• Categories
  • Popular
  • Dev Tracker
Skins
  • Default (The Show 26)
  • No Skin
  • The Show 23
  • Dark
  • The Show 24
  • The Show 25
  • The Show 26
Collapse
THESHOW.COM
Game Games Support Support My Account My Account

Community Forum

JackD290_MLBTSJ

JackD290_MLBTS

@JackD290_MLBTS
About
Posts
71
Topics
33
Followers
0
Following
0

Posts

Recent Best Controversial

    How do you motivate yourself to keep playing this mode when scripting and rubber banding ultimately decide your stats?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    Every season is the same, first 4 months you can do what you want, then after the AS break the great ‘rein it in’ begins and the game starts making you tank for no apparent reason other than to keep your stats down.

    I’ve reached a point now where I’ve just given into the fact that user input doesn’t mean a great deal. I’m not a player I’m just a viewer watching a computer force a predetermined outcome in front of me as I press buttons.

    You can only be as good as the computer wants you to be and you can only be as bad as the computer wants you to be.

    How do you guys motivate yourself to keep picking up the game even though you know it’s not really fair, you’re just at the mercy of the RNG gods?


  • I Don’t Think I Can Finish My Pitching Career
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    @StinkyMcPooter_XBL I don’t believe it’s the difficulty because I have been very successful at times on this level but 60%-70% of the games feel crammed with BS like fielders falling on their backside when trying to pick up a weakly hit ball along the ground or batters smashing everything in sight regardless of how well execute my pitches.

    If I execute poorly and give up a home run, absolutely fair enough, no arguments from me. But more often than not I’m being punished for playing well.

    I just played a game against the Astros and my batters scored 0 runs until I got taken off after the 6th inning at which point they finally remembered how to swing a bat and put up 8 runs in the last 3 innings. That’s not something that’s difficulty based, that’s something that happens all the time and is clearly coded into the game, I can only assume, to keep my wins down.

    I don’t feel like I’m a game player, I feel like a game spectator. The game pushes towards certain outcomes and I’m merely pushing buttons and watching the script unfold. I played this difficulty as a batter and felt like I had way more control of the outcome of games.


  • I Don’t Think I Can Finish My Pitching Career
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    I did a RTTS career as a batter and I had my issues but I got through it and it was generally OK.

    I’ve now tried doing a career as a pitcher and the amount of BS that’s being thrown my way by the the CPU is actually overwhelming and making the game feel almost pointless to play.

    Pitch location feels absolutely irrelevant, I perfectly execute my pitches to the corners and the game either forces them down the middle for batters to smash out of the yard or continually forces them out of the zone so that I either give up walks or have no choice but to give the batter something to crush.

    Certain batters get preferential treatment by the game and are able to just constantly foul everything off until they get bored of doing so and then hit a no doubt homer, by which point my pitch count is ridiculous.

    Umpires repeatedly favouring batters when calling balls and strikes, again feels like a built in mechanic to make you throw closer to the middle so that home runs can be dished out to whoever wants one.

    Way too many fielding errors on routine balls that allow runners on base to come round and score and hits that would normally be singles turn into doubles or triples.

    And to top it all off my team point blank refuses to score runs until I leave the field. Either that or I’m holding a one run lead into the 7th which they then blow.

    Everything in this game as a pitcher feels like a system that can be used by the game to force a certain outcome and it doesn’t even hide it. You just get spammed with BS constantly and made to feel like user input and skill have no effect whatsoever on the outcome of your time on the mound.

    This game is pure RNG and scripting, I would advise anyone who’s thinking about doing RTTS, just be a batter. You’ll still encounter BS but it’ll be way less than if you’re a pitcher.

    For a while I would just quit and restart a game if I felt like I was being cheated by the CPU but now I’m just thinking what’s the point? I play video games to have fun not to be constantly counteracting scripting and bad dice rolls.

    I’ve honestly never played a game so determined to shut down success and force failure.


  • Fed Up of Certain Batters Getting Preferential Treatment
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    @StinkyMcPooter_XBL Can’t bean him because he’s followed by Olson who constantly gets hits against me regardless of where I throw and how well I execute so beaning him is essentially conceding a run.

    Also [censored] Bobby Witt Jr, I don’t know what SDS were thinking when they juiced this guy. There’s literally nothing I can do to stop him getting on base and scoring.


  • Fed Up of Certain Batters Getting Preferential Treatment
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    I absolutely despise Brooks Lee, this guy needs to go [censored] himself.

    Every time I come up against this guy the game seems to give him a free pass to just foul off endless pitches until I either walk him, bean him or he gets a hit.

    And then he bats ahead of Matt Olson, another guy this game seems to ride the [censored] of.

    So everytime I play the Twins it’s a guarantee that Lee will get on base and Olson will hit him home.

    EVERY. [censored]. TIME.

    This game is an absolute joke.


  • They Really Need to Address Fielding Errors
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    I’m convinced that CPU fielding errors when you’re pitching are just another tool the game uses to script the outcome of certain games.

    The amount of times I hear: “Couldn’t glove it cleanly!” On a slow rolling ball to the shortstop who then fails to pick it up and allows runners on base and batters already on base to come in and score is a [censored] joke.

    I didn’t encounter any fielding errors at AA or AAA yet in the major leagues it’s happening most games.

    Sort out your scripted [censored] heap of a game SDS.


  • Starting Pitcher Not Getting Enough Wins?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    @PriorFir4383355_XBL I read somewhere that because I’m my team’s ace, I end up facing other team’s aces and that’s why my team don’t put up any runs?


  • Starting Pitcher Not Getting Enough Wins?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    @StinkyMcPooter_XBL Currently on 18 starts, 6 wins, 2 losses.

    Absolute joke that I’m getting robbed of a Cy Young because my team refuses to score runs until I leave the field.


  • Starting Pitcher Not Getting Enough Wins?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    I play for a pretty good Guardians team who are top of the division and winning loads of games. My starting pitcher is leading the AL in strikeouts and has an ERA under 2.

    Yet when my guy’s games come around, the team either wait until I’m off the field before they score or I’m holding a one run lead into the 7th inning which they then blow late on.

    I really want to win a Cy Young but the thing holding me back is my number of wins every season. Has anyone encountered this and what can I do about it?


  • Does Anyone Else Just Quit and Reload When CPU Cheats?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    @DookieD19_XBL You must be playing on a lower difficulty and/or have maxed out stats.

    Fastballs up and in are regularly getting crushed and I’m executing them perfectly. The game either forces them down the middle or allows batters to just smack them out of the stadium regardless.

    I’m guessing that’s to keep my stats down and to fulfill the predetermined outcome of certain games because nothing else seems like a logical reason.

    If I make a mistake and don’t execute I get it, but its happening on pitches where I’m not doing anything wrong and it feels like hitters just have free roam to destroy whenever they feel like it.


  • Does Anyone Else Just Quit and Reload When CPU Cheats?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    @sbchamps17_NSW It’s not one bad game, it’s a ton of bad games. The postseason one is the one that has been loaded with the most BS so far.

    Constantly having my perfect pitches crushed and fielders repeatedly making errors which allow runners to come home and turning hits that would normally be singles into doubles and triples. I didn’t even see this amount of errors on routine plays at AA level and now, at the top level, they seem to be everywhere.

    This game is void of logic, it’s just randomness and scripting.


  • Does Anyone Else Just Quit and Reload When CPU Cheats?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    @StinkyMcPooter_XBL The scripting is unacceptable.

    I’m currently playing game 7 of the ALCS and I’ve given up 4 runs and 7 hits in the second inning because the Red Sox batters are just hitting everything I throw regardless of where I throw it or how well I execute it. I’m perfectly executing pitches to the corners of the zone and my guy is just throwing meatballs right down the middle for guys to smash out the park, what a joke.

    This game is ridiculous, it doesn’t reward skill it’s just a load of predetermined [censored].

    I don’t mind being punished for making mistakes but I’m being punished for playing well so what’s the point in continuing to play when it seems like the game is forcing certain outcomes.


  • Does Anyone Else Just Quit and Reload When CPU Cheats?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    I’m at the point now where I just quit the app and replay the games constantly until I get one that feels fair because every game insists on making me give a bucket load of runs away despite the fact I’m locating my pitches perfectly and there’s nothing else I can physically do but sit back and watch everyone smash me around like a piñata.

    This game is so scripted it’s not even trying to hide it. There’s no logic and skill isn’t rewarded. You just get to a point of doing ‘too well’ and the game has to force you through [censored] so it can keep your stats down.

    Screw this scripted [censored] heap of a game. SDS you suck and so does your scripted fest of a baseball game.


  • Why is my pitcher suddenly giving up home runs for fun?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    @TripleH-4481_PSN Absolute joke, what a terrible game. RNG the show strikes again. User input means zero, everything is a dice roll. No reward for skill, just a dice roll and hope for the best. Trash.


  • Why is my pitcher suddenly giving up home runs for fun?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    After writing this post, I went back to playing and on the first pitch (a perfectly executed fastball to the high inside corner) it got smashed out the park.

    F*** this trashy game and its scripted mechanics.


  • Why is my pitcher suddenly giving up home runs for fun?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    I haven’t changed the difficulty or any sliders, I’ve upgraded my stats and I’m executing my pitches perfectly and yet all of a sudden I’m giving up multiple home runs every game?

    I really hate this game sometimes…


  • Zero Point Pitching on Legend Difficulty
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    The game just straight up cheats on legend difficulty.

    Fielders fumble routine catches and pick ups resulting in singles becoming doubles and triples with runners already on base coming into score.

    Pitch location means absolutely nothing, the game will constantly push your pitches right down the middle of the zone even though you execute them perfectly into the corners.

    Every hit you give up is either a no doubt home run or a perfect gap shot triple, bloopers and infield singles don’t seem to exist on this difficulty.

    Every batter will constantly foul off pitches to an unrealistic level just so that they can smash pitch number 15 out the park leaving you with no reward for crawling through innings 30+ pitches at a time.

    The game seems to have players that it lives up the backside of who are allowed to just smash home runs at will no matter what pitch you throw in what location.

    Absolutely no point in throwing anything outside the zone ever because batters never swing or chase any pitches.

    HOF fame pitching is too easy so WTF am I supposed to do now?


  • CPU Fielding in This Game is a Joke
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    Every time a batter hits a rolling ball to the outfield, my players do that thing where they go to scoop it off the floor but miss it and fall over allowing runs to come in and hits that would normally be singles turn into doubles and triples.

    Honestly, I thought playing RTTS as a batter was full of BS, try playing as a pitcher, it’s even worse!


  • How To Get Around Batters That Keep Fouling Off Pitches?
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    Just had an inning where I threw over 40 pitches and conceded 3 runs because the batters just fouled off everything I threw regardless of how well I threw it.

    I understand that some batters are incredibly good at covering the plate but this is getting ridiculous.

    Very clear that when the game wants to score against you there is nothing you can do about it which makes user input feel irrelevant.

    Is there something I can do to stop this happening so often? Throwing balls doesn’t work, they just lay off every time.


  • My Pitcher Got Called Up Too Soon, Getting Destroyed…
  • JackD290_MLBTSJ JackD290_MLBTS

    @StinkyMcPooter_XBL I’m not a fan of dynamic. When I did dynamic as a batter I found that it escalates really fast but then when you start struggling it doesn’t really go down. It lets you do just enough to stay at a level where you mostly suck but not so bad that it lowers the difficulty back down

X Instagram Facebook YouTube Twitch Discord TikTok
Major League Baseball Players Association Major League Baseball Sony Interactive Entertainment PlayStation Studios San Diego Studio ESRB ESRB Certificate
Terms of Use Privacy Policy TheShow.com Community Code of Conduct MLB The Show Online Code of Conduct MLB The Show Games

“PlayStation Family Mark”, “PlayStation”, “PlayStation Studios logo”, “PS5 Logo”, and “Play Has No Limits” are registered trademarks or trademarks of Sony Interactive Entertainment Inc. ©2026 Sony Interactive Entertainment LLC. MLB and MiLB trademarks and copyrights are used with permission of Major League Baseball. Visit MLB.com and MiLB.com. Officially Licensed Product of MLB Players, Inc. MLBPA trademarks, copyrighted works and other intellectual property rights are owned and/or held by MLBPA and may not be used without the written consent of MLBPA or MLB Players, Inc. Visit MLBPLAYERS.com, the Players Choice on the web. The Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum trademarks and copyrights are used with permission of the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, Inc., as applicable. Visit the official website of the Hall of Fame at BaseballHall.org. Official Licensee-Major League Alumni Marketing, Inc. © MLAM. Officially Licensed by the Negro Leagues Baseball Museum, Inc. Kansas City, MO. Stubs is a registered trademark or trademark of Sony Interactive Entertainment LLC. Nintendo Switch is a trademark of Nintendo. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

  • Login

  • Login or register to search.
  • First post
    Last post
0
  • Categories
  • Popular
  • Dev Tracker
  • Login

  • Login or register to search.