Hints:
- New Legend (as indicated on the main menu)
 - Multiple Silver Slugger Awards
 - Multiple All-Star Appearances
 
Players who meet the criteria, by position (excluding current players/known player rights based on 2021/previous years):
P:
- Don Robinson
 - Rick Rhoden
 - Carlos Zambrano
 

- Brian McCann
 - Lance Parrish
 - Joe Mayer
 - Mickey Tettleton
 - Carlton Fisk
 
1B:
- Cecil Cooper
 - Carlos Delgado
 - Mark Teixeira
 - Jack Clark
 - Will Clark
 - Cecil Fielder
 - Andres Galarraga
 - Adrian Gonzalez
 - Justin Morneau
 
2B:
- Julio Franco
 - Jeff Kent
 - Chase Utley
 - Lou Whitaker
 - Carlos Baerga
 - Bret Boone
 - Chuck Knoblauch
 - Daniel Murphy
 - Manny Trillo
 
3B:
- Adrian Beltre
 - Matt Williams
 - Vinny Castilla
 - Alex Rodriguez
 - Troy Glaus
 - Howard Johnson
 - Dean Palmer
 - Tim Wallach
 - David Wright
 
SS:
- Derek Jeter
 - Edgar Renteria
 - Hubie Brooks
 - Dave Concepcion
 - Hanley Ramirez
 - Miguel Tejada
 - Garry Templeton
 - Troy Tulowitzki
 
OF:
- Barry Bonds
 - Manny Ramirez
 - Juan Gonzalez
 - Sammy Sosa
 - Albert Belle
 - George Bell
 - Jose Canseco
 - Josh Hamilton
 - Magglio Ordonez
 - Ichiro
 - Larry Walker
 - Moises Alou
 - Dusty Baker
 - Carlos Beltran
 - Bobby Bonilla
 - Ellis Burks
 - Jose Cruz
 - Dwight Evan’s
 - David Justice
 - Carlos Lee
 - Dave Parker
 - Jim Rice
 - Darryl Strawberry
 - Andy Van Slyke
 - Willie Wilson
 
I tried my best to eliminate guys that are current, or have had cards in years past idk who SDS has the rights to anymore seems like guys come and go & with recent retirements it makes it tough.
But, who would you guys like to see?? Who do you think it will be!