Changes For The Show 25
-
@beatlesnews_PSN said in Changes For The Show 25:
Make all BR, ranked and event cards available in an alternate manner (and not just paying a high stub price through the market) for those who don't do them. All players should be able to get the good cards. It seems like discrimination (yeah, a bad word) for those who don't play BR, ranked and events.
On one hand I get why they keep some cards locked behind that...on the other hand, I think there should be stat-based ways to achieve these cards offline vs CPU as well. I prefer to do all my DD stuff vs CPU because online really isn't worth the aggravation...so I wouldn't mind if all the online requirements were doubled or even tripled for offline DD players in order to get better cards too.
-
The option to exclude non-sellable cards when filtering for duplicates. After all the repeated non-sellable cards in the final chapter, it's a pain to try to get to only the sellable cards
-
@Capt-Clutch-2K24_PSN it’s not about being good, I agree. You can grind it enough and just from the PXP and getting enough strikeouts etc (even if you suck, someone will strike out each game) to get the max reward eventually. Might just take a while (coming from someone who spent forever getting Juan Marichal, only to never use him!!)
-
@SaveFarris_PSN that is not a good idea. Especially with no sets and seasons. It will most likely be a slow grind this year and the cards in BR, Events l, Ranked will be even more valuable. Can’t make it for offline. Defeats the purpose.
-
I collected all my idea posts in this thread and put them in a new thread. https://forums.theshow.com/topic/73498/my-complete-wishlist-for-mlb-the-show-25
-
Playing Ranked games in MLB stadiums is so much worse compared to stadiums like Laughing Mountain. They need to fix MLB stadiums to make them more enjoyable to play at.
-
@beatlesnews_PSN said in Changes For The Show 25:
- Make all the best cards available late in the game (since there won't be a season 4 next year). The card I'm thinking of and I wrote about here elsewhere is the Willie Mays HOF card. I finally did get it, but I'd also love to get Brett and Satchel Paige. I wish there had been a Boss pack for them.
Collect enough cards. Most are dirt cheap at the moment. You surely have stubs.
-
@KyleS779_PSN said in Changes For The Show 25:
@beatlesnews_PSN said in Changes For The Show 25:
- Make all the best cards available late in the game (since there won't be a season 4 next year). The card I'm thinking of and I wrote about here elsewhere is the Willie Mays HOF card. I finally did get it, but I'd also love to get Brett and Satchel Paige. I wish there had been a Boss pack for them.
Collect enough cards. Most are dirt cheap at the moment. You surely have stubs.
There's no problem if you come into the game on day one, obviously. I didn't this year. I joined in when Playstation offered the game on PS Plus. I have all the cards I want that I had access to. I had to spend some stubs to get Willie Mays HOF and there's no way I'll get Chipper Jones HOF. It's cards like that I'm referring to. It'd be nice of those were accessible more easily or in Chipper Jones' case, at all.
-
I think that having cards be available online only is not good modern game design. Online play is best when its two people that actually want to play online instead of someone just trying to grind missions for the card. It can drive offline preferred people away from the game if their favorite players show up behind a tedious BR or event grind. Online players should be rewarded, but there are better ways to do so than card exclusivity.
Some ideas:
-Online earning should be faster
-Online earning should be sellable
-Online earning could be 2-4 weeks earlier
-Online cards could be a flashier version of the same card
-Online versions can go beyond p5 -
@TeakAUS_PSN said in Changes For The Show 25:
I think that having cards be available online only is not good modern game design. Online play is best when its two people that actually want to play online instead of someone just trying to grind missions for the card. It can drive offline preferred people away from the game if their favorite players show up behind a tedious BR or event grind. Online players should be rewarded, but there are better ways to do so than card exclusivity.
Some ideas:
-Online earning should be faster
-Online earning should be sellable
-Online earning could be 2-4 weeks earlier
-Online cards could be a flashier version of the same card
-Online versions can go beyond p5You really started another profile in a different region to complain about online exclusive rewards? lol If the only reward online players would get is a "flashier" version of the same card, wheres the incentive for anyone to play online?
-
@Easy_Duhz_It__PSN said in Changes For The Show 25:
@TeakAUS_PSN said in Changes For The Show 25:
I think that having cards be available online only is not good modern game design. Online play is best when its two people that actually want to play online instead of someone just trying to grind missions for the card. It can drive offline preferred people away from the game if their favorite players show up behind a tedious BR or event grind. Online players should be rewarded, but there are better ways to do so than card exclusivity.
Some ideas:
-Online earning should be faster
-Online earning should be sellable
-Online earning could be 2-4 weeks earlier
-Online cards could be a flashier version of the same card
-Online versions can go beyond p5You really started another profile in a different region to complain about online exclusive rewards? lol If the only reward online players would get is a "flashier" version of the same card, wheres the incentive for anyone to play online?
So ignore everything else and focus in on one thing? And yes, for people that actually enjoy playing online the flashier version of the card will be enough, along with all the packs, stubs, and especially the xp (which many would argue is the biggest incentive for much of 2024 anyway)
People that actually enjoy online would rather earn something playing ranked or Event than mini seasons so the incentive is still there anyway. I honestly think very few online players would be upset at all. Maybe the ones that sell the BR rewards? But event cards and Ranked cards were low value until s3 and everyone survived just fine.
-
But not everyone wants to play online
-
@TeakAUS_PSN said in Changes For The Show 25:
@Easy_Duhz_It__PSN said in Changes For The Show 25:
@TeakAUS_PSN said in Changes For The Show 25:
I think that having cards be available online only is not good modern game design. Online play is best when its two people that actually want to play online instead of someone just trying to grind missions for the card. It can drive offline preferred people away from the game if their favorite players show up behind a tedious BR or event grind. Online players should be rewarded, but there are better ways to do so than card exclusivity.
Some ideas:
-Online earning should be faster
-Online earning should be sellable
-Online earning could be 2-4 weeks earlier
-Online cards could be a flashier version of the same card
-Online versions can go beyond p5You really started another profile in a different region to complain about online exclusive rewards? lol If the only reward online players would get is a "flashier" version of the same card, wheres the incentive for anyone to play online?
So ignore everything else and focus in on one thing? And yes, for people that actually enjoy playing online the flashier version of the card will be enough, along with all the packs, stubs, and especially the xp (which many would argue is the biggest incentive for much of 2024 anyway)
People that actually enjoy online would rather earn something playing ranked or Event than mini seasons so the incentive is still there anyway. I honestly think very few online players would be upset at all. Maybe the ones that sell the BR rewards? But event cards and Ranked cards were low value until s3 and everyone survived just fine.
I ignore everything else because its really just a bunch of ridiculous ideas but i'll address them now.
-Online earning should be faster (They'd have to reconfigure their drop schedule considering they do ranked programs in two separate mission updates. Not something they're likely to do just so you can avoid playing online.)
-Online earning should be sellable (They already are.)
-Online earning could be 2-4 weeks earlier (Again...they'd have to reconfigure their entire roadmap to appease you.)
-Online cards could be a flashier version of the same card (Still as lame as it was before.)
-Online versions can go beyond p5 (Pretty much the same as the "flashier card" idea. Once you have a team of 99s at P5, going beyond is useless overkill that does nothing but put a little number in the bottom left corner.)
-
I love how there are multiple people in the thread who would prefer all cards earnable offline and are willing to put in work to do it, but you are making it seem like I am some outlier.
The simple fact is if you need exclusive cards to reward people to play online than your online gameplay probably sucks. Sure, you need to give xp, stubs, and packs so people feel they still make progress, but exclusive card rewards? People still play mini seasons and conquest even when they dont offer cards (and they rarely do). People would still play online. And a lot of people that prefer offline would still do it for the xp and packs.
-
@LIONED-33_XBL said in Changes For The Show 25:
P5 is easy enough for everyone. They dont need to make it easier.
I don't care one much one way of the other but I would not say that it is "easy enough for everyone"
The problem is that for many of us we spend so much time swapping guys in and out of out squad for different programs that it is hard to play with one player enough to P5 them.
I play more than your average player but much less than the hardcore and I have only ever P5'd one player since the feature was introduced and that was a pitcher.
I think I have a few guys to P4 this year but I am doubting that I will get them to P5. but it's not that big of a deal to me. Another +1 to my attributes means almost nothing with the cards we are all using now. I also don't play online so I don't need to show off my P5s.
-
I'm a constant card swapper myself. I try to use most cards until p1. In fact, I'm playing 23 now and not locking anything in for a collection until its p1. I may go with that approach for 2025, depending on how much offline content they provide (2024 was lighter on that, particularly in the second half of the year)
