The only thing that needs to be fixed
-
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
Personally my problem is not when my perfects are lineouts or I’m hitting balls hard for outs. It’s when my opponent clearly is worse than me as evidenced by him flailing at pitches in the dirt and he gets rewarded for poor input. I haven’t done any studies but anecdotally this game seems to favor the lesser skilled player
-
There is a tendency of everyone who actually plays the game to generalize wildly from their own experience. The human mind plays tricks on itself when it relies exclusively on what it saw, and every trick it plays is an opportunity for someone who saw through the illusion to the reality. There was a lot you couldn’t see when you watch a baseball game.
-
@jacksonvance35 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
Personally my problem is not when my perfects are lineouts or I’m hitting balls hard for outs. It’s when my opponent clearly is worse than me as evidenced by him flailing at pitches in the dirt and he gets rewarded for poor input. I haven’t done any studies but anecdotally this game seems to favor the lesser skilled player
Yes that I can totally agree with. I just don't think that the person with more good inputs should automatically win because that is not how baseball works. In the situation you're explaining though, I can agree.
-
@jacksonvance35 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
Personally my problem is not when my perfects are lineouts or I’m hitting balls hard for outs. It’s when my opponent clearly is worse than me as evidenced by him flailing at pitches in the dirt and he gets rewarded for poor input. I haven’t done any studies but anecdotally this game seems to favor the lesser skilled player
Yes, but when you look at the box score, it will read as a close game because your opponent reached on a dropped third strike, and the late bloop behind the third baseman is scored as a hit while your good swings are recorded as outs.
-
I agree to the point that a perfect perfect should 99.9% of the time be a hit. I can see a PP fly ball to deep center or a robbed HR being an our. But if I hit a PP for a line out or foul ball that doesn't make any sense. Perfect should mean PERFECT
-
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
-
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
Wow you're a very angry individual. Take a few deep breaths sir. Yes it is a video game but it is a video game based off of baseball buddy. If you want something that guarantees wins based off better input every time then don't touch anything that has to do with baseball. That is how baseball works which means that is how this game should work. Yes, more times than not the player with more good inputs SHOULD win but it shouldn't be like that every time or this wouldn't be a true baseball game. Like I said though, if you're not into that, then you shouldn't play this game or anything that has to do with baseball for that matter.
-
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
Wow you're a very angry individual. Take a few deep breaths sir. Yes it is a video game but it is a video game based off of baseball buddy. If you want something that guarantees wins based off better input every time then don't touch anything that has to do with baseball. That is how baseball works which means that is how this game should work. Yes, more times than not the player with more good inputs SHOULD win but it shouldn't be like that every time or this wouldn't be a true baseball game. Like I said though, if you're not into that, then you shouldn't play this game or anything that has to do with baseball for that matter.
I don’t want a guaranteed win and I’m not angry. It’s a video game. It should play like a video game. Not a simulation of a baseball game. They have offline, casual and non-competitive modes for that.
What people want...is to KEEP UP when they shouldnt. It’s the same ppl that cried to ban dirt balling years ago because they didn’t have the skill or the patience to track the ball.
You know I’m right. Everyone knows I’m right.
you can’t have a competitive baseball game if you implement randomness. Because what happens...and we’ve witnessed this first hand is....the person making better inputs can lose and that should never ever ever ever happen in a video game it’s a VIDEO GAME for chrissakes!!!! Lol...that is literally the definition of what a video game is.
-
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
Wow you're a very angry individual. Take a few deep breaths sir. Yes it is a video game but it is a video game based off of baseball buddy. If you want something that guarantees wins based off better input every time then don't touch anything that has to do with baseball. That is how baseball works which means that is how this game should work. Yes, more times than not the player with more good inputs SHOULD win but it shouldn't be like that every time or this wouldn't be a true baseball game. Like I said though, if you're not into that, then you shouldn't play this game or anything that has to do with baseball for that matter.
I don’t want a guaranteed win and I’m not angry. It’s a video game. It should play like a video game. Not a simulation of a baseball game. They have offline, casual and non-competitive modes for that.
What people want...is to KEEP UP when they shouldnt. It’s the same ppl that cried to ban dirt balling years ago because they didn’t have the skill or the patience to track the ball.
You know I’m right. Everyone knows I’m right.
you can’t have a competitive baseball game if you implement randomness. Because what happens...and we’ve witnessed this first hand is....the person making better inputs can lose and that should never ever ever ever happen in a video game it’s a VIDEO GAME for chrissakes!!!! Lol...that is literally the definition of what a video game is.
Haha I definitely don't know you're right because I don't believe you're right. I actually think you're wrong. So how would your amazing idea work? Every perfect-perfect is a guaranteed hit and there is no such thing as a blooper or a grounder that finds a hole? What is this correct way that you believe the game should be?
-
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
Wow you're a very angry individual. Take a few deep breaths sir. Yes it is a video game but it is a video game based off of baseball buddy. If you want something that guarantees wins based off better input every time then don't touch anything that has to do with baseball. That is how baseball works which means that is how this game should work. Yes, more times than not the player with more good inputs SHOULD win but it shouldn't be like that every time or this wouldn't be a true baseball game. Like I said though, if you're not into that, then you shouldn't play this game or anything that has to do with baseball for that matter.
I don’t want a guaranteed win and I’m not angry. It’s a video game. It should play like a video game. Not a simulation of a baseball game. They have offline, casual and non-competitive modes for that.
What people want...is to KEEP UP when they shouldnt. It’s the same ppl that cried to ban dirt balling years ago because they didn’t have the skill or the patience to track the ball.
You know I’m right. Everyone knows I’m right.
you can’t have a competitive baseball game if you implement randomness. Because what happens...and we’ve witnessed this first hand is....the person making better inputs can lose and that should never ever ever ever happen in a video game it’s a VIDEO GAME for chrissakes!!!! Lol...that is literally the definition of what a video game is.
Implementing the anti-gravity ball if you throw the same pitch three times in a row was the single worst move SDS has made to this series. The writing is on the wall gentlemen, this series is in free fall and cross platform is just going to make it worse. They will ban throwing anything out of the zone so that those new to the game can compete, I mean it technically already is banned just look at the very late or very early foul balls.
DD will be a glorified baseball card binder next season, mark my words.
-
@JEEZY-E_PSN said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
Wow you're a very angry individual. Take a few deep breaths sir. Yes it is a video game but it is a video game based off of baseball buddy. If you want something that guarantees wins based off better input every time then don't touch anything that has to do with baseball. That is how baseball works which means that is how this game should work. Yes, more times than not the player with more good inputs SHOULD win but it shouldn't be like that every time or this wouldn't be a true baseball game. Like I said though, if you're not into that, then you shouldn't play this game or anything that has to do with baseball for that matter.
I don’t want a guaranteed win and I’m not angry. It’s a video game. It should play like a video game. Not a simulation of a baseball game. They have offline, casual and non-competitive modes for that.
What people want...is to KEEP UP when they shouldnt. It’s the same ppl that cried to ban dirt balling years ago because they didn’t have the skill or the patience to track the ball.
You know I’m right. Everyone knows I’m right.
you can’t have a competitive baseball game if you implement randomness. Because what happens...and we’ve witnessed this first hand is....the person making better inputs can lose and that should never ever ever ever happen in a video game it’s a VIDEO GAME for chrissakes!!!! Lol...that is literally the definition of what a video game is.
Implementing the anti-gravity ball if you throw the same pitch three times in a row was the single worst move SDS has made to this series. The writing is on the wall gentleman, this series is in free fall and cross platform is just going to make it worse. They will ban throwing anything out of the zone so that those new to the game can compete, I mean it technically already is banned just look at the very late or very early foul balls.
DD will be a glorified baseball card binder next season, mark my words.
Opening sentence very true, runner up is destroying bunting across the entire game, both non-DD and DD. Can’t reliably sac bunt in franchise mode because of a Band-Aid put in place to combat DD bunt cheese.
Both Band-Aids that were thought up because of poor sportsmanship, and both poorly implemented.
-
@Red_Ted_is_back said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@JEEZY-E_PSN said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@bayareaj1991 said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
That is not how baseball works. If you have played/watched enough baseball, you would know that there are times where a team can outhit the other team and lose. Your team’s line drives are getting caught while the other team’s grounders and bloopers are finding holes. I might get less pp’s in a game than who I’m playing but if I get most of them in one inning and get a rally while your pp’s are spread out I might get that win and there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s baseball.
This isn’t baseball it’s a video game. You aren’t in war in COD. Sometimes in war you don’t expect to die but you do. But the person with the better inputs should win. THE BETTER INPUTS IN A VIDEO GAME DESERVE A VICTORY. It’s a VIDEO GAME!!! You aren’t a baseball player
You want to compromise the integrity of the competitive game to feel like you are in a baseball sim...if you want that PLAY OFFLINE.
Wow you're a very angry individual. Take a few deep breaths sir. Yes it is a video game but it is a video game based off of baseball buddy. If you want something that guarantees wins based off better input every time then don't touch anything that has to do with baseball. That is how baseball works which means that is how this game should work. Yes, more times than not the player with more good inputs SHOULD win but it shouldn't be like that every time or this wouldn't be a true baseball game. Like I said though, if you're not into that, then you shouldn't play this game or anything that has to do with baseball for that matter.
I don’t want a guaranteed win and I’m not angry. It’s a video game. It should play like a video game. Not a simulation of a baseball game. They have offline, casual and non-competitive modes for that.
What people want...is to KEEP UP when they shouldnt. It’s the same ppl that cried to ban dirt balling years ago because they didn’t have the skill or the patience to track the ball.
You know I’m right. Everyone knows I’m right.
you can’t have a competitive baseball game if you implement randomness. Because what happens...and we’ve witnessed this first hand is....the person making better inputs can lose and that should never ever ever ever happen in a video game it’s a VIDEO GAME for chrissakes!!!! Lol...that is literally the definition of what a video game is.
Implementing the anti-gravity ball if you throw the same pitch three times in a row was the single worst move SDS has made to this series. The writing is on the wall gentleman, this series is in free fall and cross platform is just going to make it worse. They will ban throwing anything out of the zone so that those new to the game can compete, I mean it technically already is banned just look at the very late or very early foul balls.
DD will be a glorified baseball card binder next season, mark my words.
Opening sentence very true, runner up is destroying bunting across the entire game, both non-DD and DD. Can’t reliably sac bunt in franchise mode because of a Band-Aid put in place to combat DD bunt cheese.
Both Band-Aids that were thought up because of poor sportsmanship, and both poorly implemented.
Honestly there is no need to punish people for throwing the same pitch over and over again. I shouldn’t be punished because my opponent keeps swinging at sliders out of the zone and vice versa.
-
@Mightysourdough said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
I agree to the point that a perfect perfect should 99.9% of the time be a hit. I can see a PP fly ball to deep center or a robbed HR being an our. But if I hit a PP for a line out or foul ball that doesn't make any sense. Perfect should mean PERFECT
Have you watched or played baseball before? Perfectly hit balls constantly get caught. That’s baseball. A perfect perfect line out totally makes sense. It happens all the time in real life. 99.9% is honestly a crazy expectation. If anything, pp flyballs are the only ones that should almost guarantee a hit because these are major leaguers with power so a pp flyball should almost always mean a homerun unless at polo grounds or a hitter with extremely low power. We do get perfect results most of the time on pp’s. That perfect result being an extremely hard hit ball. As for the pp foul balls, I agree with you there.
-
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
In this game right now. The person that makes the better inputs should win. Period.
If you were to fix that for 21. This would be the game of the century.
Agreed! Its the #1 complaint I have about this game.
Hopefully they'll create a "rec" league for newbies that just wanna have fun. The real rewards can stay in "competitive" ranked seasons.
-
A lot of you would lose a lot more than you already do in a “competitive ranked seasons” ...
-
@A_PerfectGame said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
In this game right now. The person that makes the better inputs should win. Period.
If you were to fix that for 21. This would be the game of the century.
-
I don’t think it will change your record much, you would probably lose more than you already do
-
Who should win this game in your better inputs world?
Player A - 3 perfects 6 goods 3 just early/late
Player B - 0 perfects 9 goods 3 just early/late
? Is it only hitting inputs that matter? What about pitching inputs?
2017 - 57.7% winning percentage
2018 - can’t see
2019 - 58.2% winning percentage
2020 - 57.7% winning percentageWe’ve been seeing the same complaints from you for years now, eventually it needs to stop being the game and start being the guy holding the controller
-
-
It’s weird to be agreeing with Canuckler, but his point is valid. Which inputs get rewarded?
If the pitcher has good input and the hitter has good input, will it be a hit or an out?
My experience lately is telling me that consistent decent input will bring better results than good (or perfect) input now and then.
In other words, if I have one or two PP a game and the rest of my swings are bad, I’m going to score less runs than if I have a bunch of 10’s, 11’s and 12’s.
Now some of you might say an 11 is a bad swing. If it is inside the pci with good timing, whether it is an 11 or not, that swing many times in a game is going to get rewarded more.
I think this is why the best players generally keep being the best players. It’s not just good input that is required, but consistent good input.
This is why I am spending way more time in custom practice. If I have to rely on one good swing every three innings, it’s not going to cut it most of the time.
-
It's very easy to say only input should determine the game, but no one ever seems to have the answer when posed with questions on that philosophy.
-
@eatyum said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
It's very easy to say only input should determine the game, but no one ever seems to have the answer when posed with questions on that philosophy.
Many here have put forward answers. Lots of suggestions about having player attributes and variables change the input difficulty instead of the outcome. I’m sure I’ve seen you yourself contribute some really good ideas in those discussions.
-
@Red_Ted_is_back said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
@eatyum said in The only thing that needs to be fixed:
It's very easy to say only input should determine the game, but no one ever seems to have the answer when posed with questions on that philosophy.
Many here have put forward answers. Lots of suggestions about having player attributes and variables change the input difficulty instead of the outcome. I’m sure I’ve seen you yourself contribute some really good ideas in those discussions.
I meant questions like this that ive put forth. If one person gets 9 good inputs spread out through one an inning and one gets 6, but all in one inning, that 6 probably wins bc he was able to produce a rally. Yet simply going by input, the first person was "better"
