All Star Program Prediction thread:
-
@samguenther1987 said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
Ok National League
Braves - Travis D'Arnaud or William Contreras
Mets - Pete Alonso or Edwin Diaz
Marlins - Jazz Chisholm
Phillies - Bryce Harper
Nationals - Juan SotoCubs - Wilson Contreras
Cardinals - Paul Goldschmidt (This could be a card with huge power numbers, he's putting together a MVP season)
Reds - Luis Castillo?
Pirates - David Bednar
Brewers - Josh HaderDodgers - Trea Turner (Will it be as good as last years card?)
Giants - Joc Pederson
Rockies - C.J Cron (I don't know if they have anyone else)
Padres - Manny Machado
Diamondbacks - Joe Mantiply (Another sleeper)I'll end this by saying I really wish SDS would do all time All Stars like Ken Griffey Jr, Cal Ripken etc instead but I know those are coming at the end of the year unfortunately
I’m sure both of them will get Takashi cards eventually. Same with Tony Gwynn,Hank Aaron,Nolan Ryan,Bob Gibson and whoever else. I really want a good Pedro Martinez card that’s better than last year.
-
I guess I should answer my own questions hahaha
AL-
Yankees- Aaron Judge
Blue Jays- Alejandro Kirk
Red Sox- I'm gonna take a wild guess and say JD Martinez will be a sub and will get the nod. Short of that, Devers or Xander flip a coin
Rays- Shane McClanahan
Orioles- Jorge Lopez (or maybe Austin Hays as a replacement)AL Central-
Twins- Luis Arraez
White Sox- Tim Anderson
Tigers- Gregory Soto
Indians- Jose Ramirez
Royals- Andrew BenintendiAL West-
A's- Paul Blackburn
Rangers- Martin Perez
Astros- Jose Altuve
Mariners- Julio Rodriguez
Angels- Ohtani I guess, or Yrout, both don't need 1 as they have multiple diamonds. -
NL East-
Mets- Starling Marte
Marlins- Sandy Alcantara although I would love a Jazz Chisolm
Braves- Max Fried
Phillies- Bryce Harper
Nationals- Juan SotoNL Central-
Cubs- Ian Happ
Pirates- David Bednar
Cardinals- Nolen Arenado
Reds- Luis Castillo
Brewers- Josh HaderNL West-
Dodgers- Tony Gonsolin
Padres- Manny Machado
Rockies- CJ Cron
DBacks- Joe Mantiply
Giants- Joc PedersonThe hardest ones to predict are the teams with several players- Dodgers, Yankees, Blue Jays, Astros, Braves and Mets
-
I wouldn't mind seeing a special Pujols and Cabrera Diamond card.
-
The teams with 1 allstar are guaranteed unless SDS waits for replacements to be announced so I'll just guess the ones with multiple.
Red Sox:Bogaerts(this team would benefit from SDS waiting for replacements
Yankees: Cortes
Blue Jays: Kirk
Guardians: J-Ram
Tigers: Soto(this is basically guaranteed too)
Twins: Arraez
Astros: Valdez
Angels: RF Ohtani
Braves: Darnaud
Mets: Jeff McNeil
Marlins: Sandy
Phillies: Harper
Cubs: Willson Contreras
Brewers: Hader
Cardinals: Goldschmidt
Dodgers: Gonsolin
Padres: Machado -
@dlgltal-athlete_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
I wouldn't mind seeing a special Pujols and Cabrera Diamond card.
Agreed. Maybe even drop their 99 for a collection itemize they did last year with Ohtani and Prince Fielder? Two more 99s won't break the game considering they're both 1Bs at best haha.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@dlgltal-athlete_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
I wouldn't mind seeing a special Pujols and Cabrera Diamond card.
Agreed. Maybe even drop their 99 for a collection itemize they did last year with Ohtani and Prince Fielder? Two more 99s won't break the game considering they're both 1Bs at best haha.
I actually hope they don't, but not because a 99 Cabrera and Pujols would break the game, but because I think the legacy picks for the ASG is dumb. It doesn't look so bad with 2 of the greatest hitters ever, but the whole reason this legacy ASG selection thing even exists imo is to give players an end of career boost to HOF resumes. Pujols and Cabrera don't need that boost, but some of the players that will be added to those spots in the future definitely will(think guys with Careers like Greinke)
-
@the_dragon1912 said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@ericulous1_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@dlgltal-athlete_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
I wouldn't mind seeing a special Pujols and Cabrera Diamond card.
Agreed. Maybe even drop their 99 for a collection itemize they did last year with Ohtani and Prince Fielder? Two more 99s won't break the game considering they're both 1Bs at best haha.
I actually hope they don't, but not because a 99 Cabrera and Pujols would break the game, but because I think the legacy picks for the ASG is dumb. It doesn't look so bad with 2 of the greatest hitters ever, but the whole reason this legacy ASG selection thing even exists imo is to give players an end of career boost to HOF resumes. Pujols and Cabrera don't need that boost, but some of the players that will be added to those spots in the future definitely will(think guys with Careers like Greinke)
I never even thought of that. It's funny though I was thinking it's pretty crazy that Pujols had only been in 10 ASGs which is a lot but nothing compared to the stars of my childhood like Ripken, Gwynn, Ozzie etc.
I also didn't really consider that this was a start of a new trend. I wish they'd have given it to Molina and Waino as well but that obviously would be ridiculous having 3 from the same franchise. I'm obviously bias though.
-
@the_dragon1912 said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@ericulous1_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@dlgltal-athlete_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
I wouldn't mind seeing a special Pujols and Cabrera Diamond card.
Agreed. Maybe even drop their 99 for a collection itemize they did last year with Ohtani and Prince Fielder? Two more 99s won't break the game considering they're both 1Bs at best haha.
I actually hope they don't, but not because a 99 Cabrera and Pujols would break the game, but because I think the legacy picks for the ASG is dumb. It doesn't look so bad with 2 of the greatest hitters ever, but the whole reason this legacy ASG selection thing even exists imo is to give players an end of career boost to HOF resumes. Pujols and Cabrera don't need that boost, but some of the players that will be added to those spots in the future definitely will(think guys with Careers like Greinke)
I guess we will just have to wait and see how these picks are used in the future. I can't imagine that a single legacy all-star selection tilts the HOF meter much at all for any player. By the time you are at the stage of your career that you would be considered for a legacy selection I would hope their case has already been made.
-
@dolenz_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@the_dragon1912 said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@ericulous1_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@dlgltal-athlete_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
I wouldn't mind seeing a special Pujols and Cabrera Diamond card.
Agreed. Maybe even drop their 99 for a collection itemize they did last year with Ohtani and Prince Fielder? Two more 99s won't break the game considering they're both 1Bs at best haha.
I actually hope they don't, but not because a 99 Cabrera and Pujols would break the game, but because I think the legacy picks for the ASG is dumb. It doesn't look so bad with 2 of the greatest hitters ever, but the whole reason this legacy ASG selection thing even exists imo is to give players an end of career boost to HOF resumes. Pujols and Cabrera don't need that boost, but some of the players that will be added to those spots in the future definitely will(think guys with Careers like Greinke)
I guess we will just have to wait and see how these picks are used in the future. I can't imagine that a single legacy all-star selection tilts the HOF meter much at all for any player. By the time you are at the stage of your career that you would be considered for a legacy selection I would hope their case has already been made.
I agree with you, but I think you are underestimating how nitpickey a good portion of The HOF voters are with their selections. 7 Allstar appearances instead of 6 could sway 30 voters for a guy like Votto
-
-
@mrkat_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
I'd love a good Arraez card - 125 vision, L/R contact. Like an old school carew where everything is a hit
Yes, this could definitely be a sleeper for sure. The popular pick would be Buxton of course but sometimes it's more fun to go with the guy that's having a Breakout.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@mrkat_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
I'd love a good Arraez card - 125 vision, L/R contact. Like an old school carew where everything is a hit
Yes, this could definitely be a sleeper for sure. The popular pick would be Buxton of course but sometimes it's more fun to go with the guy that's having a Breakout.
No please not Buxton again, I don't know why we need certain players to have 3/4/5 different cards, personally I would love to use new players from the Twins I haven't used before. Arraez would be perfect.
-
@the_dragon1912 said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@dolenz_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@the_dragon1912 said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@ericulous1_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@dlgltal-athlete_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
I wouldn't mind seeing a special Pujols and Cabrera Diamond card.
Agreed. Maybe even drop their 99 for a collection itemize they did last year with Ohtani and Prince Fielder? Two more 99s won't break the game considering they're both 1Bs at best haha.
I actually hope they don't, but not because a 99 Cabrera and Pujols would break the game, but because I think the legacy picks for the ASG is dumb. It doesn't look so bad with 2 of the greatest hitters ever, but the whole reason this legacy ASG selection thing even exists imo is to give players an end of career boost to HOF resumes. Pujols and Cabrera don't need that boost, but some of the players that will be added to those spots in the future definitely will(think guys with Careers like Greinke)
I guess we will just have to wait and see how these picks are used in the future. I can't imagine that a single legacy all-star selection tilts the HOF meter much at all for any player. By the time you are at the stage of your career that you would be considered for a legacy selection I would hope their case has already been made.
I agree with you, but I think you are underestimating how nitpickey a good portion of The HOF voters are with their selections. 7 Allstar appearances instead of 6 could sway 30 voters for a guy like Votto
This is a good point. And there are so many names that fit that description that aren't slam dunks that could be in this conversation over the next several years.
Votto, Greinke, Nelson Cruz, Bumgarner, Waino if he goes another year and a ton more in the next 5-7 years.
-
@samguenther1987 said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@ericulous1_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
@mrkat_psn said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
I'd love a good Arraez card - 125 vision, L/R contact. Like an old school carew where everything is a hit
Yes, this could definitely be a sleeper for sure. The popular pick would be Buxton of course but sometimes it's more fun to go with the guy that's having a Breakout.
No please not Buxton again, I don't know why we need certain players to have 3/4/5 different cards, personally I would love to use new players from the Twins I haven't used before. Arraez would be perfect.
Yep exactly. Arraez to me should be a no brainer. Best avg. in baseball.
-
Wish Jonah Heim would have made reserve for catcher. Would’ve loved that for the Rangers. Maybe SDS can give us an all star snub pack. Lol
-
Pujols and Cabrera double collection rewards 99 overalls...a guy can wish
-
@grux19_mlbts said in All Star Program Prediction thread::
Pujols and Cabrera double collection rewards 99 overalls...a guy can wish
I think either them or judge and acuna since they got most votes
-
I will say I’m not very excited for another CJ Cron. The Rockies have way too many 1B options already but he’ll be a nice filler/bench bat until a higher OVR Helton drops.
