23 New Legends Thread!
-
Jake Peavy confirmed.
-
@Ericulous1_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
@ChuckCLC_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Ian Kinsler
Mike Lowell
Greg Vaughn
Carlos PeñaCannot complain about these guys if we dont lose big names. Also Jeter and the Negro league players are great additions. TBH though, those 4 guys probably arent worthy of new legend reveals. Just kind of add them to the game. lol
Good way to put it. I actually think I’ll like the cards, especially Kinsler but come on, these are not legends.
I know, I know… the definition of legend in MLB the Show is retired player. Not everyone needs a reveal. I am glad that they are announcing stuff and hyping the season, I just hope they have a few big names saved up.
Kinsler was always a sneaky good card in the past, can’t remember what year we got a sig series of his card, but I raked with it.
-
@JEEZY-E_MLBTS said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
@ChuckCLC_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Ian Kinsler
Mike Lowell
Greg Vaughn
Carlos PeñaCannot complain about these guys if we dont lose big names. Also Jeter and the Negro league players are great additions. TBH though, those 4 guys probably arent worthy of new legend reveals. Just kind of add them to the game. lol
Good way to put it. I actually think I’ll like the cards, especially Kinsler but come on, these are not legends.
I know, I know… the definition of legend in MLB the Show is retired player. Not everyone needs a reveal. I am glad that they are announcing stuff and hyping the season, I just hope they have a few big names saved up.
Kinsler was always a sneaky good card in the past, can’t remember what year we got a sig series of his card, but I raked with it.
It was his Breakout card with the Rangers in 17 that was so good
-
No one excites me yet except maybe Paige and Jeter … I’ll have to see the Negro League other cards first
-
@Ericulous1_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Jake Peavy confirmed.
I’ll trade you 1 Jeter, 2 Pena’s, 1 Lowell and 1 Peavy for Ted Willams
️ -
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Jake Peavy confirmed.
I’ll trade you 1 Jeter, 2 Pena’s, 1 Lowell and 1 Peavy for Ted Willams
️I’ll trade all of them for a Jobu ritual card
-
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Jake Peavy confirmed.
I’ll trade you 1 Jeter, 2 Pena’s, 1 Lowell and 1 Peavy for Ted Willams
️Yes some guys should never leave the game I understand they have to renegotiate but make it a point to do that before the end of the previous game cycle. All time greats should be in there year after year. So in the next few years we will probably loose Babe, Honus and Lou. Honus was reintroduced in 2019. I remember before DD they had most of the guys that they are bring back in the game on the golden era teams. Satchel was in the pen, DiMaggio was a bench bat.
-
This has been about as unexciting as possible this far. I would rather have the former players they stopped paying the rights on return than these…cough cough “legends” they are revealing ( Cobb, Hornsby, Ted Williams, etc…)
-
Not very exciting releases. Don't think there are many if any I would really want.
-
@OreoRockstar_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
This has been about as unexciting as possible this far. I would rather have the former players they stopped paying the rights on return than these…cough cough “legends” they are revealing ( Cobb, Hornsby, Ted Williams, etc…)
Oh look I have a LEGEND with a career .232 batting average. I can’t wait.
-
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
@OreoRockstar_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
This has been about as unexciting as possible this far. I would rather have the former players they stopped paying the rights on return than these…cough cough “legends” they are revealing ( Cobb, Hornsby, Ted Williams, etc…)
Oh look I have a LEGEND with a career .232 batting average. I can’t wait.
Just give us Bonds, Sosa and Mcgwire and be done with this, hell I’ll take a Reggie Stocker and Pepe Alazar.
-
Since I skipped last year's game, I'll be getting a double dose of new legends when I buy this year. I'm pretty excited about playing with some of the new names that I missed out on in 22.
-
Matt Cain added.
-
Randy Johnson
Ryan Howard
Joe Mauer
Carlos Delgado
Roy Halladay
Adrian Gonzalez
Nick Swisher
Jonny Gomes
Geovany Soto
Ray Durham
Kirk Gibson
Dontrelle Willis
Mike Napoli
Kevin Youkilis
Chase Utley
Mike Mussina
Brian Wilson
J.R. Richard
Jered WeaverNot saying that these are all prime HOFers or anything, but just think that the legends pool they introduced in 22 had more appeal and recognition than what they have revealed so far outside of Jeter.
There are surely some bigger names to come, but hard to deny that last year was pretty solid when it came to the balance of HOF caliber/fun personality with the new legends they rolled out. Not getting that vibe so far.
-
Joe DiMaggio,Ted Williams, Sandy Koufax, and Ty Cobb need to be in this game.How about more catchers? Thurman Munson, Roy Campanella, Yogi Berra, and Buster Bosey.
Other than Jeter, new players have been worse than “mid”.
-
Kinda seems to me like a "put all your eggs in one basket"situation.
Well,we got Jeter.unfortunately it looks like in getting Jeter we don't get anyone else. -
@PAinPA_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Kinda seems to me like a "put all your eggs in one basket"situation.
Well,we got Jeter.unfortunately it looks like in getting Jeter we don't get anyone else.That's the thing though it's not like guys like Swisher or Dontrelle are these elite immortal players who defined their generation, but they were fun players and personalities. The current additions are just so bland. No sizzle at all with these names.
-
When is the legends trailer?
-
Will a true Legend please stand up
️ -
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in 23 New Legends Thread!:
Will a true Legend please stand up
️Ok- if you could add 3 players to this game following these below rules, who would they be?
-
No known steroid users (I have no problem with them in the game but those are some of the obvious ones).
-
They can’t have already been in the game as a legend (I.e. no Rogers Hornsby, Adrian Beltre is ok).
Correct me if I’m wrong because I don’t know who has all been in the show as a legend before.
Mine-
- Sandy Koufax
- Carlos Beltran (never been a legend before)
- Frank Robinson
-
