Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally

SDS

I've noticed a few of threads regarding player wishlists since I started jumping on this forum yesterday. I'm going to edit and keep an official tally on this post to keep track since from what I understand SDS monitors these forums. I'm adding my requests and will update as people post.

List your requests (including duplicates of whats already here for the tally.) I will tally notate specific years/variations next to a player but all requests for that specific player will be added to the total tally.

*Please rename duplicates of players you already see here to add to tally. I will comment on suggestions you send with an up vote if I agree and add to total as well.

This tally now includes the votes from the recent thread "SDS Calls You Get To Make 3 Cards...What Are They?": https://forums.theshow.com/topic/39477/sds-calls-you-get-to-make-3-cards-what-are-they?page=1

Thank you @LORD OIMAK (if anyone can figure out how to tag him please let me know)

  • Barry Bonds (73 HR Milestone) - 10
  • Bo Jackson (1989 Breakout) - 8
  • Roy Halladay (Postseason or Milestone) - 8
  • Derek Jeter (3000 Hits Milestone) - 7
  • Tim Lincecum - 7
  • Sammy Sosa (1998 MVP) - 7
  • Jose Canseco (40/40) - 6
  • Randy Johnson - 6
  • Mark McGwire - 6
  • Nomar Garciapara - 5
  • Joe DiMaggio - 5
  • Troy Tulowitzki - 5
  • Shoeless Joe Jackson - 5
  • Dontrelle Willis (Rookie of the Year) - 5
  • Satchel Paige (Signature) - 5
  • Roger Clemens - 5
  • Bernie Williams (Evolution, 1998) - 5
  • Carlos Beltran (2004 Postseason) - 5
  • Curt Schilling - 5
  • Andres Gallarraga (1996) - 5
  • Manny Ramirez (Postseason) - 5
  • Alex Rodriguez - 4
  • Barry Zito - 4
  • Ryan Howard (2006 MVP) - 4
  • Brad Lidge (Perfect Season) - 4
  • Joe Mauer (2009 Awards) - 4
  • Ted Williams - 4
  • Mark Grace (1995) - 5
  • Hideo Nomo (ROTY/No Hitter) - 4
  • Mike Mussina - 4
  • Kevin Mitchell (1989) - 4
  • Josh Gibson (Signature) - 4
  • Paul O'Neill - 4
  • Tim Hudson (2003) - 4
  • Miguel Tejada - 4
  • Carl Yastrzemski (1967 Triple Crown) - 4
  • Darryl Strawberry (Signature Series) - 4
  • Dwight Gooden (Awards) - 4
  • Chili Davis - 3
  • Scott Rolen - 3
  • Pete Rose - 3
  • Vinny Castilla - 3
  • Scott Broscius - 3
  • Moises Alou - 3
  • Mo Vaughn - 3
  • Eric Chavez - 3
  • David Wells - 3
  • Hideki Matsui (2009 Postseason) - 3
  • Francisco Rodriguez - 3
  • Ichiro - 3
  • Cool Papa Bell - 3
  • Yogi Berra - 3
  • Roger Maris - 3
  • Bartolo Colon - 3
  • Lance Berkman (Signature Series/All-Star) - 3
  • Chase Utley (2009 Postseason) - 3
  • Johan Santana (Cy Young/Prime) - 3
  • Albert Belle (50 HR/50 2B) - 3
  • Sandy Koufax - 3
  • Roy Campanella - 3
  • Frank Robinson - 3
  • Carlton Fisk - 3
  • Howard Johnson (3 time 30/30) - 3
  • Andy Pettite (Most Postseason Starts) - 2
  • Juan Gonzalez - 2
  • Bobby Bonilla - 2
  • Edgar Renteria - 2
  • Mark Texiera - 2
  • Ubaldo Jimenez - 2
  • Deion Sanders - 2
  • C.C. Sabathia - 2
  • David Cone - 2
  • Pat Hentgen - 2
  • Kenny Rogers - 2
  • Jake Peavy - 2
  • Ramon Martinez - 2
  • Willie McGee - 2
  • Steve Carlton - 2
  • Bobby Abreu (30-30 Club) - 2
  • Charlie Gehringer - 2
  • Hank Greenberg - 2
  • Jason Varitek - 2
  • Chad Bradford - 2
  • Ellis Burks - 2
  • Tony Batista - 2
  • Julio Franco - 2
  • Craig Counsell - 2
  • Chuck Knoblauch - 2
  • Kevin Youkilis - 2
  • Luis Tiant - 2
  • Jered Weaver - 2
  • Johnny Mize - 2
  • Mark Mulder - 2
  • Hiroki Kiroda - 2
  • Tim Raines - 2
  • Jimmy Key - 2
  • Marquis Grissom - 2
  • Kevin Appier - 2
  • Jose Reyes - 2
  • Dustin Pedroia (2008 MVP) - 2
  • Hack Wilson - 2
  • Hideki Irabu - 2
  • Charlie Hough - 2
  • Derek Lee (2005) - 2
  • Tim Wakefield - 2
  • Phil Neikro - 2
  • David Wright (2007 Breakout) - 2
  • Jeff Kent (MVP) - 2
  • Chris Sabo (ROTY/1991 All-Star) - 2
  • Billy Ripken (1989) - 2
  • Bobby Bonds (Prime) - 2
  • Jimmy Rollins (2007 MVP) - 2
  • Yorvit Torreabla (Signature) - 2
  • Jose Rijo - 2
  • Carlos Gonzalez (Cycle) - 2
  • Dave Conepcion - 2
  • Fernando Tatis Sr. (Milestone 2 GS 1 Inning) - 2
  • Jose Bautista (Postseason/54 HR) - 2
  • Kirk Gibson (1988) - 2
  • Jesse Barfield (1986) - 2
  • George Bell (1987 All-Star) - 2
  • Ron Gant (1990 Breakout/Milestone 30/30) - 2
  • Carlos Delgado 2000 Silver Slugger -2
  • Tino Martinez (1997 Home Run Race) - 1
  • Michael Jordan (Prospects) - 1
  • Jim Abbott - 1
  • Edgardo Alfonso - 1
  • Vlad Guerrero Sr. - 1
  • Kevin Brown - 1
  • Greg Vaughn - 1
  • Aramis Ramirez (Prime) - 1
  • Derek Lowe (All Star) - 1
  • Jermaine Dye (Silver Slugger) - 1
  • Ugeth Urbina - 1
  • Justin Morneau - 1
  • Jonathan Broxton - 1
  • Victor Martinez - 1
  • Mario Soto - 1
  • Ted Kluszewski - 1
  • Tom Browning - 1
  • Jim Maloney - 1
  • Vince Coleman - 1
  • John Rocker - 1
  • Magglio Ordonez - 1
  • Carlos Pena - 1
  • Daisuke Matsuzaka - 1
  • Rogers Hornsby - 1
  • Rafael Palmeiro - 1
  • Paul Assenmacher - 1
  • Chuck Finley - 1
  • Charles Nagy - 1
  • Javier Vasquez - 1
  • Brad Radke - 1
  • Chris Carpenter - 1
  • Don Drysdale - 1
  • Ron Cey - 1
  • Steve Sax (Rookie) - 1
  • Bill Madlock - 1
  • Mel Ott - 1
  • Andy Van Slyke - 1
  • Paul Waner - 1
  • Al Simmons - 1
  • Ed Walsh - 1
  • Cap Anson - 1
  • Kid Nichols - 1
  • Eddie Collins - 1
  • Tris Speaker - 1
  • Rube Waddell - 1
  • Doc Ellis - 1
  • Ben Sheets - 1
  • Cole Hamels (2008 Postseason) - 1
  • Jayson Werth - 1
  • Carlos Ruiz (Chooch) - 1
  • Pat Burrell (Pat the Bat) - 1
  • John Kruk - 1
  • Mitch "Wild Thing" Williams - 1
  • Juan Samuel - 1
  • Darren Daulton - 1
  • Richard [Dlck] Allen - 1
  • Greg Luzinski - 1
  • Fred Lynn - 1
  • Bobby Grich (1979 2B) - 1
  • Ron Santo - 1
  • Willie Horton - 1
  • Bob Uecker - 1
  • Mark Fidrych - 1
  • Lou Whitaker - 1
  • Jose Valverde (Papa Grande) - 1
  • Brandon Inge - 1
  • Kirk Gibson - 1
  • Johnny Damon (Red Sox) - 1
  • Terry Steinbach - 1
  • Dave Stewart - 1
  • Todd Van Poppel (Future Stars) - 1
  • Ozzie Canseco (Rookie) - 1
  • Kazuo Matsui - 1
  • Willy Taveras - 1
  • Latroy Hawkins - 1
  • Brian Fuentes - 1
  • Jeff Francis - 1
  • Jorge De La Rosa - 1
  • Eric Young - 1
  • Matt Holliday - 1
  • Aaron Rowand - 1
  • Brian Giles - 1
  • Nick Swisher - 1
  • Tug McGraw - 1
  • Mickey Vernon - 1
  • Rusty Stubbs - 1
  • Cecil Fielder - 1
  • Ted Simmons - 1
  • Gary Gaetti - 1
  • Kent Hrbek - 1
  • BJ Surhoff - 1
  • Jim Rice - 1
  • Thurman Munson - 1
  • Dave Winfield - 1
  • Danny Tartabull - 1
  • Vernon Wells - 1
  • Richie Sexson - 1
  • Mike Cameron - 1
  • Jeff Conine - 1
  • Dave Stieb - 1
  • Eric Karros - 1
  • Reggie Sanders - 1
  • Robin Ventura - 1
  • Ken Caminiti - 1
  • Ray Lankford - 1
  • Jack McDowell - 1
  • Jamie Moyer - 1
  • Frank White - 1
  • Dan Quisenberry - 1
  • Hal McRae - 1
  • Willie Wilson - 1
  • Darrell Porter - 1
  • Willie Randolph - 1
  • Pedro Guerrero - 1
  • Josh Hamilton (MVP) - 1
  • CJ Wilson - 1
  • Jose Fernandez (ROTY) - 1
  • Richard Hidalgo - 1
  • Preston Wilson - 1
  • Carlos Lee - 1
  • Jeromy Burnitz - 1
  • Alan Trammel - 1
  • Magglio Ordonez - 1
  • Todd Walker (1998 Breakout) - 1
  • Daniel Murphy (2015 Postseason) - 1
  • Ben McDonald - 1
  • Mark Eichorn - 1
  • Brady Anderson (1996 Breakout) - 1
  • R.A. Dickey - 1
  • Shawn Estes - 1
  • Mike Marshall (1974) - 1
  • Chuck Klein (1930) - 1
  • George Sisler (1920) - 1
  • Alex Gordon - 1
  • Marty Cordova - 1
  • Melvin Mora (Silver Slugger) - 1
  • Chris Hoiles (2nd Half/Breakout) - 1
  • Andre Dawson (MVP) - 1
  • Rick Sutcliffe (Cy Young) - 1
  • Jim Leyritz - 1
  • Joe Rudi (Postseason) - 1
  • Del Unser - 1
  • JR Richard - 1
  • Eric Gagne (84 Save Streak) - 1
  • Brock Holt (Postseason Cycle) - 1
  • Shawn Green (19 Total Bases) - 1
  • Javy Lopez (2003) - 1
  • Larry Walker 1997 MVP - 1
  • Dexter Fowler (5 Steal) - 1
  • Al Hrabosky (1975) - 1
  • Steve Balboni (1985) - 1
  • Marco Estrada - 1
  • Lenny Dykstra (1993) - 1
  • Mickey Tettleton - 1
  • Norm Charlton (1992 All-Star) - 1
  • Dave Stieb (1984 All-Star) - 1
  • Bob Horner (1993 Prime) - 1
  • Sidd Finch - 1
  • Carlos Guillen - 1
SDS

Barry Zito, Mike Mussina, Jake Peavy

SDS

Roy Halladay
Randy Johnson
Kevin Brown
Manny Ramirez
Mo Vaughn
Andres Galaraga
Mark Texiera
Juan Gonzalez
Paul o neill
Ellis Burks
Bobby Bonilla
Jose Canseco
Greg Vaughn
Chilli Davis
Marquis Grissom
Vinny Castila
Moises Alou
Scott Rollen
Nomar Garciapara
Edgar Renteria

There's tons more but that seems like a good start to me.

SDS

2009 Postseason Hideki Matsui.

Relatively meh DS/CS round but monster WS against the Phillies. Going to try and avoid "requesting" the obviously/popular ones.

SDS

-Can Happen
Ryan Howard (2006 MVP)
Brad Lidge Perfect Season
Bobby Abreu 30-30 club
Johan Santana Cy Young
Aramis Ramirez Prime
Derek Lowe All Star
Andy Pettite Most Postseason Starts
Lance Berkman Sig Series
Jermaine Dye Silver Slugger

-Can't happen
Curt Schilling
Roger Clemens
Albert Belle
Steve Carlton
Joe Jackson
Ugeth Urbina

SDS

Jose Rijo
Chris Sabo
Paul O'Neil
Frank Robinson
Kevin Mitchell
Mario Soto
Darryl Strawberry
Randy Johnson
Bo Jackson
Ted Kluszewski
Dave Concepcion
Tom Browning
15 year old Joe Nuxhall. Lol
Jim Maloney

SDS

@khain24_psn said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

2009 Postseason Hideki Matsui.

Relatively meh DS/CS round but monster WS against the Phillies. Going to try and avoid "requesting" the obviously/popular ones.

Upvoting Hideki as well.

SDS

Barry Bonds. That is all.

SDS

@lazy_toast_psn said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

Barry Zito, Mike Mussina, Jake Peavy

Upvoting Mussina and Zito

SDS

@khain24_psn said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

2009 Postseason Hideki Matsui.

SDS

My list of players SDS should bring back

Tulowitzki
Beltran
Ichiro
Sabathia
Colon
Mauer
Justin Morneau
Tiant
Broxton
Victor Martinez
Francisco Rodriguez

SDS

Where is Bo Jackson? He was mentioned a bunch of times

SDS

@samguenther1987 said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

Roy Halladay
Randy Johnson
Kevin Brown
Manny Ramirez
Mo Vaughn
Andres Galaraga
Mark Texiera
Juan Gonzalez
Paul o neill
Ellis Burks
Bobby Bonilla
Jose Canseco
Greg Vaughn
Chilli Davis
Marquis Grissom
Vinny Castila
Moises Alou
Scott Rollen
Nomar Garciapara
Edgar Renteria

There's tons more but that seems like a good start to me.

Upvoting Alou, Nomar, Renteria, Texiera, Mo Vaughn and Chili Davis

SDS

@bostondirtdog21 said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

Where is Bo Jackson? He was mentioned a bunch of times

Upvoting Bo

SDS

@raesone_psn said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

Barry Bonds. That is all.

Upvoting Barry

SDS

@raesone_psn said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

Barry Bonds. That is all.

Even if it's a Reggie Stocker I would take it lol

SDS

Mark Grace
Tim Raines
Slammin Sammy Sosa
Terry Pendleton
Willie McGee
Vince Coleman
Yogi Berra
Roger Maris
Chili Davis
Hack Wilson
Bob Uecker

SDS

@samguenther1987 said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

@raesone_psn said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

Barry Bonds. That is all.

Even if it's a Reggie Stocker I would take it lol

That would be a great add for the real OG’s in here

SDS

@imdfc_psn said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

-Can Happen
Ryan Howard (2006 MVP)
Brad Lidge Perfect Season
Bobby Abreu 30-30 club
Johan Santana Cy Young
Aramis Ramirez Prime
Derek Lowe All Star
Andy Pettite Most Postseason Starts
Lance Berkman Sig Series
Jermaine Dye Silver Slugger

-Can't happen
Curt Schilling
Roger Clemens
Albert Belle
Steve Carlton
Joe Jackson
Ugeth Urbina

What's your reasoning between can and can't, just curious.

SDS

@samguenther1987 said in Official Legendary/Historical Player Wishlist & Tally:

My list of players SDS should bring back

Tulowitzki
Beltran
Ichiro
Sabathia
Colon
Mauer
Justin Morneau
Tiant
Broxton
Victor Martinez
Francisco Rodriguez

Upvoting Sabathia, Colon and Beltran