I've noticed a few of threads regarding player wishlists since I started jumping on this forum yesterday. I'm going to edit and keep an official tally on this post to keep track since from what I understand SDS monitors these forums. I'm adding my requests and will update as people post.
List your requests (including duplicates of whats already here for the tally.) I will tally notate specific years/variations next to a player but all requests for that specific player will be added to the total tally.
*Please rename duplicates of players you already see here to add to tally. I will comment on suggestions you send with an up vote if I agree and add to total as well.
This tally now includes the votes from the recent thread "SDS Calls You Get To Make 3 Cards...What Are They?": https://forums.theshow.com/topic/39477/sds-calls-you-get-to-make-3-cards-what-are-they?page=1
Thank you @LORD OIMAK (if anyone can figure out how to tag him please let me know)
- Barry Bonds (73 HR Milestone) - 10
- Bo Jackson (1989 Breakout) - 8
- Roy Halladay (Postseason or Milestone) - 8
- Derek Jeter (3000 Hits Milestone) - 7
- Tim Lincecum - 7
- Sammy Sosa (1998 MVP) - 7
- Jose Canseco (40/40) - 6
- Randy Johnson - 6
- Mark McGwire - 6
- Nomar Garciapara - 5
- Joe DiMaggio - 5
- Troy Tulowitzki - 5
- Shoeless Joe Jackson - 5
- Dontrelle Willis (Rookie of the Year) - 5
- Satchel Paige (Signature) - 5
- Roger Clemens - 5
- Bernie Williams (Evolution, 1998) - 5
- Carlos Beltran (2004 Postseason) - 5
- Curt Schilling - 5
- Andres Gallarraga (1996) - 5
- Manny Ramirez (Postseason) - 5
- Alex Rodriguez - 4
- Barry Zito - 4
- Ryan Howard (2006 MVP) - 4
- Brad Lidge (Perfect Season) - 4
- Joe Mauer (2009 Awards) - 4
- Ted Williams - 4
- Mark Grace (1995) - 5
- Hideo Nomo (ROTY/No Hitter) - 4
- Mike Mussina - 4
- Kevin Mitchell (1989) - 4
- Josh Gibson (Signature) - 4
- Paul O'Neill - 4
- Tim Hudson (2003) - 4
- Miguel Tejada - 4
- Carl Yastrzemski (1967 Triple Crown) - 4
- Darryl Strawberry (Signature Series) - 4
- Dwight Gooden (Awards) - 4
- Chili Davis - 3
- Scott Rolen - 3
- Pete Rose - 3
- Vinny Castilla - 3
- Scott Broscius - 3
- Moises Alou - 3
- Mo Vaughn - 3
- Eric Chavez - 3
- David Wells - 3
- Hideki Matsui (2009 Postseason) - 3
- Francisco Rodriguez - 3
- Ichiro - 3
- Cool Papa Bell - 3
- Yogi Berra - 3
- Roger Maris - 3
- Bartolo Colon - 3
- Lance Berkman (Signature Series/All-Star) - 3
- Chase Utley (2009 Postseason) - 3
- Johan Santana (Cy Young/Prime) - 3
- Albert Belle (50 HR/50 2B) - 3
- Sandy Koufax - 3
- Roy Campanella - 3
- Frank Robinson - 3
- Carlton Fisk - 3
- Howard Johnson (3 time 30/30) - 3
- Andy Pettite (Most Postseason Starts) - 2
- Juan Gonzalez - 2
- Bobby Bonilla - 2
- Edgar Renteria - 2
- Mark Texiera - 2
- Ubaldo Jimenez - 2
- Deion Sanders - 2
- C.C. Sabathia - 2
- David Cone - 2
- Pat Hentgen - 2
- Kenny Rogers - 2
- Jake Peavy - 2
- Ramon Martinez - 2
- Willie McGee - 2
- Steve Carlton - 2
- Bobby Abreu (30-30 Club) - 2
- Charlie Gehringer - 2
- Hank Greenberg - 2
- Jason Varitek - 2
- Chad Bradford - 2
- Ellis Burks - 2
- Tony Batista - 2
- Julio Franco - 2
- Craig Counsell - 2
- Chuck Knoblauch - 2
- Kevin Youkilis - 2
- Luis Tiant - 2
- Jered Weaver - 2
- Johnny Mize - 2
- Mark Mulder - 2
- Hiroki Kiroda - 2
- Tim Raines - 2
- Jimmy Key - 2
- Marquis Grissom - 2
- Kevin Appier - 2
- Jose Reyes - 2
- Dustin Pedroia (2008 MVP) - 2
- Hack Wilson - 2
- Hideki Irabu - 2
- Charlie Hough - 2
- Derek Lee (2005) - 2
- Tim Wakefield - 2
- Phil Neikro - 2
- David Wright (2007 Breakout) - 2
- Jeff Kent (MVP) - 2
- Chris Sabo (ROTY/1991 All-Star) - 2
- Billy Ripken (1989) - 2
- Bobby Bonds (Prime) - 2
- Jimmy Rollins (2007 MVP) - 2
- Yorvit Torreabla (Signature) - 2
- Jose Rijo - 2
- Carlos Gonzalez (Cycle) - 2
- Dave Conepcion - 2
- Fernando Tatis Sr. (Milestone 2 GS 1 Inning) - 2
- Jose Bautista (Postseason/54 HR) - 2
- Kirk Gibson (1988) - 2
- Jesse Barfield (1986) - 2
- George Bell (1987 All-Star) - 2
- Ron Gant (1990 Breakout/Milestone 30/30) - 2
- Carlos Delgado 2000 Silver Slugger -2
- Tino Martinez (1997 Home Run Race) - 1
- Michael Jordan (Prospects) - 1
- Jim Abbott - 1
- Edgardo Alfonso - 1
- Vlad Guerrero Sr. - 1
- Kevin Brown - 1
- Greg Vaughn - 1
- Aramis Ramirez (Prime) - 1
- Derek Lowe (All Star) - 1
- Jermaine Dye (Silver Slugger) - 1
- Ugeth Urbina - 1
- Justin Morneau - 1
- Jonathan Broxton - 1
- Victor Martinez - 1
- Mario Soto - 1
- Ted Kluszewski - 1
- Tom Browning - 1
- Jim Maloney - 1
- Vince Coleman - 1
- John Rocker - 1
- Magglio Ordonez - 1
- Carlos Pena - 1
- Daisuke Matsuzaka - 1
- Rogers Hornsby - 1
- Rafael Palmeiro - 1
- Paul Assenmacher - 1
- Chuck Finley - 1
- Charles Nagy - 1
- Javier Vasquez - 1
- Brad Radke - 1
- Chris Carpenter - 1
- Don Drysdale - 1
- Ron Cey - 1
- Steve Sax (Rookie) - 1
- Bill Madlock - 1
- Mel Ott - 1
- Andy Van Slyke - 1
- Paul Waner - 1
- Al Simmons - 1
- Ed Walsh - 1
- Cap Anson - 1
- Kid Nichols - 1
- Eddie Collins - 1
- Tris Speaker - 1
- Rube Waddell - 1
- Doc Ellis - 1
- Ben Sheets - 1
- Cole Hamels (2008 Postseason) - 1
- Jayson Werth - 1
- Carlos Ruiz (Chooch) - 1
- Pat Burrell (Pat the Bat) - 1
- John Kruk - 1
- Mitch "Wild Thing" Williams - 1
- Juan Samuel - 1
- Darren Daulton - 1
- Richard [Dlck] Allen - 1
- Greg Luzinski - 1
- Fred Lynn - 1
- Bobby Grich (1979 2B) - 1
- Ron Santo - 1
- Willie Horton - 1
- Bob Uecker - 1
- Mark Fidrych - 1
- Lou Whitaker - 1
- Jose Valverde (Papa Grande) - 1
- Brandon Inge - 1
- Kirk Gibson - 1
- Johnny Damon (Red Sox) - 1
- Terry Steinbach - 1
- Dave Stewart - 1
- Todd Van Poppel (Future Stars) - 1
- Ozzie Canseco (Rookie) - 1
- Kazuo Matsui - 1
- Willy Taveras - 1
- Latroy Hawkins - 1
- Brian Fuentes - 1
- Jeff Francis - 1
- Jorge De La Rosa - 1
- Eric Young - 1
- Matt Holliday - 1
- Aaron Rowand - 1
- Brian Giles - 1
- Nick Swisher - 1
- Tug McGraw - 1
- Mickey Vernon - 1
- Rusty Stubbs - 1
- Cecil Fielder - 1
- Ted Simmons - 1
- Gary Gaetti - 1
- Kent Hrbek - 1
- BJ Surhoff - 1
- Jim Rice - 1
- Thurman Munson - 1
- Dave Winfield - 1
- Danny Tartabull - 1
- Vernon Wells - 1
- Richie Sexson - 1
- Mike Cameron - 1
- Jeff Conine - 1
- Dave Stieb - 1
- Eric Karros - 1
- Reggie Sanders - 1
- Robin Ventura - 1
- Ken Caminiti - 1
- Ray Lankford - 1
- Jack McDowell - 1
- Jamie Moyer - 1
- Frank White - 1
- Dan Quisenberry - 1
- Hal McRae - 1
- Willie Wilson - 1
- Darrell Porter - 1
- Willie Randolph - 1
- Pedro Guerrero - 1
- Josh Hamilton (MVP) - 1
- CJ Wilson - 1
- Jose Fernandez (ROTY) - 1
- Richard Hidalgo - 1
- Preston Wilson - 1
- Carlos Lee - 1
- Jeromy Burnitz - 1
- Alan Trammel - 1
- Magglio Ordonez - 1
- Todd Walker (1998 Breakout) - 1
- Daniel Murphy (2015 Postseason) - 1
- Ben McDonald - 1
- Mark Eichorn - 1
- Brady Anderson (1996 Breakout) - 1
- R.A. Dickey - 1
- Shawn Estes - 1
- Mike Marshall (1974) - 1
- Chuck Klein (1930) - 1
- George Sisler (1920) - 1
- Alex Gordon - 1
- Marty Cordova - 1
- Melvin Mora (Silver Slugger) - 1
- Chris Hoiles (2nd Half/Breakout) - 1
- Andre Dawson (MVP) - 1
- Rick Sutcliffe (Cy Young) - 1
- Jim Leyritz - 1
- Joe Rudi (Postseason) - 1
- Del Unser - 1
- JR Richard - 1
- Eric Gagne (84 Save Streak) - 1
- Brock Holt (Postseason Cycle) - 1
- Shawn Green (19 Total Bases) - 1
- Javy Lopez (2003) - 1
- Larry Walker 1997 MVP - 1
- Dexter Fowler (5 Steal) - 1
- Al Hrabosky (1975) - 1
- Steve Balboni (1985) - 1
- Marco Estrada - 1
- Lenny Dykstra (1993) - 1
- Mickey Tettleton - 1
- Norm Charlton (1992 All-Star) - 1
- Dave Stieb (1984 All-Star) - 1
- Bob Horner (1993 Prime) - 1
- Sidd Finch - 1
- Carlos Guillen - 1
....sorry had to.