Mike Trout 99ovr vs Ken Griffey 99ovr

[NuclearEng2017]

Who is better? Cards seem close in stats. What is your opinion.

Is Juan Soto (Finest Edition) better than any of those two?

[jswance2_PSN]

Trout is my guy...

[jswance2_PSN]

Trout is my guy...

[B28_baseball_PSN]

Soto is the best

[samguenther1987_PSN]

Soto
Trout
Griffey

Mantle on the bench

[the_dragon1912_PSN]

@samguenther1987 said in Mike Trout 99ovr vs Ken Griffey 99ovr:

Soto
Trout
Griffey

Mantle on the bench

I agree. I would take Mays over Mantle too FWIW but not everyone has 1 mil and 2-3 weeks of waiting

[samguenther1987_PSN]

@the_dragon1912 said in Mike Trout 99ovr vs Ken Griffey 99ovr:

@samguenther1987 said in Mike Trout 99ovr vs Ken Griffey 99ovr:

Soto
Trout
Griffey

Mantle on the bench

I agree. I would take Mays over Mantle too FWIW but not everyone has 1 mil and 2-3 weeks of waiting

Tell me about it, i'm waiting on Donaldson (should be about 20 orders ahead of me) and even that is painful lol.

[thinkbluedgr_PSN]

Lofton is the goat.

[samguenther1987_PSN]

@thinkbluedgr said in Mike Trout 99ovr vs Ken Griffey 99ovr:

Lofton is the goat.

Very underrated card. Suprising power too. I have him on my all speed team.

[mjfc_363_PSN]

Trout is a hit machine!!!

[Hubijerk_PSN]

So, I've been playing most of my games recently on HOF after being stuck in AS for most of the season and I just reworked my lineup after considering who's been effective and who hasn't. Purely by the numbers Grif is better. On AS they are probably close. On HOF Trouts split against lefty's really hurts him.

Right now I have Cobb in left, Grif in center, and Walker in right. I keep Mantle on the bench and Trout doesn't make the team. On HOF anyone with a contact below 100 is a serious liability and honestly you want contact as close to max as you can get (I just swapped out Gehrig for Prest. DJ at 1st). Now everyone's throwing maxed out pitchers and the PCI's are tiny. As HOF isn't the dinger fest AS is speed and baserunning are much more important as well.

If you're on All Star guys like Trout, Tatis, J-rame, etc. are practically Gods. Once you get on HOF or above I feel like you really have build you're team more carefully and purposefully.