Does anyone have an exhaustive list of players that used to be in the game (any previous year)
-
Pepe Alazar
-
Eric Kiss and Mike Swanny Swanson
-
Mario Mendoza was in 17 apparently
https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/comments/6uciic/the_show_17_legends_by_age/
-
@w1ck3dx24 I loved using Ted Williams!!! I also loved using the Yankees Arod flashback at third base. Hershiser also had a [censored] good card. Just a few more.
Ron Santo
Jason Isringhausen
Darin Erstadt
Garret Anderson
Doc Ellis
Dave Winfield
Gaylord Perry -
Dan Plesac and Steve Bedrosian
-
@saintleo14 wow I remember Plesac but not Bedrosian.
-
@platewelder_363 said in Does anyone have an exhaustive list of players that used to be in the game (any previous year):
@saintleo14 wow I remember Plesac but not Bedrosian.
He had a gold card at launch 2 or 3 years ago. Never got another.
-
@saintleo14 they did the same shiiiit to Isringhausen a few years back. He’d be decent to have now with the way cutters and sinkers are used.
-
Carlton Fisk and Dwight Evans
-
Joe Random
-
@Blujfan1992 Fisk had a decent card one year. I forgot about Evans too.
-
Hopefully John Donalson and Randy Johnson get removed by 2025. (I’m planning to take 1 year off, hope it works).
-
There is no way they will take them out of the game
-
Donaldson is likely here to stay though the 5 year Negro League cycle they talked about last year. I can’t speak for Randy since they seem to add and remove legends at will.
-
Jared Weaver, Frank Tanana. I heard someone here say Weaver was badmouthing the game, so I don't expect him back anytime too soon. I miss me some Tanana and not just because his name rhymes with banana. It is fun to spell and say though. T-A-N-A-Nananana
-
@broken_toy1 said in Does anyone have an exhaustive list of players that used to be in the game (any previous year):
Jared Weaver, Frank Tanana. I heard someone here say Weaver was badmouthing the game, so I don't expect him back anytime too soon. I miss me some Tanana and not just because his name rhymes with banana. It is fun to spell and say though. T-A-N-A-Nananana
Lyrical gangsta nanana lol
-
The List (with last year in The Show):
BOLD indicates Hall of Famer
ITALICS indicates civil/criminal/social issues that may or may not be preventing re-inclusionRoberto Alomar (Gone Since 2021)
Garrett Anderson (2022)
Rick Ankiel (2019)
Steve Bedrosian (2020)
Buddy Bell (2018)
Heath Bell (2021)
Albert Belle (2018)
Yogi Berra (2018)
Bret Boone (2020)
Mark Buehrle (2020)
Jay Buhner (2022)
Will Clark (2021)
Ty Cobb (2020)
Doug Drabek (2018)
Ray Durham (2022)
Lenny Dykstra (2018)
Doc Ellis (2018)
Dwight Evans (2021)
Darrin Erstad (2018)
Carlton Fisk (2018)
George Foster (2021)
Keith Foulke (2020)
Cliff Floyd (2021)
Steve Garvey (2019)
Kirk Gibson (2022)
Jonny Gomes (2022)
Adrian Gonzalez (2022)
Travis Hafner (2019)
Mike Hampton (2021)
Orlando Hernandez (2021)
Orel Hershiser (2022)
Rogers Hornsby (2020)
Aubrey Huff (2019)
Jason Isringhausen (2020)
Tommy John (2019)
Andruw Jones (2021)
Eric Karros (2018)
Dave Kingman (2020)
Ryan Klesko (2021)
Kenny Lofton (2022)
Dennis Martinez (2020)
Tino Martinez (2021)
Jack McDowell (2018)
Fred McGriff (2021)
Mario Mendoza (2018)
Jack Morris (2021)
Dale Murphy (2020)
Phil Niekro (2018)
John Olerud (2021)
Gaylord Perry (2018)
Juan Pierre (2022)
Dan Plesac (2021)
Kirby Puckett (2021)
Pee Wee Reese (2021)
Harold Reynolds (2018)
Benito Santiago (2020)
Ron Santo (2022)
Mike Scott (2021)
Enos Slaughter (2020)
Geovany Soto (2022)
Dave Stieb (2018)
Huston Street (2022)
Nick Swisher (2022)
Frank Tanana (2021)
Luis Tiant (2018)
Omar Vizquel (2020)
Jered Weaver (2022)
Matt Williams (2020)
Ted Williams (2020) -
@lewisnadasurf1 My Xbox user name is "MarioMendoza935"
-
@SaveFarris said in Does anyone have an exhaustive list of players that used to be in the game (any previous year):
The List (with last year in The Show):
BOLD indicates Hall of Famer
ITALICS indicates civil/criminal/social issues that may or may not be preventing re-inclusionFred McGriff (2021)
Embolden the Crime Dog as newly enshrineth he is
Awesome list btw
-
@iBonafideScrub_ if I see Donaldson or Randy I just quit. I don’t even try for a friendly. I’m just so sick of facing them. I don’t care about wins or losses just if I’m having fun or not.
