Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19
-
There are tons of Rookie diamonds in the game for players that either never became diamond or currently aren't. I say who cares, give the people a diamond Rookie Judge and arbitrarily jack up the vision a little bit to make it more usable.
-
@eatyum said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@cvogsfashow said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@SaveFarris said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
He didn't participate in either HRD or ASG.
He didn't really deserve either Topps Now or POTM.
He didn't really do all that much in the Postseason.
He career doesn't yet warrant a Signature Series card.
He didn't warrant a Finest.Not really sure what card you think he should have had.
I definitely agree he didn't do anything to deserve a 2019 card but he should of had some sort of FB 2017 card. He is a big name and SDS could of made some doe off of it.
Honestly, I don't think they would have made "doe" off it. Would it be cool to have? Absolutely! But the first response people would have to the card would be ThE vIsIoN is to low for HOF.
To the competitive player, no he would not of been desirable. However, there is far more players who sit anywhere from 699 and under compared to 700+. He also had the most jersey sold I believe in 2018 and 2019 so he is a big name and a lot of individuals would of went after a high diamond version of him.
-
@LankyRyan said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
There are tons of Rookie diamonds in the game for players that either never became diamond or currently aren't. I say who cares, give the people a diamond Rookie Judge and arbitrarily jack up the vision a little bit to make it more usable.
I agree with this. Pete Alonso did fantastic things this past year and look at his finest card. Keeping in mind he had a 26% K rate and 2017 Judge had a 31% K rate. The man has 83 visions on his card with 92 contact R and 80 contact L. He batted .266 versus R and .240 versus L. Judge in 2017 batted .298 versus R and .230 versus L. They would be very similar cards IMO.
-
@cvogsfashow said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@eatyum said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@cvogsfashow said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@SaveFarris said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
He didn't participate in either HRD or ASG.
He didn't really deserve either Topps Now or POTM.
He didn't really do all that much in the Postseason.
He career doesn't yet warrant a Signature Series card.
He didn't warrant a Finest.Not really sure what card you think he should have had.
I definitely agree he didn't do anything to deserve a 2019 card but he should of had some sort of FB 2017 card. He is a big name and SDS could of made some doe off of it.
Honestly, I don't think they would have made "doe" off it. Would it be cool to have? Absolutely! But the first response people would have to the card would be ThE vIsIoN is to low for HOF.
To the competitive player, no he would not of been desirable. However, there is far more players who sit anywhere from 699 and under compared to 700+. He also had the most jersey sold I believe in 2018 and 2019 so he is a big name and a lot of individuals would of went after a high diamond version of him.
Sure, but I'm thinking in relative terms here. Often the most expensive cards are the most desirable competitive ones. The only exceptions are the things like early event rewards or LS gatekeepers. I'm sure a lot of players would want a high version of him, but he wouldn't be expensive enough that SDS would make a lot of money off it. I was never saying it wouldn't be popular or that it shouldn't exist.
-
@NicholasHowardT5 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@DriveByTrucker17 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@NicholasHowardT5 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@cvogsfashow said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@SaveFarris said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
He didn't participate in either HRD or ASG.
He didn't really deserve either Topps Now or POTM.
He didn't really do all that much in the Postseason.
He career doesn't yet warrant a Signature Series card.
He didn't warrant a Finest.Not really sure what card you think he should have had.
I definitely agree he didn't do anything to deserve a 2019 card but he should of had some sort of FB 2017 card. He is a big name and SDS could of made some doe off of it.
It would be the same card as his live series ?
I don’t think you realize how good his 2017 season was.
52 homeruns 208 K’s. .284 avg it would be his live series card like I said before lmao.
8.3 fWAR
174 wRC+
1.049 OPS
18.7 BB%
0.61 BB/KMuch better than his next two years. Plus his defense wasn’t as good in 2017, so the card would look much different than his LS.
-
@ImDFC said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
Poor Yankee fans. Come back when you have 2 whole legends In a game
Just because SDS hates your team doesn't mean other teams don't deserve cards
Incoming "you wouldn't understand Cardinals fan"
-
@DriveByTrucker17 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@NicholasHowardT5 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@DriveByTrucker17 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@NicholasHowardT5 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@cvogsfashow said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@SaveFarris said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
He didn't participate in either HRD or ASG.
He didn't really deserve either Topps Now or POTM.
He didn't really do all that much in the Postseason.
He career doesn't yet warrant a Signature Series card.
He didn't warrant a Finest.Not really sure what card you think he should have had.
I definitely agree he didn't do anything to deserve a 2019 card but he should of had some sort of FB 2017 card. He is a big name and SDS could of made some doe off of it.
It would be the same card as his live series ?
I don’t think you realize how good his 2017 season was.
52 homeruns 208 K’s. .284 avg it would be his live series card like I said before lmao.
8.3 fWAR
174 wRC+
1.049 OPS
18.7 BB%
0.61 BB/KMuch better than his next two years. Plus his defense wasn’t as good in 2017, so the card would look much different than his LS.
Now turn those stats you just said and how they’d affect his ratings ? Vision? Nah staying as his his vision is horrible. Power ? It already shows in his power stats. Walks? He already has like 107 discipline if I’m not mistaken
-
Rookies have ended Diamonds because they get started a lot high than Judge did when they royally screw themselves making him a common that ended diamond. These guys start mid silver for the most part now, nobody is going Common - Diamond like Judge and making everyone millions of coins. People had hundreds of him.
-
@SaveFarris said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
He didn't participate in either HRD or ASG.
He didn't really deserve either Topps Now or POTM.
He didn't really do all that much in the Postseason.
He career doesn't yet warrant a Signature Series card.
He didn't warrant a Finest.Not really sure what card you think he should have had.
I love Judge but I agree with this. If anything Betts and of course Joe Carter were more deserving
-
@ImDFC said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
Poor Yankee fans. Come back when you have 2 whole legends In a game
Pick a better team then
-
@NicholasHowardT5 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@DriveByTrucker17 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@NicholasHowardT5 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@DriveByTrucker17 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@NicholasHowardT5 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@cvogsfashow said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@SaveFarris said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
He didn't participate in either HRD or ASG.
He didn't really deserve either Topps Now or POTM.
He didn't really do all that much in the Postseason.
He career doesn't yet warrant a Signature Series card.
He didn't warrant a Finest.Not really sure what card you think he should have had.
I definitely agree he didn't do anything to deserve a 2019 card but he should of had some sort of FB 2017 card. He is a big name and SDS could of made some doe off of it.
It would be the same card as his live series ?
I don’t think you realize how good his 2017 season was.
52 homeruns 208 K’s. .284 avg it would be his live series card like I said before lmao.
8.3 fWAR
174 wRC+
1.049 OPS
18.7 BB%
0.61 BB/KMuch better than his next two years. Plus his defense wasn’t as good in 2017, so the card would look much different than his LS.
Now turn those stats you just said and how they’d affect his ratings ? Vision? Nah staying as his his vision is horrible. Power ? It already shows in his power stats. Walks? He already has like 107 discipline if I’m not mistaken
What I’m saying is that the card would absolutely be better in every offensive attribute, but would be worse on defense.
Which would make it much different than his LS card.
-
Aaron Judge lost a step or two
-
There were numerous players that did not get a Sig card. Eric Davis, Matt Kemp, Jason Giambi, Brett Boone, Alan Trammel, Vida Blue, Kenny Lofton to name a few. Yet they saw fit to give Sig cards to players like Travis Hafner, Matt Carpenter, Rick Ankiel, Kerry Wood, Aubrey Huff??? Doesn’t make much sense.
-
@mjfc_363 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
There were numerous players that did not get a Sig card. Eric Davis, Matt Kemp, Jason Giambi, Brett Boone, Alan Trammel, Vida Blue, Kenny Lofton to name a few. Yet they saw fit to give Sig cards to players like Travis Hafner, Matt Carpenter, Rick Ankiel, Kerry Wood, Aubrey Huff??? Doesn’t make much sense.
All of the guys you mentioned that didn’t get an SS card already had 90+ overall cards though. Sure, they definitely could’ve still gotten one, other players with 90+ overall cards still got SS cards. I’m sure SDS just didn’t feel the need to give those guys juiced up cards, for one reason or another.
On the other hand, every guy you mentioned that did get an SS card either didn’t get any other diamond cards, or only had a lower diamond card (Wood).
I’m sure circumstance played a major role as well. I doubt Hafner gets an SS card if the All-Star Game isn’t in cleveland. Rick Ankiel is just a novelty. Aubrey Huff was just to give the Rays another SS card, since they lack legends. Carpenter because one of the head DD guys is a big Cardinals fan apparently lol
-
Oh look another pointless complaint thread.
Judge hasn't been in the league long enough as of 19 to warrant a flashback. Stop bellyaching about this and wait 10 more days after today like the rest of us to see if you get what you want and then resume normal complaints.
-
This post is deleted!
-
@Maverick31762 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@DriveByTrucker17 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@mjfc_363 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
There were numerous players that did not get a Sig card. Eric Davis, Matt Kemp, Jason Giambi, Brett Boone, Alan Trammel, Vida Blue, Kenny Lofton to name a few. Yet they saw fit to give Sig cards to players like Travis Hafner, Matt Carpenter, Rick Ankiel, Kerry Wood, Aubrey Huff??? Doesn’t make much sense.
All of the guys you mentioned that didn’t get an SS card already had 90+ overall cards though. Sure, they definitely could’ve still gotten one, other players with 90+ overall cards still got SS cards. I’m sure SDS just didn’t feel the need to give those guys juiced up cards, for one reason or another.
On the other hand, every guy you mentioned that did get an SS card either didn’t get any other diamond cards, or only had a lower diamond card (Wood).
I’m sure circumstance played a major role as well. I doubt Hafner gets an SS card if the All-Star Game isn’t in cleveland. Rick Ankiel is just a novelty. Aubrey Huff was just to give the Rays another SS card, since they lack legends. Carpenter because one of the head DD guys is a big Cardinals fan apparently lol
So maybe the Giambi, Davis, Lofton group should have gotten SS while the comically bad Huff, Hafner, Carpenter group should’ve got the seasonal cardOh and more importantly Sig Joe Carter. Even the most depraved fan cannot possibly think Racist Huff is more deserving
I don't see what racism has to do with Joe Carter playing 400 more games but had the same career WAR as Huff.
-
@Maverick31762 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@DriveByTrucker17 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@mjfc_363 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
There were numerous players that did not get a Sig card. Eric Davis, Matt Kemp, Jason Giambi, Brett Boone, Alan Trammel, Vida Blue, Kenny Lofton to name a few. Yet they saw fit to give Sig cards to players like Travis Hafner, Matt Carpenter, Rick Ankiel, Kerry Wood, Aubrey Huff??? Doesn’t make much sense.
All of the guys you mentioned that didn’t get an SS card already had 90+ overall cards though. Sure, they definitely could’ve still gotten one, other players with 90+ overall cards still got SS cards. I’m sure SDS just didn’t feel the need to give those guys juiced up cards, for one reason or another.
On the other hand, every guy you mentioned that did get an SS card either didn’t get any other diamond cards, or only had a lower diamond card (Wood).
I’m sure circumstance played a major role as well. I doubt Hafner gets an SS card if the All-Star Game isn’t in cleveland. Rick Ankiel is just a novelty. Aubrey Huff was just to give the Rays another SS card, since they lack legends. Carpenter because one of the head DD guys is a big Cardinals fan apparently lol
So maybe the Giambi, Davis, Lofton group should have gotten SS while the comically bad Huff, Hafner, Carpenter group should’ve got the seasonal cardOh and more importantly Sig Joe Carter. Even the most depraved fan cannot possibly think Racist Huff is more deserving
Still stuck on the Joe Carter Sig? LOL He will be remembered for his clutch not for his average MLB career.
-
@cvogsfashow said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@Maverick31762 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@DriveByTrucker17 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
@mjfc_363 said in Aaron Judge did not get a single flashback in MLB 19:
There were numerous players that did not get a Sig card. Eric Davis, Matt Kemp, Jason Giambi, Brett Boone, Alan Trammel, Vida Blue, Kenny Lofton to name a few. Yet they saw fit to give Sig cards to players like Travis Hafner, Matt Carpenter, Rick Ankiel, Kerry Wood, Aubrey Huff??? Doesn’t make much sense.
All of the guys you mentioned that didn’t get an SS card already had 90+ overall cards though. Sure, they definitely could’ve still gotten one, other players with 90+ overall cards still got SS cards. I’m sure SDS just didn’t feel the need to give those guys juiced up cards, for one reason or another.
On the other hand, every guy you mentioned that did get an SS card either didn’t get any other diamond cards, or only had a lower diamond card (Wood).
I’m sure circumstance played a major role as well. I doubt Hafner gets an SS card if the All-Star Game isn’t in cleveland. Rick Ankiel is just a novelty. Aubrey Huff was just to give the Rays another SS card, since they lack legends. Carpenter because one of the head DD guys is a big Cardinals fan apparently lol
So maybe the Giambi, Davis, Lofton group should have gotten SS while the comically bad Huff, Hafner, Carpenter group should’ve got the seasonal cardOh and more importantly Sig Joe Carter. Even the most depraved fan cannot possibly think Racist Huff is more deserving
Still stuck on the Joe Carter Sig? LOL He will be remembered for his clutch not for his average MLB career.
You mean the Joe Carter that from 86 to 97 (12 seasons) was a sure bet/averaged 30 HRs/100 RBIs in an era that saw very few 40 HRs+ hitters? That "average" Joe Carter? He's basically a RH Fred McGriff. You have to put him in context of his era.
