Who has the worst swing in the game?
-
Is a swing just about optics? Or does it actually matter for somthing in game
-
@boduke82 said in Who has the worst swing in the game?:
Chipper.
This is impossibly blasphemous!
I know that I've done awful with Willson Ramos when I was grinding innings with Mets. I've also done weirdly horrible with Alex Bregman this year, which is weird because I killed it with him last year.
But out of every player, Josh Bell. I don't know why he had to go and redo his motion captured swing and ruin it. His swing in 19 was the best in the game.
-
@BodamEscapePlan said in Who has the worst swing in the game?:
@boduke82 said in Who has the worst swing in the game?:
Chipper.
This is impossibly blasphemous!
I know that I've done awful with Willson Ramos when I was grinding innings with Mets. I've also done weirdly horrible with Alex Bregman this year, which is weird because I killed it with him last year.
But out of every player, Josh Bell. I don't know why he had to go and redo his motion captured swing and ruin it. His swing in 19 was the best in the game.
Same with Bregman, they must have removed the trash can quirk.
-
Piazza or Joe Carter
-
@olivegarden2 said in Who has the worst swing in the game?:
@raesONE said in Who has the worst swing in the game?:
Bo Bichette by a landslide
REALLY? I do great with his PL card off of my bench. My least favorite is Sandberg and it isn't even close for me
Yeah his stance is horrible and the way he loads up makes the timing window super awkward imo. I avoid him at all times.
-
Sheffield stands to close to the plate -
-
@buttmuncher150 said in Who has the worst swing in the game?:
Is a swing just about optics? Or does it actually matter for somthing in game
From my experience, the swing matters a lot. Some people have a slow bat swing, some are much faster. Who you hit well with can depend on the swing - I seem to hit better with players that have a faster swing style then a slower one. Other people are the opposite. Basically just find cards that you seem to hit well with and use them, sometimes their rating won't matter. If a guy is a 85 and you rake with him but suck with a 94 overall card, just stick with what works for you and use the 85.
-
@jrbufford1 said in Who has the worst swing in the game?:
Sheffield stands to close to the plate -
True, but once you get used to him, oh boy does he crush!! My fav hitter this year by far
-
I hate to say it because I really want to use him, but Rickey Henderson. Piazza as well.
-
Rickey would really be awesome if I could hit at all with him lol
-
Barry Larkin. Worst card I've used all year.
-
Dee Gordon
-
Buster Posey for me unfortunately
-
Honestly I've never noticed a gameplay difference in stances or swings. Hitter types I do notice a difference, so since I'm more of a fly ball hitter I'll do better with trout than I do with biggio and better with biggio than I do with gwynn. Obviously those guys all have different attributes so I'm using them more as an example than making a point about those players in particular
-
Joe “Perfect/Jammed” Carter
-
Gallos swing is so slow and awkward. It throws off my timing compared to the rest of my lineup.
-
people out here saying chipper and gallo have the worst swings in the game... how do i downvote?
-
@seannydrama7 said in Who has the worst swing in the game?:
The answer is objectively and unequivocally DJ LeMahieu, but if anyone has any candidates for Honorable Mention...let’s have ‘em!
I [censored] hate Mickey Mantle’s swing. Idk what it is but it’s so bad I can’t hit well with Mantle when I get to use his cards
-
Has to be Reggies, swing is so slow you would’ve thought he was swinging a log
-
For me just in the players I have had to use for anything so far it's that awful Brandon crawford card in the moments for one of the potm cards. Felt like he was swinging underwater. I figured it out but it threw me off so badly with everyone else
