If you could have…

[Oreo Thomas_XBL]

Dodgers
Steve Sax
Orel Hershiser ( bring him back)
Mike Scioscia
Casey Blake ( one of my best friends growing up)
Pedro Guerrero

[GixxerRyder750_PSN]

Braves

Deion Sanders
Mark Lemke
Javy Lopez
Steve Avery
Mark Wohlers

[Dolenz_PSN]

Albert Pujols
Ted Simmons
Willie McGee
Chris Carpenter
Rogers Hornsby

[RevCuddyer_PSN]

Twins:

Johan Santana
Michael Cuddyer
Tony Oliva
Kirby Puckett
Kent Hrbek

[maurice91932_PSN]

Padres that have never been in the game:

Nate Colbert
Ken Caminiti
Bip Roberts
Randy Jones
Garry Templeton

Padres that have been in the game and need to come back:

Dave Winfield
Adrian Gonzalez
Benito Santiago

[theBlindRhino_PSN]

Dodgers
Billy Ashley
Ismael Valdez
Kal Daniels
Karim Garcia
Chad Fonville

[fubar2k7_PSN]

@fubar2k7_PSN said in If you could have…:

Dodgers

Sandy Koufax
Don Drysdale
Gil Hodges
Steve Garvey
Steve Sax

I’m cheating and adding a plus 1. Hideo Nomo.

[Purex37_XBL]

Chicago White Sox

Bo Jackson
Jack McDowell
Robin Ventura
Mark Beurhle
Bobby Jenks

Honorable mentions Ozzie Guillen, Albert Belle, Boby Thigpen, AJ, Carlton Fisk or Michael Jordan

[samguenther1987_PSN]

@dap1234567890 said in If you could have…:

For the Mariners...

1. Ichiro
2. Alvin Davis
3. Dan Wilson
4. Jamie Moyer
5. Jay Buhner (I don't think he is in the game this year)
   5.1. If Buhner is still in the game, #5 would be Dae Ho Lee

I kind of miss Tino Martinez but it's a solid 5.

[SaveFarris_PSN]

Ben McDonald
Todd Walker
Warren Morris
Chad Ogea
Ryan Theriot

Honorable Mention (sort of): Dylan Crews, Paul Skenes

[aam34_PSN]

Red Sox

1. Mo Vaughn
2. Manny
3. Post season Dave Roberts with 99 speed 99 steal
4. Josh Beckett
5. 99 Yaz
6. Teddy Ballgame

[aam34_PSN]

@aam34_PSN said in If you could have…:

Red Sox

1. Mo Vaughn
2. Manny
3. Post season Dave Roberts with 99 speed 99 steal
4. Josh Beckett
5. 99 Yaz

[SotaNice-_PSN]

MN Twins

Johan Santana
Michael Cuddeyer
Josh Willingham
Alexi Casilla
Denard Span

[dsparks_PSN]

Sandy Koufax
Raul Mondesi
Hanley Ramirez
Manny Ramirez
Hideo Nomo

[AlexTheGreater7_XBL]

Pirates
Brian Giles
Kent Tekulve
Pie Traynor
Doug Drabek
Manny Sanguillen

[capardo_XBL]

Orioles:

1969 Boog Powell
1966 Frank Robinson
1982 John Löwenstein
1970 Mike Cuellar
1977 Ken Singleton

[samguenther1987_PSN]

Cubs

Hack Willson
Shawon Dunston
Mark Grace
Carlos Zambrano
Moises Alou

If i could have a 6th it would be Derek Lee

[HustlinOwl_MLBTS]

Pete Rose
Frank Robinson
Ted Kluszewski
Jose Rijo
Danny Graves

[Johnny_Coletrain_PSN]

Braves:

Javy Lopez
Dale Murphy
JD Drew
John Rocker
Rafael Furcal

Honorable Mention: Steve Avery, Otis Nixon, Brian Jordan

[BxnnyMxn__PSN]

@Honor_The_Game44_PSN said in If you could have…:

Rangers

Adrian Beltre
Ruben Sierra
Pete Incaviglia
Rusty Greer
Charlie Hough

Fantastic list. Inky had such raw power…would’ve loved to seen the exit velo on some of his shots