What even is good PCI for???
-
So im not 100% sure if im just more terrible than I feel or if the game is just in a bad state currently.
I have sucked with MVP Trout however aside from K's all my outs have been extremely good PCI placement and good swing timing yet its 100% of the time a routine fly ball or worse a Perfect Perfect fly out to the wall against a righty. Yet I come up with SS Jimmy Rollins and a ball not even close to the PCI is a no doubters to the same part of the yard. Im sure you are aware but just incase you are not track MVP Trout has 125 power vs right handed pitchers and SS Jimmy has 77. How the HE double hockey sticks does 77 power hit it a good 100 feet further than 125 (maxed out power) its stuff like that, that makes me annoyed to play the game. I enjoy it but it gets annoying. Mind you I know im not a great player ill be lucky to make WS but I have a winning record but some of my Ls should have been Ws because swing timing wise I out played my opponent. I had 1 game i lost and my opponents legitimately had zero good swing timing and I have a majority good swing timing with about 15-20 Perfect Perfect outs. Yea in 20 Perfect Perfect hits i batted .000 and according to SDS getting a Perfect Perfect is supposed to be close to .800 fat crock of crud that was
-
Yeah, I'm going to need concrete proof that you went 0-20 on perfect/perfects, you should easily be able to provide that evidence because it tracks your perfects in game history. We can all see it by searching your name.
For instance, in your last game, all 3 perfects were hits.
I can't find any that list 20 perfect outs, weird right?
-
Every single lerson who has complained about perfect/perfect outs on this forum has been exxagerating. Every. Single. One. I was frustrated when I first got the game too and thought most of my perfect/perfects were outs then I tracked my own data and realized I was batting well over .800 on perfect/perfects.
-
@Kovz88 said in What even is good PCI for???:
Every single lerson who has complained about perfect/perfect outs on this forum has been exxagerating. Every. Single. One. I was frustrated when I first got the game too and thought most of my perfect/perfects were outs then I tracked my own data and realized I was batting well over .800 on perfect/perfects.
-
@Kovz88 said in What even is good PCI for???:
Every single lerson who has complained about perfect/perfect outs on this forum has been exxagerating. Every. Single. One. I was frustrated when I first got the game too and thought most of my perfect/perfects were outs then I tracked my own data and realized I was batting well over .800 on perfect/perfects.
This is just not true. I have never exaggerated. Nobody is batting ,800 on perfect/perfects. Nobody. The reason I know this is because no matter what mode I play in whether it is a moment, event, showdown, or RS I hit well below .500 on perfect/perfects. And that is being generous.
-
@eatyum said in What even is good PCI for???:
Yeah, I'm going to need concrete proof that you went 0-20 on perfect/perfects, you should easily be able to provide that evidence because it tracks your perfects in game history. We can all see it by searching your name.
For instance, in your last game, all 3 perfects were hits.
I can't find any that list 20 perfect outs, weird right?
You seem like a knowledgeable stalker. How/where do you find this info? On this site? In game?
I know for a fact I had at least 1 last game with either Thome or Killebrew and it merely fluttered to the outfield. I had another with perfect pci placement in the same game but with only good timing that did the exact same thing. Yet this sad game lets rng decide who gets a hit instead of skill. And of course my opponent who flails at every pitch gets bailed out in the bottom of the 5th and gets handed the victory. -
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@eatyum said in What even is good PCI for???:
Yeah, I'm going to need concrete proof that you went 0-20 on perfect/perfects, you should easily be able to provide that evidence because it tracks your perfects in game history. We can all see it by searching your name.
For instance, in your last game, all 3 perfects were hits.
I can't find any that list 20 perfect outs, weird right?
You seem like a knowledgeable stalker. How/where do you find this info? On this site? In game?
I know for a fact I had at least 1 last game with either Thome or Killebrew and it merely fluttered to the outfield. I had another with perfect pci placement in the same game but with only good timing that did the exact same thing. Yet this sad game lets rng decide who gets a hit instead of skill. And of course my opponent who flails at every pitch gets bailed out in the bottom of the 5th and gets handed the victory.You can find it either in-game by going to your game history, or you can click the "my account" on the top right of this site, then "mlb 20 dashboard".
In that dashboard is a bar where you came type in your or someone else's PSN and see their game history, the P/P are listed at the bottom
-
And for those who say RNG doesn't exist then please explain to my feeble mind how perfect/perfects result in pop-ups while there are many times where the pci isn't even on the ball and it flies over the wall. The game has to have a way of determining when a hit will occur or not and pci placement and timing is not the be all end all.
-
@eatyum said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@eatyum said in What even is good PCI for???:
Yeah, I'm going to need concrete proof that you went 0-20 on perfect/perfects, you should easily be able to provide that evidence because it tracks your perfects in game history. We can all see it by searching your name.
For instance, in your last game, all 3 perfects were hits.
I can't find any that list 20 perfect outs, weird right?
You seem like a knowledgeable stalker. How/where do you find this info? On this site? In game?
I know for a fact I had at least 1 last game with either Thome or Killebrew and it merely fluttered to the outfield. I had another with perfect pci placement in the same game but with only good timing that did the exact same thing. Yet this sad game lets rng decide who gets a hit instead of skill. And of course my opponent who flails at every pitch gets bailed out in the bottom of the 5th and gets handed the victory.You can find it either in-game by going to your game history, or you can click the "my account" on the top right of this site, then "mlb 20 dashboard".
In that dashboard is a bar where you came type in your or someone else's PSN and see their game history, the P/P are listed at the bottom
In-game all I see is box score and game log. Where in there does it show contact relults?
-
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@eatyum said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@eatyum said in What even is good PCI for???:
Yeah, I'm going to need concrete proof that you went 0-20 on perfect/perfects, you should easily be able to provide that evidence because it tracks your perfects in game history. We can all see it by searching your name.
For instance, in your last game, all 3 perfects were hits.
I can't find any that list 20 perfect outs, weird right?
You seem like a knowledgeable stalker. How/where do you find this info? On this site? In game?
I know for a fact I had at least 1 last game with either Thome or Killebrew and it merely fluttered to the outfield. I had another with perfect pci placement in the same game but with only good timing that did the exact same thing. Yet this sad game lets rng decide who gets a hit instead of skill. And of course my opponent who flails at every pitch gets bailed out in the bottom of the 5th and gets handed the victory.You can find it either in-game by going to your game history, or you can click the "my account" on the top right of this site, then "mlb 20 dashboard".
In that dashboard is a bar where you came type in your or someone else's PSN and see their game history, the P/P are listed at the bottom
In-game all I see is box score and game log. Where in there does it show contact relults?
You want to go to game log and then scroll to the bottom, if there was p/p in that game, it will be listed along with the result of that outcome.
It only lists P/P, it doesn't show other outcomes like good/squared or good/good
-
@eatyum said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@eatyum said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@eatyum said in What even is good PCI for???:
Yeah, I'm going to need concrete proof that you went 0-20 on perfect/perfects, you should easily be able to provide that evidence because it tracks your perfects in game history. We can all see it by searching your name.
For instance, in your last game, all 3 perfects were hits.
I can't find any that list 20 perfect outs, weird right?
You seem like a knowledgeable stalker. How/where do you find this info? On this site? In game?
I know for a fact I had at least 1 last game with either Thome or Killebrew and it merely fluttered to the outfield. I had another with perfect pci placement in the same game but with only good timing that did the exact same thing. Yet this sad game lets rng decide who gets a hit instead of skill. And of course my opponent who flails at every pitch gets bailed out in the bottom of the 5th and gets handed the victory.You can find it either in-game by going to your game history, or you can click the "my account" on the top right of this site, then "mlb 20 dashboard".
In that dashboard is a bar where you came type in your or someone else's PSN and see their game history, the P/P are listed at the bottom
In-game all I see is box score and game log. Where in there does it show contact relults?
You want to go to game log and then scroll to the bottom, if there was p/p in that game, it will be listed along with the result of that outcome.
It only lists P/P, it doesn't show other outcomes like good/squared or good/good
I see it now. Thanks for the info.
-
The whole games stupid, you can have perfect perfect and get beat by late/early all day long. A monopoly on a sport turns in to this - look at garbage [censored] Madden. It's all about DD and stubs purchase, [censored] rewarding anyone for being good at it. And God forbid you want to play franchise in anything anymore, they remove features every year not add them.
-
There are quite a few issues with the game. Batting average on perfect perfects isn’t one of them.
-
@mitchhammond24 said in What even is good PCI for???:
There are quite a few issues with the game. Batting average on perfect perfects isn’t one of them.
Idk what’s more ridiculous: someone calling eatyum a stocker for looking at your game history or OP making a claim that he went 0-20 on perfect perfects.
-
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Kovz88 said in What even is good PCI for???:
Every single lerson who has complained about perfect/perfect outs on this forum has been exxagerating. Every. Single. One. I was frustrated when I first got the game too and thought most of my perfect/perfects were outs then I tracked my own data and realized I was batting well over .800 on perfect/perfects.
This is just not true. I have never exaggerated. Nobody is batting ,800 on perfect/perfects. Nobody. The reason I know this is because no matter what mode I play in whether it is a moment, event, showdown, or RS I hit well below .500 on perfect/perfects. And that is being generous.
You are exxagerating right now. I wrote down every perfect perfrct I hit on a sheet of paper for about a month. Was batting about .830 and I guarantee no matter what you think you too are batting at the very least .760. Also the fact that you said you get perfect perfrct pop ups in another post is another example of great exaggeration. To use your line, that is something that ahas never happened to anyone ever in this game.
-
@Kovz88 said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Kovz88 said in What even is good PCI for???:
Every single lerson who has complained about perfect/perfect outs on this forum has been exxagerating. Every. Single. One. I was frustrated when I first got the game too and thought most of my perfect/perfects were outs then I tracked my own data and realized I was batting well over .800 on perfect/perfects.
This is just not true. I have never exaggerated. Nobody is batting ,800 on perfect/perfects. Nobody. The reason I know this is because no matter what mode I play in whether it is a moment, event, showdown, or RS I hit well below .500 on perfect/perfects. And that is being generous.
You are exxagerating right now. I wrote down every perfect perfrct I hit on a sheet of paper for about a month. Was batting about .830 and I guarantee no matter what you think you too are batting at the very least .760. Also the fact that you said you get perfect perfrct pop ups in another post is another example of great exaggeration. To use your line, that is something that ahas never happened to anyone ever in this game.
Ok I mistyped. I meant pop-fly not pop-up. Not an exaggeration just a mistype. I have however experienced at least 2 perfect/perfect foul balls. Even in the hitting view window post play still displayed perfect/perfect. So it wasn't a bug or anything. -
@Kovz88 said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Kovz88 said in What even is good PCI for???:
Every single lerson who has complained about perfect/perfect outs on this forum has been exxagerating. Every. Single. One. I was frustrated when I first got the game too and thought most of my perfect/perfects were outs then I tracked my own data and realized I was batting well over .800 on perfect/perfects.
This is just not true. I have never exaggerated. Nobody is batting ,800 on perfect/perfects. Nobody. The reason I know this is because no matter what mode I play in whether it is a moment, event, showdown, or RS I hit well below .500 on perfect/perfects. And that is being generous.
You are exxagerating right now. I wrote down every perfect perfrct I hit on a sheet of paper for about a month. Was batting about .830 and I guarantee no matter what you think you too are batting at the very least .760. Also the fact that you said you get perfect perfrct pop ups in another post is another example of great exaggeration. To use your line, that is something that ahas never happened to anyone ever in this game.
Ok I mistyped. I meant pop-fly not pop-up. Not an exaggeration just a mistype. I have however experienced at least 2 perfect/perfect foul balls. Even in the hitting view window post play still displayed perfect/perfect. So it wasn't a bug or anything.
-
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Kovz88 said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Warpedzilla said in What even is good PCI for???:
@Kovz88 said in What even is good PCI for???:
Every single lerson who has complained about perfect/perfect outs on this forum has been exxagerating. Every. Single. One. I was frustrated when I first got the game too and thought most of my perfect/perfects were outs then I tracked my own data and realized I was batting well over .800 on perfect/perfects.
This is just not true. I have never exaggerated. Nobody is batting ,800 on perfect/perfects. Nobody. The reason I know this is because no matter what mode I play in whether it is a moment, event, showdown, or RS I hit well below .500 on perfect/perfects. And that is being generous.
You are exxagerating right now. I wrote down every perfect perfrct I hit on a sheet of paper for about a month. Was batting about .830 and I guarantee no matter what you think you too are batting at the very least .760. Also the fact that you said you get perfect perfrct pop ups in another post is another example of great exaggeration. To use your line, that is something that ahas never happened to anyone ever in this game.
Ok I mistyped. I meant pop-fly not pop-up. Not an exaggeration just a mistype. I have however experienced at least 2 perfect/perfect foul balls. Even in the hitting view window post play still displayed perfect/perfect. So it wasn't a bug or anything.
Pop fly or pop up, if you dont have a video I don't believe you. The fouls is a problem that plenty of people have had and while im sure most of them is because of bugs/glitches some probably have to do with wind and the curve of the ball off the bat. You also didn't address your exaggerating your low average on perfect perfects.
-
@eatyum said in What even is good PCI for???:
Yeah, I'm going to need concrete proof that you went 0-20 on perfect/perfects, you should easily be able to provide that evidence because it tracks your perfects in game history. We can all see it by searching your name.
For instance, in your last game, all 3 perfects were hits.
I can't find any that list 20 perfect outs, weird right?
You are probably 100% correct that I didn't have a 0-20 single game perfect perfect but I am 100% positive that I did have a stretch of a few games where I went 0-10 it was fairly early in the game. I did drastically over exaggerate but my point still stands quite a few of my Perfect Perfect outs were well within the PCI in a way the would have given them perfect HR launch angle. But I've also had a game where my opponent hit a perfect perfect fly ball with Mickey Mantle and it didn't even make the warning track and the launch angle was perfect for a HR. Then I came up and with awards Machado hit a perfect perfect HR at the exact same launch angle against Machado's weaker side which both are far lower than Mickey. My opponent that game even messaged me and said "the game clearly wants you to win" and I feel he was right i did absolutely terrible that game and that was what felt like one of the few games I got rewarded on my perfects. Most of my losses come from games like that where I've drastically out preformed my opponent in terms of good swing time and PCI but still lose because they get late or early rewards. I do apologize for over exaggerating. Im just frustrated because I feel like half my losses should have been wins. I know when I get beat properly and tip my cap to them. I just wanted to vent im sorry again for the exaggeration
-
I do admit that I very drastically over exaggerated that I went 0-20 on perfect perfects i was quite buzzed when I posted that so I do apologize for the exaggeration. However perfect perfect debate was not my point i admit I probably am batting over .600-.700 on perfect perfect. My point was about not being rewarded on PCI placement or rewarded for bad PCI placement. Im not sure which game it was and this is not an exaggeration. It was recently but idk the exact game nor date I've had a lot going on but I remember it very clearly because of what happened. Now to be clear on this point its not about perfect perfect as most of the perfect perfects of this particular game were hits by both myself and my opponent. It was against a right handed pitcher and I had MVP Trout at the dish it was good swing time just millimeters on the early side of perfect perfect however the PCI was dead center of the top dot on the altitude PCI selection a couple innings later Jimmy Rollins hits a HR my issue is the Trout hit was a routine fly ball with good PCI where as the Rollins HR I was about 4 millimeters below the ball on the J-Roll HR. I don't have a problem with Perfect Perfect outs at all yes it sucks and re re reading my post it was flawed. I don't have a problem with PP outs because I play baseball IRL and I've had games where I crushed everything hit the ball perfectly just right to a Glove thats Baseball but when I constantly get good PCI placement with Good swing timing and have a hitter who has 125 power vs righties it should go way further than a ball not squared up from a guy who has way less power. That is my issue with the game. I miss spoke in my altered state of mind my emphasis was meant to be on PCI placement not on Perfect Perfect averages
