Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.
-
@chuckclc_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@go4stros25_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Left ohtani. Center trout. Right Buxton.
Buxton is the only one that can absorb the secondary penalty and not move down in fielding rarity (stays diamond)
I go Buxton in Center. He is wasted putting all that speed, reaction and fielding in a corner spot. Trout is good in Center, but Buxton is a beast.
Buxton can run down the foul balls in right that trout can’t plus you don’t want trouts noodle in right. He will cost you runs if you put him there. Since right field requires the strongest arm it’s Buxton or Gallo no question
-
@easyduhzit_mlbts said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
If the SDSGods ever smile upon me and grant me the elusive Trout pull, i will never use him just because its taken so long to get him. Im content with my outfield as it is anyway.
Except trout is the best hitting card in the game right now. Not using Trout would weaken your team
-
@killerpresence4 said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@chuckclc_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@go4stros25_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Left ohtani. Center trout. Right Buxton.
Buxton is the only one that can absorb the secondary penalty and not move down in fielding rarity (stays diamond)
I go Buxton in Center. He is wasted putting all that speed, reaction and fielding in a corner spot. Trout is good in Center, but Buxton is a beast.
Buxton can run down the foul balls in right that trout can’t plus you don’t want trouts noodle in right. He will cost you runs if you put him there. Since right field requires the strongest arm it’s Buxton or Gallo no question
Trout has a very good arm. I just think it is a waste for Buxton. I think speed, fielding and reaction in CF come in play way more than a RF arm does. Plus like I said, Trouts is just fine. I dont think there is a right answer, it is a personal preference really. I see your point. I just find it more relevant for me to have Buxton in CF. Either way probably wont make much of a difference in the long run.
I guess I meant Buxtons Speed, fielding and Reaction are much higher than Trouts, where as Trouts arm is only like 6 points less than Buxtons.
-
@chuckclc_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@killerpresence4 said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@chuckclc_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@go4stros25_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Left ohtani. Center trout. Right Buxton.
Buxton is the only one that can absorb the secondary penalty and not move down in fielding rarity (stays diamond)
I go Buxton in Center. He is wasted putting all that speed, reaction and fielding in a corner spot. Trout is good in Center, but Buxton is a beast.
Buxton can run down the foul balls in right that trout can’t plus you don’t want trouts noodle in right. He will cost you runs if you put him there. Since right field requires the strongest arm it’s Buxton or Gallo no question
Trout has a very good arm. I just think it is a waste for Buxton. I think speed, fielding and reaction in CF come in play way more than a RF arm does. Plus like I said, Trouts is just fine. I dont think there is a right answer, it is a personal preference really. I see your point. I just find it more relevant for me to have Buxton in CF. Either way probably wont make much of a difference in the long run.
I guess I meant Buxtons Speed, fielding and Reaction are much higher than Trouts, where as Trouts arm is only like 6 points less than Buxtons.
I agree. No right or wrong way to go about it. Plus once you parallel trout I believe he stays gold fielding in RF, and secondary position penalties dont effect arm strength. Buxton is a beast in the outfield tho. I personally hit better online with Buxton than trout. I might try switching them in the order and having trout bat second and Buxton 3rd.
-
@chuckclc_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@killerpresence4 said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@chuckclc_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@go4stros25_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Left ohtani. Center trout. Right Buxton.
Buxton is the only one that can absorb the secondary penalty and not move down in fielding rarity (stays diamond)
I go Buxton in Center. He is wasted putting all that speed, reaction and fielding in a corner spot. Trout is good in Center, but Buxton is a beast.
Buxton can run down the foul balls in right that trout can’t plus you don’t want trouts noodle in right. He will cost you runs if you put him there. Since right field requires the strongest arm it’s Buxton or Gallo no question
Trout has a very good arm. I just think it is a waste for Buxton. I think speed, fielding and reaction in CF come in play way more than a RF arm does. Plus like I said, Trouts is just fine. I dont think there is a right answer, it is a personal preference really. I see your point. I just find it more relevant for me to have Buxton in CF. Either way probably wont make much of a difference in the long run.
An 80 arm and 85 at 5th parallel is not good enough in right field. But you’re right it’s all comes down to personal preference. I would much rather have Buxton patrolling the bigger field which includes right center and the foul lines as well as making people at least think about tagging up on anything to right field. But to each there own.
-
@mjfc_363_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@go4stros25_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@mjfc_363_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Bro Trout is the best card in the game!! People might tell you otherwise....it’s a con! Don’t believe em.
Who said he wasn't?
I apologize if you thought I was trying to start some [censored]. Dudes post sounded like he wasn’t wild about having Trout. Just stating what I believe to be true.
You're good, I didnt think that at all.
-
@x814xmafia_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Current outfield is:
LF POTM Ohtani
CF POTM Buxton
RF 42 SantanderBench spots are
42 Griffey
42 Gallo
42 Goodrum
42 Stanton
Prime Jason BayWhere would you plug in Trout?
RF and replace Goodrum with Santander?
LF and replace Ohtani with Gallo?
CF and replace Stanton or Bay with Buxton?
I'm thinking the first one. RF and place Santander on the bench replacing Goodrum.
Your team looking roughy.
-
Who is your SS if you have Goodrum on the bench???
-
Organization in LF, Trout in CF, Buxton in RF. I would keep Goodrum since he can switch hit and play every position. Gallo to ph vs RHP. Gallo for LHP. Odd one out should be Santander or Bay but as another post said, sell Bay today he is up to almost 50k.
-
I don't have Trout (yet) but my OF is Griffey Jr. in LF, Buxton in CF, and Acuna Jr in RF. When I get Trout he will probably replace Buxton (who I don't hit that well with anyway), I'll put Trout in left, Acuna in CF and Griffey in RF.
-
@carbrenash_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Who is your SS if you have Goodrum on the bench???
42 Bogaerts. Huge Red Sox fan. He'll stay in my lineup for awhile. Only way Bogaerts will leave my lineup is if I somehow luck out and get to 100pts in the current BR program and take Story.
-
@bjd10048842_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@x814xmafia_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Current outfield is:
LF POTM Ohtani
CF POTM Buxton
RF 42 SantanderBench spots are
42 Griffey
42 Gallo
42 Goodrum
42 Stanton
Prime Jason BayWhere would you plug in Trout?
RF and replace Goodrum with Santander?
LF and replace Ohtani with Gallo?
CF and replace Stanton or Bay with Buxton?
I'm thinking the first one. RF and place Santander on the bench replacing Goodrum.
Your team looking roughy.
What do you mean?
-
Goodrum is better than Santander but do as you wish
-
@go4stros25_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Left ohtani. Center trout. Right Buxton.
Buxton is the only one that can absorb the secondary penalty and not move down in fielding rarity (stays diamond)
This.
-
@x814xmafia_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@carbrenash_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Who is your SS if you have Goodrum on the bench???
42 Bogaerts. Huge Red Sox fan. He'll stay in my lineup for awhile. Only way Bogaerts will leave my lineup is if I somehow luck out and get to 100pts in the current BR program and take Story.
Makes sense bc of your team allegiance to the Red Sox. Niko is great at SS though.
-
@carbrenash_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@x814xmafia_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
@carbrenash_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Who is your SS if you have Goodrum on the bench???
42 Bogaerts. Huge Red Sox fan. He'll stay in my lineup for awhile. Only way Bogaerts will leave my lineup is if I somehow luck out and get to 100pts in the current BR program and take Story.
Makes sense bc of your team allegiance to the Red Sox. Niko is great at SS though.
Yeah. I even has 42 Series Hayes in at 3rd. He'll stay there until I can get Chipper.
-
Sell Trout---do collections---EZ
-
Agree with your first instinct. I would be looking to upgrade my infield. Some really great, affordable pieces from April POTM (Vlad and Turner would both be upgrades over the 42 series guys). Also some great affordable LS diamonds that play above their stats (LS Story, Martinez for a bench bat,) I would also look to get Groshans from TA2.
-
@pats1124_psn said in Since I pulled Trout; I may as well use him.:
Agree with your first instinct. I would be looking to upgrade my infield. Some really great, affordable pieces from April POTM (Vlad and Turner would both be upgrades over the 42 series guys). Also some great affordable LS diamonds that play above their stats (LS Story, Martinez for a bench bat,) I would also look to get Groshans from TA2.
I gave all those players. 42 Bogaerts band Hates start for me because I'm a Red Sox fan (half tempted to put TN Dalbec in at first over 42 Muncy) and my nephew went to school with Hayes.
Hayes will probably get bumped yo the bench when I get Glaus.
also, since I mainly play offline; I can get away with lesser ovr players in my lineup.
-
A admin locked this topic on
