That would be more funny to me if something very similar hadn’t happened to me, twice, just yesterday.
First was a high pop up to second while I was giving Roberts a try, and he just stood there, with no catch animation activated, and the ball landed right next to him (I sold him after the game). The second was a fly to diamond defense Donnie Baseball and the [censored] thing nearly landed on his head. Again, no catch animation despite standing in the marker with little blue rings encircling him.
Is this a thing, now, or just weird luck?