Which card is worse?
-
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
Lightning Rizzo or lightning dawson? Neither of them make my squad but I am a Cubs fan so I will at least give Rizzo a try but these are extremely underwhelming in my opinion. Call me crazy. I don't think that 80 contact holds up on Hall of Fame
Which first basemen, or even secondary first basemen, are CLEARLY better than Rizzo, besides Frank? You should be able to name a lot considering Rizzo is "extremely" disappointing...
-
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
Lightning Rizzo or lightning dawson? Neither of them make my squad but I am a Cubs fan so I will at least give Rizzo a try but these are extremely underwhelming in my opinion. Call me crazy. I don't think that 80 contact holds up on Hall of Fame
Which first basemen, or even secondary first basemen, are CLEARLY better than Rizzo, besides Frank? You should be able to name a lot considering Rizzo is "extremely" disappointing...
If your pci placement is consistently good, FOFT Bellinger is better. Rizzo is homerun or single. Bellinger has better defense, reaction and better speed
-
@ibonafidescrub_ said in Which card is worse?:
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
Lightning Rizzo or lightning dawson? Neither of them make my squad but I am a Cubs fan so I will at least give Rizzo a try but these are extremely underwhelming in my opinion. Call me crazy. I don't think that 80 contact holds up on Hall of Fame
Which first basemen, or even secondary first basemen, are CLEARLY better than Rizzo, besides Frank? You should be able to name a lot considering Rizzo is "extremely" disappointing...
If your pci placement is consistently good, FOFT Bellinger is better. Rizzo is homerun or single. Bellinger has better defense, reaction and better speed
If your pci is consistently good you'll have better results with Rizzo considering he has better contact and power to both sides...
-
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
Lightning Rizzo or lightning dawson? Neither of them make my squad but I am a Cubs fan so I will at least give Rizzo a try but these are extremely underwhelming in my opinion. Call me crazy. I don't think that 80 contact holds up on Hall of Fame
Which first basemen, or even secondary first basemen, are CLEARLY better than Rizzo, besides Frank? You should be able to name a lot considering Rizzo is "extremely" disappointing...
LS Jram, 96 Michael young, LS vlad, 91 posada, 91 adley, 95 pujols, 92 boggs, 90 ward, 90 France and 90 bell.
-
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
@wingspan_nsw said in Which card is worse?:
I think I'm the only person who wants to use that Dawson card. I have LS Acuna in CF now, and he has hit well online (I'm only in AS so not a great feat) but when I unlock Dawson I'm putting him in CF. I missed him last year, I don't know why but I always love his cards.
Dude acuna is 10 times the card Dawson is in every aspect including the live series quirks. Acuna is a top 10 card and too 3 outfielder in my opinion. I played a handful of events with Dawson. That card just hits whiffle balls and when I do get a PP it semmes like it's a low liner or screaming grounder. No moon shots. But that's just me.
You are right. Acuna is my best hitter online, I guess it would be pretty dumb to bench him. I did unlock Dawson, I think I will platoon Dawson and Gibson in RF for now.
-
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Which card is worse?:
@bearsfan217_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
Rizzo has a nice swing, him and Dawson will make my lineup for awhile. Screw the 'meta' , use cards that are fun
Winner winner chicken dinner!!! Never seen so many crybabies crying over free cards! Entitled brats that need a good swift kick n da @ss.
Every card in the entire game is free depending on how much you play and your skill. I'm really not sure what your point is. I was asking people's opinions on these two specific cards. Let's not be a keyboard warrior.
Well since i wasn't quoting you how bout you mind your own business and shove it? I was giving my opinion sorry your so sensitive.
-
@grizzbear55_psn said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Which card is worse?:
@bearsfan217_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
Rizzo has a nice swing, him and Dawson will make my lineup for awhile. Screw the 'meta' , use cards that are fun
Winner winner chicken dinner!!! Never seen so many crybabies crying over free cards! Entitled brats that need a good swift kick n da @ss.
Every card in the entire game is free depending on how much you play and your skill. I'm really not sure what your point is. I was asking people's opinions on these two specific cards. Let's not be a keyboard warrior.
Well since i wasn't quoting you how bout you mind your own business and shove it? I was giving my opinion sorry your so sentive.
Lol put the keyboard down Francis
-
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
@grizzbear55_psn said in Which card is worse?:
@bearsfan217_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
Rizzo has a nice swing, him and Dawson will make my lineup for awhile. Screw the 'meta' , use cards that are fun
Winner winner chicken dinner!!! Never seen so many crybabies crying over free cards! Entitled brats that need a good swift kick n da @ss.
Every card in the entire game is free depending on how much you play and your skill. I'm really not sure what your point is. I was asking people's opinions on these two specific cards. Let's not be a keyboard warrior.
Well since i wasn't quoting you how bout you mind your own business and shove it? I was giving my opinion sorry your so sentive.
Lol put the keyboard down Francis
Stop crying Franchesca!
-
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@ibonafidescrub_ said in Which card is worse?:
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
Lightning Rizzo or lightning dawson? Neither of them make my squad but I am a Cubs fan so I will at least give Rizzo a try but these are extremely underwhelming in my opinion. Call me crazy. I don't think that 80 contact holds up on Hall of Fame
Which first basemen, or even secondary first basemen, are CLEARLY better than Rizzo, besides Frank? You should be able to name a lot considering Rizzo is "extremely" disappointing...
If your pci placement is consistently good, FOFT Bellinger is better. Rizzo is homerun or single. Bellinger has better defense, reaction and better speed
If your pci is consistently good you'll have better results with Rizzo considering he has better contact and power to both sides...
how many doubles you have with Rizzo so far?
-
@ibonafidescrub_ said in Which card is worse?:
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@ibonafidescrub_ said in Which card is worse?:
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
Lightning Rizzo or lightning dawson? Neither of them make my squad but I am a Cubs fan so I will at least give Rizzo a try but these are extremely underwhelming in my opinion. Call me crazy. I don't think that 80 contact holds up on Hall of Fame
Which first basemen, or even secondary first basemen, are CLEARLY better than Rizzo, besides Frank? You should be able to name a lot considering Rizzo is "extremely" disappointing...
If your pci placement is consistently good, FOFT Bellinger is better. Rizzo is homerun or single. Bellinger has better defense, reaction and better speed
If your pci is consistently good you'll have better results with Rizzo considering he has better contact and power to both sides...
how many doubles you have with Rizzo so far?
He's too slow. 21 speed is awful. It ruins the card worse than the low contact.
-
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
@ibonafidescrub_ said in Which card is worse?:
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@ibonafidescrub_ said in Which card is worse?:
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
Lightning Rizzo or lightning dawson? Neither of them make my squad but I am a Cubs fan so I will at least give Rizzo a try but these are extremely underwhelming in my opinion. Call me crazy. I don't think that 80 contact holds up on Hall of Fame
Which first basemen, or even secondary first basemen, are CLEARLY better than Rizzo, besides Frank? You should be able to name a lot considering Rizzo is "extremely" disappointing...
If your pci placement is consistently good, FOFT Bellinger is better. Rizzo is homerun or single. Bellinger has better defense, reaction and better speed
If your pci is consistently good you'll have better results with Rizzo considering he has better contact and power to both sides...
how many doubles you have with Rizzo so far?
He's too slow. 21 speed is awful. It ruins the card worse than the low contact.
This is why I said FOFT is better, defense is better, speed is better, but he wanted to talk about contact and power numbers.
-
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
Lightning Rizzo or lightning dawson? Neither of them make my squad but I am a Cubs fan so I will at least give Rizzo a try but these are extremely underwhelming in my opinion. Call me crazy. I don't think that 80 contact holds up on Hall of Fame
Which first basemen, or even secondary first basemen, are CLEARLY better than Rizzo, besides Frank? You should be able to name a lot considering Rizzo is "extremely" disappointing...
LS Jram, 96 Michael young, LS vlad, 91 posada, 91 adley, 95 pujols, 92 boggs, 90 ward, 90 France and 90 bell.
JRam is not clear, 20 less power both sides. Vlad has awful contact vs RHP and less power to both sides. Adley has considerably less power to both sides and worse vision. Boggs has no power at all. Ward has very low power vs LHP and he bats right that's a straight up no go. France again no power. Bell essentially same contact, less power.
Not saying any of those cards are bad. They're all way faster, Adley/Bell/Jram switch hit. But they are not CLEARLY better. Rizzo is a very good power hitter at this stage in the game.
Thomas, Pujols, and Rizzo are the only 80 contact/100 power to both sides cards in the game right now.
-
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
@jkooch66_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
Lightning Rizzo or lightning dawson? Neither of them make my squad but I am a Cubs fan so I will at least give Rizzo a try but these are extremely underwhelming in my opinion. Call me crazy. I don't think that 80 contact holds up on Hall of Fame
Which first basemen, or even secondary first basemen, are CLEARLY better than Rizzo, besides Frank? You should be able to name a lot considering Rizzo is "extremely" disappointing...
LS Jram, 96 Michael young, LS vlad, 91 posada, 91 adley, 95 pujols, 92 boggs, 90 ward, 90 France and 90 bell.
JRam is not clear, 20 less power both sides. Vlad has awful contact vs RHP and less power to both sides. Adley has considerably less power to both sides and worse vision. Boggs has no power at all. Ward has very low power vs LHP and he bats right that's a straight up no go. France again no power. Bell essentially same contact, less power.
Not saying any of those cards are bad. They're all way faster, Adley/Bell/Jram switch hit. But they are not CLEARLY better. Rizzo is a very good power hitter at this stage in the game.
Thomas, Pujols, and Rizzo are the only 80 contact/100 power to both sides cards in the game right now.
It's funny how you are quoting me on things I never said. I never said there were a lot of first baseman that were CLEARLY better than rizzo. But I just named a handful that I believe are better than him and more versatile. You disagree with me. I also have Frank Thomas who is most definitely better than Rizzo but you conceded that fact. All I said in my original post was that Rizzo is underwhelming and he does not make my squad. I then asked which card is worse in Rizzo or Dawson. You then went on a rant about which cards were better and which were not in your opinion. That's not what this post was about. The only reason I'm even trying him is because I'm a Cubs fan otherwise the card would collect dust because in my opinion it is buns. And yes it is an undisputed fact that live series j-ram is better than this Rizzo card. You're also saying things that are false because jayram and Vlad have inside edge almost every day that boosts their stats and vlads power is usually above 100 versus righties almost daily. The fact that Rizzo is beyond slow and doesn't play any other positions leaves him underwhelming. He will rake an All-Star but I think he will fail and Hall of Fame and legend in my opinion
-
Dawson is turrible for me, with a capital Y.
-
@dominickb3_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
@bearsfan217_xbl said in Which card is worse?:
Rizzo has a nice swing, him and Dawson will make my lineup for awhile. Screw the 'meta' , use cards that are fun
This right here. I have a lineup created named "favs". It's guys that I either was or am a fan of and enjoy using. Might not be my best possible lineup but it's a ton of fun.
So you normally play with guys you don't like??
I only play with guys I like, always done that and always will be like that
better overall cards don't mean you play better with em
-
Both of them are wrecking the ball for me, both Dawson and Rizzo have been home run machines. I can't see taking Rizzo out until i get Thomas (if I'm ever able to aford Trout)
-
@samguenther1987 said in Which card is worse?:
Both of them are wrecking the ball for me, both Dawson and Rizzo have been home run machines. I can't see taking Rizzo out until i get Thomas (if I'm ever able to aford Trout)
On Hall of Fame online? I'm doing well on all star in events but not sure that holds up in RS on HofF. Dawson has a good avg but doesn't hit it hard enough 8n my experience
-
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
@samguenther1987 said in Which card is worse?:
Both of them are wrecking the ball for me, both Dawson and Rizzo have been home run machines. I can't see taking Rizzo out until i get Thomas (if I'm ever able to aford Trout)
On Hall of Fame online? I'm doing well on all star in events but not sure that holds up in RS on HofF. Dawson has a good avg but doesn't hit it hard enough 8n my experience
O haha no, on veteran/ all star against the CPU. I don't venture online much props to those who do though. I enjoy hitting with Dawson and i was glad to see he was brought back this year.
-
@samguenther1987 said in Which card is worse?:
@t-rox_09_mlbts said in Which card is worse?:
@samguenther1987 said in Which card is worse?:
Both of them are wrecking the ball for me, both Dawson and Rizzo have been home run machines. I can't see taking Rizzo out until i get Thomas (if I'm ever able to aford Trout)
On Hall of Fame online? I'm doing well on all star in events but not sure that holds up in RS on HofF. Dawson has a good avg but doesn't hit it hard enough 8n my experience
O haha no, on veteran/ all star against the CPU. I don't venture online much props to those who do though. I enjoy hitting with Dawson and i was glad to see he was brought back this year.
Cool good luck. I'm warming up to him also.
-
Like Rizzo so far but struggling w Dawson. Loved his 99;Expos card from back when.
-
A admin locked this topic on
