Players you just can’t hit with?
-
I hit very well with Utley... .500 + offline, but I can't hit with the 99 Clemente for some reason. He is like 4 for 40 offline since I got him... (very disappointing since I chose to do NL first because I wanted him over Frank, but he hasn't helped me yet.)
-
Any Soto card and no one else is even close for me.
-
Of the higher OVR collection cards, mine is definitely Michael Young. I can never seem to square anything up, even when I'm going good with the rest of the lineup. I want him to be good so I keep trying but may just give up on him finally.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Of the higher OVR collection cards, mine is definitely Michael Young. I can never seem to square anything up, even when I'm going good with the rest of the lineup. I want him to be good so I keep trying but may just give up on him finally.
Yeah, I forgot to mention him, I suck with him too.
-
Any Aaron Judge card, I don't know if it's that he's too tall or I can't get his swing down just right but I always seems to get jammed with him so it's a pop up or flyball.
-
FoTF Trout!!
Also Gary Sanchez was hitting a cool .165 for me. -
@samguenther1987 said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Any Aaron Judge card, I don't know if it's that he's too tall or I can't get his swing down just right but I always seems to get jammed with him so it's a pop up or flyball.
Judge is a close 2nd to mine as well. I got him on the bench as a PH but now that I got Frank Thomas his my PH instead of Judge.
I read a message awhile ago about a guy can’t hit with any tall player but couldn’t understand why but after using Judge I can see why lol his area strike is big and it I think that makes a difference.
-
Jazz has been hard to get a hit with. Also the MA Pete Alanso has zero homers and maybe 2 rbi's while batting 3rd behind FOTF Buxton and Stott who are usually on base. I think I have 2 doubles and a few singles in 20 games.
Also any Willie Mays card I have been terrible with. Great Defense but basically a out before he steps to the plate.
-
The 96 Gary Carter hits like a common for me
-
@samguenther1987 said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Any Aaron Judge card, I don't know if it's that he's too tall or I can't get his swing down just right but I always seems to get jammed with him so it's a pop up or flyball.
Every year I always suck with Judge too. That is until last week when I put him in the lineup to get PXP for the AL East. I don't know if its because he's a 95 now or what but I was finally killing the ball with him.
-
@ericulous1_psn said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Of the higher OVR collection cards, mine is definitely Michael Young. I can never seem to square anything up, even when I'm going good with the rest of the lineup. I want him to be good so I keep trying but may just give up on him finally.
He's been one of my better hitters even hitting a few homeruns (2 in one game recently) I think it's the short swing that I like.
-
@samguenther1987 said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
@ericulous1_psn said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Of the higher OVR collection cards, mine is definitely Michael Young. I can never seem to square anything up, even when I'm going good with the rest of the lineup. I want him to be good so I keep trying but may just give up on him finally.
He's been one of my better hitters even hitting a few homeruns (2 in one game recently) I think it's the short swing that I like
Yeah, his is a swing I really thought I'd like, I even hit ok with his 84. I'm assuming at this point it's just mental. Him not me of course, thinking of getting M.Y. some much needed therapy.
-
Aaron Judge. All of his cards including last year. They could release 125 in every category with him and still barely bat .200
-
@doihearbossmusic_mlbts said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
The 96 Gary Carter hits like a common for me
He’s a good hitter for me only on all star, against only lefties, and bronze pitchers. Other than that….
-
Just about all of them. lol
-
Jazz Chisholm and adley ruschman.
-
@dsparks_psn said in Players you just can’t hit with?:
Any Soto card and no one else is even close for me.
I was good with Soto in '20 & '21. Not so this year.
-
Devers. The stance is hard to deal with. Long swing.
