Plz fix the gameplay
-
Here are the perfect perfect logs for the last 8 games (50 Perfects)
Easily checked here
https://mlb25.theshow.com/universal_profiles/psn/Dinger_Dan19/game_historyChatGPT Summary There are 50 total entries in the dataset you provided Here’s the corrected breakdown: Home runs: 26 Doubles: 4 Singles: 16 Outs: 4 Batting Average: .9207/20/2025 7:33PM CDT
Rutschman: 102 mph (Rutschman homered to right (408 feet). 1 RBI)7/20/2025 5:26PM CDT
Olson: 114 mph (Olson grounded to right for a single. )
Schwarber: 113 mph (Schwarber homered to right (444 feet). 1 RBI)
Duran: 104 mph (Duran homered to center (418 feet). 1 RBI)
Lindor: 109 mph (Lindor homered to right (411 feet). 1 RBI)7/20/2025 4:10PM CDT
Raleigh: 108 mph (Raleigh homered to right (461 feet). 2 RBI)
Lindor: 110 mph (Lindor lined out to CF (L8). )
Rutschman: 112 mph (Rutschman batted out to 1B (L3). )
De La Cruz: 105 mph (De La Cruz lined to center for a single, but out advancing (8-6-4). 1 RBI)
Grich: 101 mph (Grich homered to right (433 feet). 2 RBI)
Smith: 111 mph (Smith lined to left for a single, but out advancing (7-4). )
Raleigh: 113 mph (Raleigh homered to left (493 feet). 2 RBI)7/19/2025 8:37PM CDT
Buxton: 109 mph (Buxton homered to left (420 feet). 1 RBI)
Smith: 107 mph (Smith lined to left for a single, but out advancing (7-4). )
Carroll: 110 mph (Carroll homered to center (444 feet). 2 RBI)
Smith: 110 mph (Smith lined to left for a single. )7/19/2025 2:09PM CDT
Raleigh: 108 mph (Raleigh homered to right (428 feet). 1 RBI)
Greene: 106 mph (Greene grounded to center for a single. )
Bellinger: 108 mph (Bellinger homered to center (441 feet). 1 RBI)
Raleigh: 112 mph (Raleigh homered to center (442 feet). 1 RBI)
Bellinger: 103 mph (Bellinger homered to left (411 feet). 1 RBI)
De La Cruz: 109 mph (De La Cruz homered to right (451 feet). 1 RBI)
Bellinger: 114 mph (Bellinger grounded to left for a single. )
Crow-Armstrong: 105 mph (Crow-Armstrong homered to left (400 feet). 1 RBI)7/19/2025 1:20PM CDT
Judge: 111 mph (Judge grounded to left for a single. )
Bellinger: 101 mph (Bellinger homered to center (410 feet). 1 RBI)
Witt Jr.: 115 mph (Witt Jr. grounded out to SS (6-3). )
Bellinger: 112 mph (Bellinger doubled to center. )
Schwarber: 114 mph (Schwarber doubled to center. )
Suarez: 115 mph (Suarez grounded to center for a single. )7/19/2025 12:36PM CDT
De La Cruz: 113 mph (De La Cruz homered to center (425 feet). 1 RBI)
Bellinger: 109 mph (Bellinger homered to center (443 feet). 1 RBI)
Sheffield: 101 mph (Sheffield lined to center for a single. )
Witt Jr.: 103 mph (Witt Jr. homered to center (418 feet). 2 RBI)
Springer: 110 mph (Springer homered to left (447 feet). 1 RBI)
Bellinger: 107 mph (Bellinger homered to center (435 feet). 2 RBI)
Kirk: 107 mph (Kirk grounded to center for a single. 1 RBI)
Guerrero Jr.: 108 mph (Guerrero Jr. grounded and deflected off SS Ripken Jr. for a single. )
Bellinger: 111 mph (Bellinger lined to right for a single. )
Duran: 106 mph (Duran doubled to right. 1 RBI)
De La Cruz: 106 mph (De La Cruz doubled to center. )
Chapman: 108 mph (Chapman homered to center (422 feet). 2 RBI)
Schwarber: 112 mph (Schwarber homered to right (402 feet). 1 RBI)7/19/2025 12:22AM CDT
Lindor: 107 mph (Lindor homered to center (435 feet). 1 RBI)
Lindor: 112 mph (Lindor grounded to center for a single. )
Sheffield: 113 mph (Sheffield grounded to left for a single. )
Smith: 111 mph (Smith grounded to center for a single. )
Duran: 100 mph (Duran lined out to LF (L7). )
Schwarber: 115 mph (Schwarber homered to right (435 feet). 1 RBI)
Smith: 110 mph (Smith homered to center (442 feet). 1 RBI) -
@Dolenz_PSN where’s the Bobby Witt Perfperf foul ball on the 2nd from the bottom? Where’s is the Rutchman lineout to RF in that same game? Where’s the Lindor groundout in the second from the top? Also why are we counting my opponents again.
-
@Dinger_Dan19_PSN Ok since you’re still grasping onto the lie, I’ll make it easy for you:
Your most recent game (not part of the six I mentioned earlier):
Rutschman: 102 mph (Rutschman homered to right (408 feet). 1 RBI)
Now the six I mentioned:
Game 6:
Olson: 114 mph (Olson grounded to right for a single. )
Schwarber: 113 mph (Schwarber homered to right (444 feet). 1 RBI)
Duran: 104 mph (Duran homered to center (418 feet). 1 RBI)
Lindor: 109 mph (Lindor homered to right (411 feet). 1 RBI)Game 5:
Raleigh: 108 mph (Raleigh homered to right (461 feet). 2 RBI)
Lindor: 110 mph (Lindor lined out to CF (L8). )
Rutschman: 112 mph (Rutschman batted out to 1B (L3). )
De La Cruz: 105 mph (De La Cruz lined to center for a single, but out advancing (8-6-4). 1 RBI)
Grich: 101 mph (Grich homered to right (433 feet). 2 RBI)
Smith: 111 mph (Smith lined to left for a single, but out advancing (7-4). )
Raleigh: 113 mph (Raleigh homered to left (493 feet). 2 RBI)Game 4:
Buxton: 109 mph (Buxton homered to left (420 feet). 1 RBI)
Smith: 107 mph (Smith lined to left for a single, but out advancing (7-4). )
Carroll: 110 mph (Carroll homered to center (444 feet). 2 RBI)
Smith: 110 mph (Smith lined to left for a single. )Game 3:
Raleigh: 108 mph (Raleigh homered to right (428 feet). 1 RBI)
Greene: 106 mph (Greene grounded to center for a single. )
Bellinger: 108 mph (Bellinger homered to center (441 feet). 1 RBI)
Raleigh: 112 mph (Raleigh homered to center (442 feet). 1 RBI)
Bellinger: 103 mph (Bellinger homered to left (411 feet). 1 RBI)
De La Cruz: 109 mph (De La Cruz homered to right (451 feet). 1 RBI)
Bellinger: 114 mph (Bellinger grounded to left for a single. )
Crow-Armstrong: 105 mph (Crow-Armstrong homered to left (400 feet). 1 RBI)Game 2:
Judge: 111 mph (Judge grounded to left for a single. )
Bellinger: 101 mph (Bellinger homered to center (410 feet). 1 RBI)
Witt Jr.: 115 mph (Witt Jr. grounded out to SS (6-3). )
Bellinger: 112 mph (Bellinger doubled to center. )
Schwarber: 114 mph (Schwarber doubled to center. )
Suarez: 115 mph (Suarez grounded to center for a single. )Game 1:
De La Cruz: 113 mph (De La Cruz homered to center (425 feet). 1 RBI)
Bellinger: 109 mph (Bellinger homered to center (443 feet). 1 RBI)
Sheffield: 101 mph (Sheffield lined to center for a single. )
Witt Jr.: 103 mph (Witt Jr. homered to center (418 feet). 2 RBI)
Springer: 110 mph (Springer homered to left (447 feet). 1 RBI)
Bellinger: 107 mph (Bellinger homered to center (435 feet). 2 RBI)
Kirk: 107 mph (Kirk grounded to center for a single. 1 RBI)
Guerrero Jr.: 108 mph (Guerrero Jr. grounded and deflected off SS Ripken Jr. for a single. )
Bellinger: 111 mph (Bellinger lined to right for a single. )
Duran: 106 mph (Duran doubled to right. 1 RBI)
De La Cruz: 106 mph (De La Cruz doubled to center. )
Chapman: 108 mph (Chapman homered to center (422 feet). 2 RBI)
Schwarber: 112 mph (Schwarber homered to right (402 feet). 1 RBI)Should I keep going? These are a direct copy and paste of your last 7 games. It’s 41 for 44 now. I’m sure you feel like it’s worse, but game logs don’t lie. Your truth isn’t reality. There’s only one objective truth and that’s shown here and in your game logs.
-
Omg how do I post these! PSN app won’t post them. And I don’t have Olsen so we’re counting my opponents swings again.
-
@Dinger_Dan19_PSN said in Plz fix the gameplay:
@Dolenz_PSN where’s the Bobby Witt Perfperf foul ball on the 2nd from the bottom? Where’s is the Rutchman lineout to RF in that same game? Where’s the Lindor groundout in the second from the top? Also why are we counting my opponents again.
We are counting your opponents because game logs don't specify which team hit the perfect/perfect. And while it is easy for me to do some cutting and pasting while on the dual monitors of my PC I am not going to try an determine which teams those players are on when there are so many occasions where a player is on both teams.
Feel free to dispute the logs. But I can't think of any reason that the game log would show Lindor's perfect/perfect line out but not other players.
-
@Dolenz_PSN It also provides a bigger and more relevant sample. Was he unlucky and had more perfect perfect outs than his opponent? Yes. Does that mean the hitting engine is broken? No, it just means he was unlucky and only hit .857 on perfects. Perfect perfects should not be a hit 100% of the time.
-
@Dinger_Dan19_PSN said in Plz fix the gameplay:
Omg how do I post these! PSN app won’t post them. And I don’t have Olsen so we’re counting my opponents swings again.
P/P foul balls don't show on the game log.
-
@GoozeFn_PSN this is all very strange to me. Op seems very frustrated in the game play. And to come on here that frustrated just to be exaggerating that much doesn't make sense. Especially when I know for certain the game is indeed playing very bad this year. Now it may not be exactly what the op stated. But where there is smoke there is fire. And im hearing and seeing alot of smoke about the game play this year.
Content is great game play is not. No one cares about content when the game is this buggy.
-
@GoozeFn_PSN said in Plz fix the gameplay:
@Dolenz_PSN Exactly. I have also said that hitting is worse this year. It’s just exaggerated every single time someone comes here to complain about it. You don’t have to lie to make your point.
After reading the OP, I was pretty sure that this was the outcome … If you post numbers be sure to have them right and not lie about it. If you do not know how to post screenshots, use google or AI to explain it to you. If both is too hard, do not post threads with numbers at all
-
@SpawnOfDitka_XBL Complaining about perfect perfects outs is not new.
-
Respectfully- I get what you're driving at, but relying on those "stats", which have shown to be fairly inaccurate time and time again, really doesn't strengthen your argument. (I played 3 games in the WC- my record only shows 1, for example)
What does is saying that in baseball, failing only 70% of the time puts you in the HoF. So when someone above went "So 7/23 on P/P is good?", my response is absolutely yes it is...that's a .304 avg on p/p batted balls.
Frustrating? Sure. Should every P/P be a hit? Surely not.
-
@GoozeFn_PSN have you taken a look at Google reviews on this game? Go check those out. Every single complaint is about hitting this year. Every single review!!!
Im not kidding every single review mentions hitting this year.
The reviews on this game are so bad this year. And i couldn't agree more. I want to break my monitor or tv everytime I play the game this year seems to be a common review when it comes to hitting. I feel that.
-
The hitting is a major issue with the game and everyone knows it. I don’t understand all the white knights who year after year it’s the same people defend this dribble.
-
@VioletNine9_XBL said in Plz fix the gameplay:
The hitting is a major issue with the game and everyone knows it. I don’t understand all the white knights who year after year it’s the same people defend this dribble.
Who is being a white knight? Am I?
I have stated numerous times that the hitting feels unrewarding.
Am I being a white knight because I don't take someone's claim that the overwhelming majority of their perfect/perfects are outs at face value? I have never once, that I can remember, defended the hitting in this year's game. I question launch angles and exit velocities of my swings quite often.
Am I supposed to believe them and just assume that SDS is doctoring every person's game history to show perfect/perfects in a better light?
I am all for questioning the hitting system. I just don't believe that posting what seems to be exaggerated numbers is useful. Maybe the venting helps the user who is doing the venting but I don't think it is useful in the long run.
-
@Dolenz_PSN I guess it’s a binary option. You either have to accept opinions as fact in spite of the facts, or you’re a white knight shill and people wonder why there’s no meaningful discussion.
-
@Dolenz_PSN said in Plz fix the gameplay:
@VioletNine9_XBL said in Plz fix the gameplay:
The hitting is a major issue with the game and everyone knows it. I don’t understand all the white knights who year after year it’s the same people defend this dribble.
Who is being a white knight? Am I?
I have stated numerous times that the hitting feels unrewarding.
Am I being a white knight because I don't take someone's claim that the overwhelming majority of their perfect/perfects are outs at face value? I have never once, that I can remember, defended the hitting in this year's game. I question launch angles and exit velocities of my swings quite often.
Am I supposed to believe them and just assume that SDS is doctoring every person's game history to show perfect/perfects in a better light?
I am all for questioning the hitting system. I just don't believe that posting what seems to be exaggerated numbers is useful. Maybe the venting helps the user who is doing the venting but I don't think it is useful in the long run.
Haven't you noticed that if you don't agree with someone, especially on this forum, that's complaining about the game; they'll call you a white knight or a simp for SDS.
Its supposed to be construed as an insult. But unless they're actually saying it to your face, not miles and miles away behind a keyboard, it just comes off as how childish they can be.
-
The feedback given at the end of a game is not at all accurate. So I would caution using that for anyone or in any case. I know this because I played an opponent the other day that literally dinked almost every hit. I was about to ask him how he was doing it because it seemed intentional. It was actually impressive. Everything just falling perfectly into gaps just over the infielders heads or placed just perfectly down the line. When looking at the feedback after the game it said he only had one late or early dink and no bad contact. So essentially he had no bad contact. His PCi ratings on the balls weren’t good but it said his timing or something was fine. Bottom line is the results at the end of the game are often one or two numbers off from your opponents and rarely right from what I’ve seen.
-
I once had an opponent reach base on a strikeout 3 times in one game with Will Smith behind the plate...
-
@RAisEdByGoAt_XBL I’ve never noticed a single discrepancy in the game logs, but I’ll test it with perfect perfects in the next games I play.
-
My 2 cents: I don’t think hitting is broken , but I do agree with the word @Dolenz_PSN uses “unrewarding”. I’ll give an example…
I’m currently finishing up a Lefty Longball mini season. As you can imagine (since I’m playing it “late”), my team is full of 96-99 hitters with 100+ contact, power, and clutch.
Yet, I can’t tell you the number of games I’ve won with the score 1-0, 2-1, 3-1, 3-0 ( low scoring).
This should NOT be the case! I should be scoring 10+ runs per game, given the terrible pitchers I’m facing.
Yet, that is not the case. I play in Rookie. I can only assume my team has been nerfed/gated to stop me from running up the score and getting too much XP/PXP. Yes, I’m winning, but it’s a very unrewarding experience.
