Players you just can’t hit with?
-
I seen a thread about the “best hitters on you team” and this is the exact opposite. Who are some players you just can’t hit with?
Mine is undoubtedly Chase Utley. Over 180 at bats and I was hitting a messily .213 with him against the cpu for god sake lol. Every hit was a weak pop up, grounder, etc. Only 2 home runs and also his OPS was under .500 I gave up on him and I’m using Foscue at 2B now and his doing a bit better but still not quite as better than the rest of my players.
Idk what it is about 2B but I just can’t seem to find someone I truly like there. Who are you guys using at 2B?
-
For me, it's Adley Rutschman. I got off to a hot start with him but now I am hitting under .250 with him. Benched him for Gary Sanchez.
-
Mentioned before I couldn’t hit with LS Trout or Acuna and some reason the game would not let me get hits with FoTF Jazz Chisholm
For 2B there’s plenty of options especially if you use secondaries
Best offense: Milestone Jorge Polanco
Best all around: 2nd Half Ketel Marte -
Joe Morgan, never could hit with him, still can't.
-
I hit very well with Utley... .500 + offline, but I can't hit with the 99 Clemente for some reason. He is like 4 for 40 offline since I got him... (very disappointing since I chose to do NL first because I wanted him over Frank, but he hasn't helped me yet.)
-
Any Soto card and no one else is even close for me.
-
Of the higher OVR collection cards, mine is definitely Michael Young. I can never seem to square anything up, even when I'm going good with the rest of the lineup. I want him to be good so I keep trying but may just give up on him finally.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Of the higher OVR collection cards, mine is definitely Michael Young. I can never seem to square anything up, even when I'm going good with the rest of the lineup. I want him to be good so I keep trying but may just give up on him finally.
Yeah, I forgot to mention him, I suck with him too.
-
Any Aaron Judge card, I don't know if it's that he's too tall or I can't get his swing down just right but I always seems to get jammed with him so it's a pop up or flyball.
-
FoTF Trout!!
Also Gary Sanchez was hitting a cool .165 for me. -
@samguenther1987 said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Any Aaron Judge card, I don't know if it's that he's too tall or I can't get his swing down just right but I always seems to get jammed with him so it's a pop up or flyball.
Judge is a close 2nd to mine as well. I got him on the bench as a PH but now that I got Frank Thomas his my PH instead of Judge.
I read a message awhile ago about a guy can’t hit with any tall player but couldn’t understand why but after using Judge I can see why lol his area strike is big and it I think that makes a difference.
-
Jazz has been hard to get a hit with. Also the MA Pete Alanso has zero homers and maybe 2 rbi's while batting 3rd behind FOTF Buxton and Stott who are usually on base. I think I have 2 doubles and a few singles in 20 games.
Also any Willie Mays card I have been terrible with. Great Defense but basically a out before he steps to the plate.
-
The 96 Gary Carter hits like a common for me
-
@samguenther1987 said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Any Aaron Judge card, I don't know if it's that he's too tall or I can't get his swing down just right but I always seems to get jammed with him so it's a pop up or flyball.
Every year I always suck with Judge too. That is until last week when I put him in the lineup to get PXP for the AL East. I don't know if its because he's a 95 now or what but I was finally killing the ball with him.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Of the higher OVR collection cards, mine is definitely Michael Young. I can never seem to square anything up, even when I'm going good with the rest of the lineup. I want him to be good so I keep trying but may just give up on him finally.
He's been one of my better hitters even hitting a few homeruns (2 in one game recently) I think it's the short swing that I like.
-
@samguenther1987 said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
@ericulous1_psn said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Of the higher OVR collection cards, mine is definitely Michael Young. I can never seem to square anything up, even when I'm going good with the rest of the lineup. I want him to be good so I keep trying but may just give up on him finally.
He's been one of my better hitters even hitting a few homeruns (2 in one game recently) I think it's the short swing that I like
Yeah, his is a swing I really thought I'd like, I even hit ok with his 84. I'm assuming at this point it's just mental. Him not me of course, thinking of getting M.Y. some much needed therapy.
-
Aaron Judge. All of his cards including last year. They could release 125 in every category with him and still barely bat .200
-
@doihearbossmusic_mlbts said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
The 96 Gary Carter hits like a common for me
He’s a good hitter for me only on all star, against only lefties, and bronze pitchers. Other than that….
