I agree that what he did as a "Manager" is wrong & being banned from baseball is what he deserved. But that was as a "Manager" & NOT as a "Player". What he achieved as a player was thru honest merits & got more hits lifetime then anyone else which no one yet has been able to break or even come close with the only exception Ichiro coming some what close. That achievements alone should have him in the HOF. The ban should'nt have anything to do with it. Player / Manager are 2 different things & took place at different times. The ban is punishment enough with not being able to "work" in anyway at all within MLB. But keeping him out of the HOF for me is wrong. He did something no other player has been able to do & it's as well punishing the fans of that era such as myself.
General Discussion
13.8k
Topics
96.9k
Posts
-
Baseball Savant
Locked -
Charlie Hustle !!!!!!!
Locked Moved -
Stolen Base Moments
Locked -
Lineup Diversity
Locked -
-
-
Co-op mode
Locked -
I need help
Locked -
SS Billy Wagner and the stub sale
Locked Moved -
The Illuminati
Locked -
SS Eddie Mathews Price
Locked Moved -
Baseball gifts thread
Locked Moved -
-
DO NOT bring back stadium sounds
Locked Moved -
Betances to Mets
Locked Moved -
I pulled 6 Diamonds
Locked Moved -
Ryu to the Jays baby!
Locked Moved -
merry christmas to you guys
Locked Moved -
What is the Beta?
Locked Moved -
MLB 20 Different wishlist
Locked Moved