Fix Timing Hitting

Hey MLB the Show fixed your swing timing how the hell I’m keep hitting the ball on good timing and still not getting a base hit or a home run this is outrageous I even had a couple of perfect timing and still fly out or ground out and my good swing timing sometimes be strikes also fix this

Ok Karen

OP probably expects to score every time he goes to the bar.

They need to fix the PCI sensitivity movement. It varies from pitcher to pitcher and level of difficulty. At least give us the option of adjusting it ourselves.

@Matt_42187 said in Fix Timing Hitting:

They need to fix the PCI sensitivity movement. It varies from pitcher to pitcher and level of difficulty. At least give us the option of adjusting it ourselves.

Please SDS, let us adjust the sensitivity

Punctuation is your friend.

I feel like the better question to ask SDS is why is there tinkering with the hitting window every update? Pitching has been the problem all season, and because a small percentage of the community is beyond amazing at the game they tweak hitting, negatively effecting a much larger portion of the playerbase. I am nowhere near good, but the minute I start to feel like I'm improving, there's a tweak under the hood and I'm back at square one trying to get my [censored] together. This is much more noticeable in moments/showdown where pitch speeds sliders are through the roof and your hitting sliders seem way down. I imagine the game we would have had this year had they kept hitting in the ballpark of where it was in early access and fixed the real problems with the game (Pitching and Fielders Speeds).

@CriscoDaDragon87 said in Fix Timing Hitting:

Hey MLB the Show fixed your swing timing how the hell I’m keep hitting the ball on good timing and still not getting a base hit or a home run this is outrageous I even had a couple of perfect timing and still fly out or ground out and my good swing timing sometimes be strikes also fix this

Think about it though. Many mlb hitters time pitches good with the barrel on the ball not everything you hit is gonna be a hit. Also sometimes I feel with certain pitches and locations you dont want to be good or perfect
you want late or early with good pci contact.

@Dthomp said in Fix Timing Hitting:

I feel like the better question to ask SDS is why is there tinkering with the hitting window every update? Pitching has been the problem all season, and because a small percentage of the community is beyond amazing at the game they tweak hitting, negatively effecting a much larger portion of the playerbase. I am nowhere near good, but the minute I start to feel like I'm improving, there's a tweak under the hood and I'm back at square one trying to get my [censored] together. This is much more noticeable in moments/showdown where pitch speeds sliders are through the roof and your hitting sliders seem way down. I imagine the game we would have had this year had they kept hitting in the ballpark of where it was in early access and fixed the real problems with the game (Pitching and Fielders Speeds).

I agree. As soon as I have it down to the tee, boom....perfect pop ups and ground outs to the pitcher! I get that it's about good PCI placement, but I'm too old to chase a yellow marker and pressing a button at the same time. I guess I'm switching to pure analog at this point. I can't use a PCI and swing at the same time for some reason, but I do okay with analog because it's the PCI and swing all in one button. But then as soon as you get into Legend, it's quite hard to even make contact on analog.