Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...
-
@matt_42187_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@texas10pt_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@matt_42187_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@aaronjw76_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
and not die at the [censored] track.
I've had HRs with way less power to this location but trout... warning track power lol
https://twitter.com/MaddenNate1/status/1520956332257558530?s=20&t=Y448aMLudd-627br8lz47w
That’s pretty bad. I wonder what the elevation is for that park?
That's Laughing Mountain....Should have been gone.
That’s not laughing mountain. It’s Barnes. That’s why I was asking what’s the elevation is.
Barnes Canyon? The two look the same to me except left field. Barnes always had a much lower elevation than LM but someone earlier said they brought it down to sea level. Still IMO your hit should have been gone to me.
-
Geez how deep is that fence? Center says 420 so I am guessing that part of the fence is maybe 440?
-
@texas10pt_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@matt_42187_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@texas10pt_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@matt_42187_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@aaronjw76_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
and not die at the [censored] track.
I've had HRs with way less power to this location but trout... warning track power lol
https://twitter.com/MaddenNate1/status/1520956332257558530?s=20&t=Y448aMLudd-627br8lz47w
That’s pretty bad. I wonder what the elevation is for that park?
That's Laughing Mountain....Should have been gone.
That’s not laughing mountain. It’s Barnes. That’s why I was asking what’s the elevation is.
Barnes Canyon? The two look the same to me except left field. Barnes always had a much lower elevation than LM but someone earlier said they brought it down to sea level. Still IMO your hit should have been gone to me.
Look at the bottom of the hitting feedback. I thought it was laughing as well before I noticed the stadium name. That probably had something to do with it.
-
You have to be a kid…your crying about not hitting a HR in a video game.
Lol….sound familiar?????????????????????
-
I don't normally agree with these and instead come in with a "hardest hit ball in statcast era was a double play", but considering the park, dimensions and the player, this 100% should have been gone lol
-
Agreed. If it's online competitive, 100%. "Stick skills reign supreme" -- NOT.
Any PP with a 100+ power guy should be gone, anywhere save Polo Grounds.
-
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
Agreed. If it's online competitive, 100%. "Stick skills reign supreme" -- NOT.
Any PP with a 100+ power guy should be gone, anywhere save Polo Grounds.
My PP always falls short.
-
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
While I agree not all PPs are the same (especially mine), this instance that PP should have been a long dong. Pitcher attributes, stamina, confidence should not have kept that PP short.
-
Just curious? How far is that ball supposed to go?
450?
480?It looks like he hit it off Brian Wilson (Hr/9 rating 88) and hit it to the part of the field that has a 430-440 foot fence.
I'm not saying that it should not be a HR, just that it does not seem as clear cut as others are making it out to be. That was still hit around 420 ft and a HR in almost every other stadium.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Blahblahblah.
ONE HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE POWER.
PERFECT-PERFECT.
Pinpoint perfect pitch shouldn't matter. Unless the wind is blowing in 25 mph, shouldn't matter. Pitcher confidence, HR/9, H/9...shouldn't matter.
So long as SDS stands by competitive mode being "stick skills reign supreme," none of that should matter.
125 power, perfect-perfect is all that should matter.
-
@ikasnu_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
While I agree not all PPs are the same (especially mine), this instance that PP should have been a long dong. Pitcher attributes, stamina, confidence should not have kept that PP short.
I disagree, I am not saying that should not have been a HR but I think everything matters Hitters attri, and Pitchers Attri the inning the condition IE wind, looks to be hit to the furthest part of the ball park, how do they code that into the game also matters, Something on attr by pitchers or the conditions of the park or what velo do you need vs Pitching attr to hit it out of that park in that location all matters. What is the percentage of that ball being hit out in that field with that pitcher and that hitter in that part of the game. Just bringing some light of why that may have not a perfect perfect HR. Frustrating for the hitter yes indeed. If we knew how this game was designed and coded then we would have more of an understanding on why it plays the way it does online. We will never know that. Other thing to considers is if User hitting used square to hit that then yeah probably should have gone out but with x or o that may have been the difference and what level was the game on, R, VET, AS, HOF, LEG all matters, IMO
-
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Blahblahblah.
ONE HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE POWER.
PERFECT-PERFECT.
Pinpoint perfect pitch shouldn't matter. Unless the wind is blowing in 25 mph, shouldn't matter. Pitcher confidence, HR/9, H/9...shouldn't matter.
So long as SDS stands by competitive mode being "stick skills reign supreme," none of that should matter.
125 power, perfect-perfect is all that should matter.
but pitcher attribute have to matter hitting is not the only thing that matter in this game, if pitching does not matter then why have them just go play HR Derby, saying Perfect Perfect pitches do not matter in this game is ignorant. Not saying that pitch was. Look at the location of that pitch it was up and was not down the middle of the plate. What button did you use to swing with.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@ikasnu_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
While I agree not all PPs are the same (especially mine), this instance that PP should have been a long dong. Pitcher attributes, stamina, confidence should not have kept that PP short.
I disagree, I am not saying that should not have been a HR but I think everything matters Hitters attri, and Pitchers Attri the inning the condition IE wind, looks to be hit to the furthest part of the ball park, how do they code that into the game also matters, Something on attr by pitchers or the conditions of the park or what velo do you need vs Pitching attr to hit it out of that park in that location all matters. What is the percentage of that ball being hit out in that field with that pitcher and that hitter in that part of the game. Just bringing some light of why that may have not a perfect perfect HR. Frustrating for the hitter yes indeed. If we knew how this game was designed and coded then we would have more of an understanding on why it plays the way it does online. We will never know that. Other thing to considers is if User hitting used square to hit that then yeah probably should have gone out but with x or o that may have been the difference and what level was the game on, R, VET, AS, HOF, LEG all matters, IMO
No wind online so toss that one out. But in this instance hes just a smidge under the ball with max power and a perfect swing. The ball should be gone, Mike Trout IRL hits that ball a minimum 450 ft. Difficulty doesn't matter, only argument i could see is whether or not this was an X swing or an O swing. If OP is circle swinging, then I change my stance and say "nah brah". Any other swing, I think it should be a HR.
-
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Please don’t speak sensible on this forum- i think it gets you banned because I see so little people doing it
-
@ikasnu_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@ikasnu_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
While I agree not all PPs are the same (especially mine), this instance that PP should have been a long dong. Pitcher attributes, stamina, confidence should not have kept that PP short.
I disagree, I am not saying that should not have been a HR but I think everything matters Hitters attri, and Pitchers Attri the inning the condition IE wind, looks to be hit to the furthest part of the ball park, how do they code that into the game also matters, Something on attr by pitchers or the conditions of the park or what velo do you need vs Pitching attr to hit it out of that park in that location all matters. What is the percentage of that ball being hit out in that field with that pitcher and that hitter in that part of the game. Just bringing some light of why that may have not a perfect perfect HR. Frustrating for the hitter yes indeed. If we knew how this game was designed and coded then we would have more of an understanding on why it plays the way it does online. We will never know that. Other thing to considers is if User hitting used square to hit that then yeah probably should have gone out but with x or o that may have been the difference and what level was the game on, R, VET, AS, HOF, LEG all matters, IMO
No wind online so toss that one out. But in this instance hes just a smidge under the ball with max power and a perfect swing. The ball should be gone, Mike Trout IRL hits that ball a minimum 450 ft. Difficulty doesn't matter, only argument i could see is whether or not this was an X swing or an O swing. If OP is circle swinging, then I change my stance and say "nah brah". Any other swing, I think it should be a HR.
I can agree with that. If X I can still see that ball in that park not clearing the fence, square should have been gone, I have hit some perfect perfect use X a lot of them fall short of the fence and it is like really. I get the frustration.
-
@suntlacrimae50_mlbts said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
@dbarmonstar_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
You all act like the pitcher should not matter at all, I did not look at it, what inning, Who was the pitcher, What is the pitcher Attributes, Was the pitch a perfect perfect pitch? All that plays a part as well. Not every perfect perfect hit should be a HR. So many other factors. Was the Wind blowing in? What time of day I am sure matters.
Blahblahblah.
ONE HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE POWER.
PERFECT-PERFECT.
Pinpoint perfect pitch shouldn't matter. Unless the wind is blowing in 25 mph, shouldn't matter. Pitcher confidence, HR/9, H/9...shouldn't matter.
So long as SDS stands by competitive mode being "stick skills reign supreme," none of that should matter.
125 power, perfect-perfect is all that should matter.
Just say you don’t watch or never played baseball without actually saying it- at times I do feel a bit sorry for SDS bc of ppl like you
Is the game perfect- no( those diving slides and foul tips need fixing)
But a person made a perfect and correct response to the issue at hand and all you can say is “wahwah 125power P/P should be a HR” lol
-
Interesting this thread has generated the discussion is has. Nice to see actual discussion.
Some notes:
- It was whatever spring training difficulty was as I was my 3rd game into RS
- Chase Utley took Wilson yard as the batter before Trout. He had thrown 8 pitches including a HR before Trout came to the plate
- X swing with Trout
My issue with the result isn't so much that game but we have all hit no doubt HR's from hitters with sub 90 power that were early (or late) so when someone lands a PP with 125 power off a pitcher than JUST gave up a HR then it kinda should be a HR IMO. I'd argue that stance for anyone here even if it was against me.
It's not like it was vs Randy Johnson.
-
@aaronjw76_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
Interesting this thread has generated the discussion is has. Nice to see actual discussion.
Some notes:
- It was whatever spring training difficulty was as I was my 3rd game into RS
- Chase Utley took Wilson yard as the batter before Trout. He had thrown 8 pitches including a HR before Trout came to the plate
- X swing with Trout
My issue with the result isn't so much that game but we have all hit no doubt HR's from hitters with sub 90 power that were early (or late) so when someone lands a PP with 125 power off a pitcher than JUST gave up a HR then it kinda should be a HR IMO. I'd argue that stance for anyone here even if it was against me.
It's not like it was vs Randy Johnson.
Yeah, I think your argument is valid, so many people complain about not getting hits with PP. PP should be player max exit velo and with 125 power should be max of max exit velo and if launch angle is not a line drive, so upper part of PCI, then no way should it not be gone, unless you had some massive wind, which isn't in RS.
It seems clear to me that they overcorrected from last year. None of us like seeing the RNG in the game, but its there and when we do it's a very hard pill to swallow.
-
@aaronjw76_psn said in Perfect with 125 power should be a HR no matter the ballpark...:
Interesting this thread has generated the discussion is has. Nice to see actual discussion.
Some notes:
- It was whatever spring training difficulty was as I was my 3rd game into RS
- Chase Utley took Wilson yard as the batter before Trout. He had thrown 8 pitches including a HR before Trout came to the plate
- X swing with Trout
My issue with the result isn't so much that game but we have all hit no doubt HR's from hitters with sub 90 power that were early (or late) so when someone lands a PP with 125 power off a pitcher than JUST gave up a HR then it kinda should be a HR IMO. I'd argue that stance for anyone here even if it was against me.
It's not like it was vs Randy Johnson.
I understand what you are saying, Question would be what part of the field did Utley hit the HR, I get it the arguement of late and early, even using X. It will be interesting to know if a player has hit an early or late in that that park at that location in the park, with what hitter and pitcher. I am not saying you are wrong. I understand your point of view.
