Does anyone have an exhaustive list of players that used to be in the game (any previous year)

[fubar2k7_PSN]

Roberto Alomar was in the game but once he got banned from baseball they probably had to remove him.

[fubar2k7_PSN]

@w1ck3dx24_PSN

Here are a few others you can add to your removed list.

Will Clark
Matt Williams
Orel Hershiser
Kirk Gibson
Jack Morris
Kirby Puckett
Sean Casey
Pee Wee Reese

[SaveFarris_PSN]

Would post, but the office is currently all out of internet.

Maybe this weekend.

[ANF_GOLD99_MLBTS]

John Dowd*

[fubar2k7_PSN]

@ANF_GOLD99 said in Does anyone have an exhaustive list of players that used to be in the game (any previous year):

John Dowd*

He wasn’t in this game. Reggie Stocker was this games version of Barry Bonds. Dowd was in MVP Baseball.

[arvcpa_MLBTS]

Pepe Alazar

[BxnnyMxn__PSN]

Eric Kiss and Mike Swanny Swanson

[lewisnadasurf1_PSN]

Mario Mendoza was in 17 apparently

https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/comments/6uciic/the_show_17_legends_by_age/

[platewelder_363_PSN]

@w1ck3dx24 I loved using Ted Williams!!! I also loved using the Yankees Arod flashback at third base. Hershiser also had a [censored] good card. Just a few more.

Ron Santo
Jason Isringhausen
Darin Erstadt
Garret Anderson
Doc Ellis
Dave Winfield
Gaylord Perry

[saintleo14_MLBTS]

Dan Plesac and Steve Bedrosian

[platewelder_363_PSN]

@saintleo14 wow I remember Plesac but not Bedrosian.

[saintleo14_MLBTS]

@platewelder_363 said in Does anyone have an exhaustive list of players that used to be in the game (any previous year):

@saintleo14 wow I remember Plesac but not Bedrosian.

He had a gold card at launch 2 or 3 years ago. Never got another.

[platewelder_363_PSN]

@saintleo14 they did the same shiiiit to Isringhausen a few years back. He’d be decent to have now with the way cutters and sinkers are used.

[Blujfan1992_XBL]

Carlton Fisk and Dwight Evans

[ChuckCLC_PSN]

Joe Random

[platewelder_363_PSN]

@Blujfan1992 Fisk had a decent card one year. I forgot about Evans too.

[iBonafideScrub__PSN]

Hopefully John Donalson and Randy Johnson get removed by 2025. (I’m planning to take 1 year off, hope it works).

[sbchamps17_NSW]

There is no way they will take them out of the game

[fubar2k7_PSN]

Donaldson is likely here to stay though the 5 year Negro League cycle they talked about last year. I can’t speak for Randy since they seem to add and remove legends at will.

[broken_toy1_PSN]

Jared Weaver, Frank Tanana. I heard someone here say Weaver was badmouthing the game, so I don't expect him back anytime too soon. I miss me some Tanana and not just because his name rhymes with banana. It is fun to spell and say though. T-A-N-A-Nananana