My bad. -
@TheBigPapa55_PSN said in MLB The Show Legends List:
@PAinPA_PSN
Sexual harassment. It's not abuse, it's not...the other unnamed thing, how did this get Alomar banned? This is just a question; you're right he won't be in the game but brother, that's wild.They clearly found something more than harassment.
-
Any list without David Andrew Stieb on it is no list at all. We all make mistakes. Revise. Repent. Revel in baseball greatness! That is all from Blue Jays world!
-
@Blujfan1992_XBL
I added Stieb. My bad. -
For the Cardinals I would like to see
MVP (or AS, Gold Glove or Silver Slugger) - Willie McGee
Cy Young - Chris CarpenterRed Schoendienst is a Cardinal legend but not the most desirable for the game especially if Hornsby is also in the game. I mean, I am old and I remember him as the manager of the team.
With Pujols and McGwire and with the ability to play Simmons or Musial at first then I am not sure we need Hernandez.
And on the selfish side I would like Wainwright back in the game. He did have 4 top 3 Cy Young finishes, 200 wins, holds the record (with Yadi) for most wins and most games started as a battery,
2009 he was 3rd (behind Tim Lincecum and previously mentioned Chris Carpenter)
2010 he was 2nd (Behind Roy Halladay)
2013 he was 2nd (Behind Kershaw) He also led the league in Wins, Starts and IP
2014 he was 3rd (Behind Kershaw and Cueto) -
@TheBigPapa55_PSN Please add Ken Caminiti and Kevin Brown to the Padres.
-
@GoozeFn_PSN
I added Kevin Brown to the Rangers since he hit the 20-win club with them and I figure that would warrant more of a card. -
so they took my favorite player out of the game, Ryne Sandberg. I get it that he passed away recently and SDS probably had licensing issues, but [censored] this one hurts. nice to see they added Santo, Grace, and Banks back into the game though
-
@Cubsfan217_XBL Where is this information coming from?
-
@TheBigPapa55_PSN said in MLB The Show Legends List:
SP Kevin Brown (#41) 99 Overall Milestone
I'd love a Kevin Brown as much as anyone, but exactly which Milestone would his Rangers card be?
My Rangers list:
Juan Gonzalez (Postseason)
Charlie Hough (All-Star)
Kenny Rogers (Milestone/Perfect Game)
Rusty Greer (Standout)
Julio Franco (Awards [ASG MVP])
Ruben Sierra (Awards [**** YOU ROBIN YOUNT!!!])
Kevin Brown (All-Star) -
@Cubsfan217_XBL said in MLB The Show Legends List:
so they took my favorite player out of the game, Ryne Sandberg. I get it that he passed away recently and SDS probably had licensing issues, but [censored] this one hurts. nice to see they added Santo, Grace, and Banks back into the game though
where'd you hear this? He had a program last season.
-
Add me to the list of wondering where all that Cubs info came from. Adding three players from any single team seems like a pipe dream for that team's fans.
-
@SaveFarris_PSN
They wont add Charlie Hough because hes a knuckleballer -
@SaveFarris_PSN
20 win season.
