Best Catcher that’s not a CAP?
-
Catcher is the last position that I’m trying to find the go-to player at.
Currently, I have TA 2 Huff behind the plate but only have had a couple games with him and I’m still undecided.
I’ve used Piazza for a while after choosing him in the 1st inning program and wa[censored]ting right around .300 so kinda leaning towards puting him back in since he’s parallel 4.
Ive used 89 Gary for a few games but still haven’t found a catcher I’m happy with. What catcher has been consistent at the plate for you all?
-
I'm gonna say Joe Torre. He's surprisingly good, you should try him.
-
Huff is the stuff
-
@raesone_psn said in Best Catcher that’s not a CAP?:
I'm gonna say Joe Torre. He's surprisingly good, you should try him.
That max contact and good vision intrigue me since I’ve been playing more on legend. Once I get the next choice pack from the NL Central TA, I’ll give him a look since unfortunately that 94 Bench doesn’t look too appealing
-
I am an offline player, but I've hit fairly well with TA2 Bench. Couldn't hit with Huff. LS Realmuto hit really well for me also.
-
@sgtsly_psn said in Best Catcher that’s not a CAP?:
I am an offline player, but I've hit fairly well with TA2 Bench. Couldn't hit with Huff. LS Realmuto hit really well for me also.
Being a Reds fan I’ll eventually give Bench a look and see how he plays. I’m always playing HOF and above in Ranked so his righty splits are what worry me
-
Posada or Bench. Posada only guy still hitting over .400 for me mostly on HOF
-
Topps Now Keibert Ruiz is easily the best bang for your buck
90+ contact plus power vs RHP
80+ contact plus power vs LHP -
Offline player
Mike Piazza. .330+ Ave top 3 HR hitters on my team.
-
I love Adley. Having a switch hitter w/ solid speed, defense, contact and power is super nice. Usually hits 7th, but super well rounded and helps keep the lineup balanced.
-
+1 for Torre. Against RHP I think Gary Sanchez is the best catcher but he won't do you much good against Glavine, Lee, Leiter, Valenzuela, or Crochet
-
Jorge Posada has been my catcher since I unlocked him the first week he is unbelievable has a great swing does not make any mistakes behind the plate, throws Runners out and it's four more power than his number show. I can't wait for his upgraded card
-
I'm torn right now between Gary Sanchez, 42 Salvy Perez and Huff. Going to give Huff an extended trial once I'm done with my last two TA 2 divisions. Haven't used him much because I knocked out the AL West TA2 first so didn't wanna waste innings with him.
-
There shouldn't be any good CAP Cs this year! There are no gold or diamond C primary archetypes!
-
Everyone in World Series uses Posada.
-
Slam-tana is the correct answer!
-
Jorge Jorge Jorge
-
After a couple more games with Huff, if he doesn’t cut it, I’ll try out Posada from what I’m seeing here
-
I loved LS Perez, then moved to 42 Perez...then came Posada and I thought there would never be anyone else behind the plate for me. Then I finally tried Huff and have been really impressed. Has been all offline except for one ranked game...but he just seems to square everything up for me. I do value defense big time and want to test out Wieters...but I really think this is all going to circle back around to Posada for me.
-
Top hitting catcher on team is Topps Now Tyler Stephenson. He absolutely rakes. I've tried to replace him several times. He'[censored]ting in the 350 range in total and well over 400 versus lefties.
