AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza

SDS

I’ve been hitting well with Piazza, but his inability to throw anyone out on the base paths is killing me. Was wondering if the AS Realmuto would be the better alternative? I could sell Piazza and still have some left over for others.

Just curious what others think, and if there’s possibly a better option.

Thanks y’all!

SDS

I’m biased, but for real, JT ASG is the single best catcher in the game. I know loads of people use Schwarber, but he can’t throw anyone out either. JT hits both sides really well, and his reverse stats play extremely well when opponents try to play matchup games with him.

SDS

I'm seeing ridiculous hits with cards like Piazza, Mookie and Clemente.

I hit a ball 4 feet outside in the gap with Mookie earlier today. Had no business making contact let alone driving it in the gap.

That what happens when these cards are programmed to perform a certain way regardless of input. The attributes are so out of hand. They'll be 150 instead of 125 soon. Can almost guarantee it.

SDS

@ccarr77_psn said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

I'm seeing ridiculous hits with cards like Piazza, Mookie and Clemente.

I hit a ball 4 feet outside in the gap with Mookie earlier today. Had no business making contact let alone driving it in the gap.

That what happens when these cards are programmed to perform a certain way regardless of input. The attributes are so out of hand. They'll be 150 instead of 125 soon. Can almost guarantee it.

Why stop at one 150 and 4 feet outside? I want 200 and the ability to swing an oak tree trunk.

SDS

@quinnymcquinn said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

@ccarr77_psn said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

I'm seeing ridiculous hits with cards like Piazza, Mookie and Clemente.

I hit a ball 4 feet outside in the gap with Mookie earlier today. Had no business making contact let alone driving it in the gap.

That what happens when these cards are programmed to perform a certain way regardless of input. The attributes are so out of hand. They'll be 150 instead of 125 soon. Can almost guarantee it.

Why stop at one 150 and 4 feet outside? I want 200 and the ability to swing an oak tree trunk.

With IE you'll have 200 point attributes.

Remember a few years ago when Jung Ho Kang turned into Babe Ruth when his IE was up?

Me remembers. Boom-Shaka-Laka

SDS

@savagesteve74 said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

I’m biased, but for real, JT ASG is the single best catcher in the game. I know loads of people use Schwarber, but he can’t throw anyone out either. JT hits both sides really well, and his reverse stats play extremely well when opponents try to play matchup games with him.

I said it the first week the card came out. JT is unreal.

SDS

I’m a collection posada fan. Best catcher in the game IMO

SDS

@mrwonderful95 said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

I’m a collection posada fan. Best catcher in the game IMO

That's another great card.

SDS

@mrwonderful95 said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

I’m a collection posada fan. Best catcher in the game IMO

I forgot about Posada, I’ll have to give him a try too.

SDS

@mrwonderful95 said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

I’m a collection posada fan. Best catcher in the game IMO

I want to try him out. I’ve never been wow’ed by his cards. But he’s at a good market price and I love switch hitters. I struggle righty on righty

SDS

I prefer ASG JT, Awards Posada, and HRD Salvy but I keep them all because I want all the friggin cards. I only ever sell duplicates. But if you really have to choose, I'd take JT beteen the 2.

SDS

@quinnymcquinn said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

@mrwonderful95 said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

I’m a collection posada fan. Best catcher in the game IMO

I want to try him out. I’ve never been wow’ed by his cards. But he’s at a good market price and I love switch hitters. I struggle righty on righty

I wouldn't say Posada is better than JT but he's really good. He gets on base all time and smacks a few homers here and there. Easily a top 5 catcher IMO.

SDS

Team JT here and I was late to the party so only have him parallel 4. Even without the defense, he is an amazing hitter.

SDS

@xthedoc_mlbts said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

I’ve been hitting well with Piazza, but his inability to throw anyone out on the base paths is killing me. Was wondering if the AS Realmuto would be the better alternative? I could sell Piazza and still have some left over for others.

Just curious what others think, and if there’s possibly a better option.

Thanks y’all!

If you do, wait till tomorrow when the all star pack is in the daily program; his price will inevitably drop.

SDS

I think the real question is JT vs Schwarbs. I still think JT wins. Piazza sucks IMO. I had him and sold him. He doesnt do anything better than JT plus his swing is awful.

SDS

@mrwonderful95 said in AS Realmuto vs SIG Piazza:

I’m a collection posada fan. Best catcher in the game IMO

Collection Posada kills Awards Posada

SDS

Realmuto! Not even a contest!

SDS

Am I an outlier for playing with Santana. He isn’t anything sexy. Just does the job.