TSN Community Voting - 2022 MLB HoF
-
@savefarris_psn said in TSN Community Voting - 2022 MLB HoF:
Bonds
Clemens
ARod
Manny
Schilling
Helton
Kent
Rolen
Sheffield
Wagner(11. Ortiz)
I would probably swap Kent and Papi but mine is the exact same otherwise
-
Bonds, Clemens, Helton, Ortiz, Ramirez, Rodriguez, Rollins, Schilling, Sosa, Wagner
-
With seven votes in..Bonds and Wagner with 100%; Clemens, Ortiz, Ramirez, Rodriguez with 86%; and Schilling, Sosa with 71%...
Bobby Abreu 0 (0%), Barry Bonds 7 (100%), Mark Buehrle 0 (0%), Roger Clemens 6 (86%), Carl Crawford 0 (0%), Prince Fielder 0 (0%), Todd Helton 4 (57%), Ryan Howard 1 (14%), Tim Hudson 0 (0%), Torii Hunter 0 (0%), Andruw Jones 3 (43%), Jeff Kent 2 (29%), Tim Lincecum 0 (0%), Justin Morneau 1 (14%), Joe Nathan 0 (0%), David Ortiz 6 (86%), Jonathon Papelbon 0 (0%), Jake Peavy 0 (0%), Andy Pettitte 1 (14%), A.J. Pierzynski 0 (0%), Manny Ramirez 6 (86%), Alex Rodriguez 6 (86%), Scott Rolen 4 (57%), Jimmy Rollins 2 (29%), Curt Schilling 5 (71%), Gary Sheffield 4 (57%), Sammy Sosa 5 (71%), Mark Teixera 0 (0%), Omar Vizquel 0 (0%), Billy Wagner 7 (100%)
-
Mine would be Bonds, Clemens, Rodriguez, Schilling, Rolen, Wagner, Pettitte, Ramirez, Jones, and Sheffield.
Bonds, Rodriguez, Rolen, Ramirez, Jones, and Sheffield have the most fWAR among the hitters in the list, in that order. Pitcher fWAR isn’t as great of a metric, but Clemens has the most of any pitcher ever while pitching less innings than the next three highest. Schilling is the 20th best, Pettitte is the 32nd. And Wagner is a top 10 reliever by any metric.
-
A lot of players on this list who would belong in the hall of very good, but not many of them are hall of famers in my opinion. Schilling, Ortiz and Wagner have my vote. That's it.
-
@whitejw98_psn said in TSN Community Voting - 2022 MLB HoF:
A lot of players on this list who would belong in the hall of very good, but not many of them are hall of famers in my opinion. Schilling, Ortiz and Wagner have my vote. That's it.
I absolutely agree with you. These are all 30 names on this year's ballot for the BBWAA reporters. If we look at the 2019 BBWAA vote, we saw 16 of the 35 names get less than 5% which removes them from all future ballots. We also saw only 4 of the 35 names reach the 75% mark needed to be selected. Some reporters send in 10 names and some give your argument and send in fewer than 10 names. I think that process (with the maximum of 10 ballots per player before they get dropped off future ballots) truly makes getting into the HoF through the BBWAA vote a significant achievement! I appreciate how you came up with less than 10 names and your reasoning for it.
-
Wagner (for his dominance,400+ saves, and his numbers are very comparable to Hoffman who is in) Rollins (has the awards, an mvp, 1 of 4 to have a quadruple double, 5 divisions 2 pennants and a ws, and is the all time stats leader on his team in a few categories)Schilling( doesnt have the era, or win totals(played when that mattered) and no awards- that makes him not worthy, but 3 300k seasons 3000+k's and 2 ws push him over the threshold)
those are the only ones i d vote for, some had very good primes and HoF worthy stretches but not enough seasons of them. -
@whitejw98_psn said in TSN Community Voting - 2022 MLB HoF:
A lot of players on this list who would belong in the hall of very good, but not many of them are hall of famers in my opinion. Schilling, Ortiz and Wagner have my vote. That's it.
You're a stooge dude.
@PAinPA_PSN You're also a stooge.
-
With ten votes in..Wagner 100% with Bonds and Schilling 80%...
Bobby Abreu 0 (0%), Barry Bonds 8 (80%), Mark Buehrle 0 (0%), Roger Clemens 7 (70%), Carl Crawford 0 (0%), Prince Fielder 0 (0%), Todd Helton 4 (40%), Ryan Howard 1 (10%), Tim Hudson 0 (0%), Torii Hunter 0 (0%), Andruw Jones 4 (40%), Jeff Kent 2 (20%), Tim Lincecum 0 (0%), Justin Morneau 1 (10%), Joe Nathan 0 (0%), David Ortiz 7 (70%), Jonathon Papelbon 0 (0%), Jake Peavy 0 (0%), Andy Pettitte 2 (20%), A.J. Pierzynski 0 (0%), Manny Ramirez 7 (70%), Alex Rodriguez 7 (70%), Scott Rolen 5 (50%), Jimmy Rollins 3 (30%), Curt Schilling 8 (80%), Gary Sheffield 5 (50%), Sammy Sosa 5 (50%), Mark Teixera 0 (0%), Omar Vizquel 0 (0%), Billy Wagner 10 (100%)
-
Bonds
Wagner
Schilling
A-Rod
Clemens
Helton
Sosa
Jones
Ortiz -
A admin locked this topic on
