Outfield starters

SDS

I am currently RF - Griffey Jr., CF - Willie Mays, LF - Ichiro....
I am about to get Babe Ruth.....who should I replace? I am thinking Ichiro?

SDS

Yup.
My outfield is set with Ruth, Mays and Griffey

SDS

Ichiro should be replaced for sure

SDS

bye bye itchy [censored] hello pig man

SDS

Belli Yelli Willi

SDS

LF to RF: Babe, Mays, Bellinger. I keep Ichiro on the bench and sub him in for Ruth late in games and for pinch running/hitting.

SDS

LF: ?????????????
CF: SS Griffey
RF: Finest Bellinger
I don't have a slam dunk player for left, though I tend to lean towards Acuna, Kaline, and Ichiro for various reasons. I don't have Mays and I really can't be bothers to play the market to buy the 5 or so most expensive LS cards

SDS

@ImDFC said in Outfield starters:

LF: ?????????????
CF: SS Griffey
RF: Finest Bellinger
I don't have a slam dunk player for left, though I tend to lean towards Acuna, Kaline, and Ichiro for various reasons. I don't have Mays and I really can't be bothers to play the market to buy the 5 or so most expensive LS cards

I have tried the 3 guys you named and they can all work but it can also be whose swing can work for you because I had Kaline and wanted to make him work but couldn't hit with him. I finally finished the live series collection and so have Mays with Griffey and Bellinger but another name I would throw out to you that people sometimes forget is Finest Ketel Marte. I had him at LF because his fielding will be around 74 there but he has great hitting stats and switch hitter on top of that. He was my 3rd guy out there before getting Mays.

SDS

babe Lf mays CF belli RF
griffey and trout on the bench
babe is more than serviceable even robbed a HR against me lol

SDS

I’m rocking Mays, Trout and Belli right now

SDS

I recently but him in LF and he is game changing....Rickey Henderson. Dude does it all

SDS

Williams, Cobb, Griffey start - Mays and Trout on the bench for speed, defense, platoon advantage if necessary.

SDS

Side bar my most recent OF is LF Hend, CF Cobb and RF Griffey.

Cobb was always in LF prior. He is a waaaaaay better CF. Possibly second only to Mays

SDS

Side bar my most recent OF is LF Hend, CF Cobb and RF Griffey.

Cobb was always in LF prior. He is a waaaaaay better CF. Possibly second only to Mays

SDS

Please delete

SDS

Please delete double post

SDS

I am seeing a lot of people choosing Belli over Griffey. I have both. I will say I haven't used Belli enough to know how I hit with him. I believe I am over .330 with him but with not a huge sample size. Griffey I am .340 and he is the player I have used most. I have heard a lot of people complain about Griffeys glitchy defense but have not experienced it myself. Is Belli more sound defensively?

SDS

Just benched Griffey. I get his animation constantly and I’m sick of it. I know some hardly see it but I do no matter where I put him. I put Belinger in RF

SDS

@Oachs83 said in Outfield starters:

Just benched Griffey. I get his animation constantly and I’m sick of it. I know some hardly see it but I do no matter where I put him. I put Belinger in RF

I get his bad animations every 2-3 games I feel always at bad times. I now run belli May's and ruth. trout comes in for ruth late game and Griffey is my 1st lefty off the bench cause man he can still hit

SDS

@Baracesilk said in Outfield starters:

I am seeing a lot of people choosing Belli over Griffey. I have both. I will say I haven't used Belli enough to know how I hit with him. I believe I am over .330 with him but with not a huge sample size. Griffey I am .340 and he is the player I have used most. I have heard a lot of people complain about Griffeys glitchy defense but have not experienced it myself. Is Belli more sound defensively?

I honestly have never had the bad animations with Griffey and he is probably my third or fourth best bat. Bellinger is my best hitter followed by Donaldson surprisingly which is why he will never leave 3rd. But I have Griffey with Belli and Mays. Between them three the outfield defense is set. I will say though between Griffey and Belli I have to give Belli the edge in hitting because he has a great swing and can make contact even if not the best PCI placement.