Gehrig vs Thames

SDS

Is Lou worth the stubs, or is Thames still better?

SDS

@ZPiazza6 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

Is Lou worth the stubs, or is Thames still better?

What lou gehrig? I am waiting for his 99 to drop. He was my best first baseman by a long shot last year.

SDS

You mean Musial? Gehrig doesn’t have a diamond card yet

SDS

I can't speak to Thames as I'm not there yet, but Stan is a beast. He has 1st locked up unless Jesus Christ himself comes down and picks up a 1st basemans mitt.

SDS

Musial is better statistically especially once prestiged because it gives him Silver defense at first. Depends on who swing you click with and if its worth an extra $130k or so to you. I don't think Musial is the best 1b we get though with Big Hurt, Gehrig and Pujols to still come. Hes at worst an end game bench bat though.

SDS

@ZFree1122 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

Musial is better statistically especially once prestiged because it gives him Silver defense at first. Depends on who swing you click with and if its worth an extra $130k or so to you. I don't think Musial is the best 1b we get though with Big Hurt, Gehrig and Pujols to still come. Hes at worst an end game bench bat though.

Jimmy Foxx will be better than all of those guys you just named, so don’t leave him out

SDS

@the_dragon1912 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

@ZFree1122 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

Musial is better statistically especially once prestiged because it gives him Silver defense at first. Depends on who swing you click with and if its worth an extra $130k or so to you. I don't think Musial is the best 1b we get though with Big Hurt, Gehrig and Pujols to still come. Hes at worst an end game bench bat though.

Jimmy Foxx will be better than all of those guys you just named, so don’t leave him out

I believe you but the big hurt is always my end game 1b unless they give Ruth 1b secondary.

SDS

@ZFree1122 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

@the_dragon1912 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

@ZFree1122 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

Musial is better statistically especially once prestiged because it gives him Silver defense at first. Depends on who swing you click with and if its worth an extra $130k or so to you. I don't think Musial is the best 1b we get though with Big Hurt, Gehrig and Pujols to still come. Hes at worst an end game bench bat though.

Jimmy Foxx will be better than all of those guys you just named, so don’t leave him out

I believe you but the big hurt is always my end game 1b unless they give Ruth 1b secondary.

The thing is, Frank is one of those that doesn’t just gee and haw with everyone.

SDS

@wingo18 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

@ZFree1122 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

@the_dragon1912 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

@ZFree1122 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

Musial is better statistically especially once prestiged because it gives him Silver defense at first. Depends on who swing you click with and if its worth an extra $130k or so to you. I don't think Musial is the best 1b we get though with Big Hurt, Gehrig and Pujols to still come. Hes at worst an end game bench bat though.

Jimmy Foxx will be better than all of those guys you just named, so don’t leave him out

I believe you but the big hurt is always my end game 1b unless they give Ruth 1b secondary.

The thing is, Frank is one of those that doesn’t just gee and haw with everyone.

Yeah I saw so much if frank last year I will probably never use him again. If Foxx is affordable, he’s my guy. I never hit well with Pujols but he probably only has two years left until he is out of the game so I might get some use out of him

SDS

Gherig is cool, and Thames is good, but it's always going to be Live Series Ryon Healy for me

SDS

@Hubijerk said in Gehrig vs Thames:

I can't speak to Thames as I'm not there yet, but Stan is a beast. He has 1st locked up unless Jesus Christ himself comes down and picks up a 1st basemans mitt.

Everybody knows JC can’t hit a curveball.

SDS

Thames and killabrew are all I need until Gehrig drops

SDS

@bhall09 said in Gehrig vs Thames:

@Hubijerk said in Gehrig vs Thames:

I can't speak to Thames as I'm not there yet, but Stan is a beast. He has 1st locked up unless Jesus Christ himself comes down and picks up a 1st basemans mitt.

Everybody knows JC can’t hit a curveball.

But does JC rip?

Do you walk JC to get to Vlad?