Who’s your catcher?
-
Biggio right now, but his swing doesn’t necessarily do it for me. Posada has been killer in the events though so I might keep him around for a while. I tend to not have very good luck with catchers though. Last year I had over 100 ABs with just about every catcher in the game besides the BR Posada and never hit above .250 with any of them. Maybe I will go to the dark side and use a CAP at catcher. It will always be the best option at that position
-
@Jeviduty said in Who’s your catcher?:
@Nanthrax_1 said in Who’s your catcher?:
Carlos Santana FotF simply because I rake with him. It's about time for a defensive upgrade though.
I did the same for an insane amount of time but that arm gets exploited a hell of a lot. Also those passed balls in late innings when you're trying to close the game...hurts like hell. Love him though.
Ya, I've been rocking him for 2 months lol. I haven't had many passed balls, but ya, it's a free base to anyone with good speed against me.
You can't deny the switch hitting bat though. I think I'm around .340/.380/.580 with him, and I'll take an OPS over .900 from my C any day..I sucked with 92 Piazza.. I generally won't play with Yankees so no to 87 Sanchez. And I haven't chosen Posey yet..
Hoping for a high rated Gary Carter
-
CAP as of today but it’ll be Torre soon. Gary Sanchez POTM is also really good
-
I like Piazza a bit, JT Realmuto smashes the ball. I like Posada too....I posted this question last week and people raved about Rustchman
-
@yeahlexx said in Who’s your catcher?:
I have biggio back there but I can’t take his bat anymore. I just can’t hit with him and it sucks. Who are some good options?
Biggio's bat is great, hard to take it out of the lineup. It's his subpar blocking that ticks me off. I almost want to play him in LF and sit Minnie, and just deal with Posey only being a slap hitter vs righties.
-
i got the Posey 99 card he is nice good arm too i also loved the POTM Sanchez
-
POTM Sanchez. I can’t hit a thing with him, but a good arm. Will get the 99 Posey when I can.
-
POTM Sanchez hits bombs and his fielding isn't terrible but can gun down runners
-
@samguenther1987 said in Who’s your catcher?:
POTM Sanchez rakes and I personally like Joey Bart, I've also considered getting Posada. Piazza is also a option if you have the dodger LS done.
The only one out of those I do not have is Bart. I like Posada swing, Sanchez has been good for me. I can not hit with Piazza
-
@car_7488 said in Who’s your catcher?:
I use my cap best catcher in the game
CAP. Will always be my CAP. I'd sit Sandberg and play Biggio at 2nd if I ever get him if needed.
Part of the fun for DD for me is using a CAP, especially since their not completely broken like a few years ago.
-
@Khain24 said in Who’s your catcher?:
@car_7488 said in Who’s your catcher?:
I use my cap best catcher in the game
CAP. Will always be my CAP. I'd sit Sandberg and play Biggio at 2nd if I ever get him if needed.
Part of the fun for DD for me is using a CAP, especially since their not completely broken like a few years ago.
Mlb 17 all 99 cap R.I.P
-
@yeahlexx said in Who’s your catcher?:
I have biggio back there but I can’t take his bat anymore. I just can’t hit with him and it sucks. Who are some good options?
I’m in the exact same boat, I hit pretty well wkth Sandberg so it sucks even more I can’t touch anything with Craig. I’ve had success with my cap C I might go back to him
-
Posey and Posada
-
I used Sean Murphy's prospect card for a while. He's solid defensively. I've also been using Buster's HW card, which is, how do you say...really freakin good.
-
Posada. Switch hitter that hits well from both sides. I'm working on a CAP catcher, but might just get that Torre card next inning.
-
Was POTM Sanchez but just got posey from the rewards path.
-
@samguenther1987 said in Who’s your catcher?:
@DrewshBag420 said in Who’s your catcher?:
Posada...I hate him but I can't find a catcher that I have luck with. I might pick up Posey when I hit diamond
I've stayed away from Posey because I hear he doesn't hit that well but he may be my next target when I hit diamond.
I never thought I would hit well with posey but I smash with him - he plays first for me though
-
I go with Bart, Keibert Ruiz (not even joking), and the A’s Sean Murphy currently. I have Sanchez but didn’t hit well with him.
-
I use posey for now, but i'm just a couple cards away from completing the AL so I may end up putting biggio at catcher and moving posey to first.
-
Stick it out with Biggio. 90 speed at Catcher is too good to pass up
