Did he hold up in time? He did!
-
Hard to say, but I think my opponent went. What do you think?
-
game said he didnt, didn't it?
-
I mean, by that angle, it’s hard to tell. I think I’d lean more towards the “he checked his swing” side, but it’s definitely debatable. Maybe a different angle would give us a definitive answer?
-
This happens constantly to me but I have to wonder if it is just a lag issue. Like what I’m seeing on my screen is different than what is happening or what the other guy is seeing. I also get the animation where the bat barely leaves your shoulder and it’s called a swinging strike.
-
I'm convinced it's just a 50/50 and there's no actual umpiring going on.
-
@EvylShaun said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
I'm convinced it's just a 50/50 and there's no actual umpiring going on.
There isn't any umpiring going on, check swings are decided by the discipline stat and some mixture (very low of) user input, basically mostly discipline. The animation of the swing has no bearing.
-
@eatyum said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
@EvylShaun said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
I'm convinced it's just a 50/50 and there's no actual umpiring going on.
There isn't any umpiring going on, check swings are decided by the discipline stat and some mixture (very low of) user input, basically mostly discipline. The animation of the swing has no bearing.
Best description I've heard so far. I'll accept that as fact going forward with no further research or questioning.
I have spoken.
-
-
@eatyum said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
@EvylShaun said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
I'm convinced it's just a 50/50 and there's no actual umpiring going on.
There isn't any umpiring going on, check swings are decided by the discipline stat and some mixture (very low of) user input, basically mostly discipline. The animation of the swing has no bearing.
Worst part, I read these guys like open books. They sell out on the fastball so desperately, so I just serve up chanegups and curveballs that they will 100% swing through if I could only hit the strike zone. Of course I'm painting corners on the wrong side and they get every single check swing going their way until I have to challenge and they hit an absolute moonshot on a meatball down the middle. Great stuff.
-
@raesONE said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
@eatyum said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
@EvylShaun said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
I'm convinced it's just a 50/50 and there's no actual umpiring going on.
There isn't any umpiring going on, check swings are decided by the discipline stat and some mixture (very low of) user input, basically mostly discipline. The animation of the swing has no bearing.
Worst part, I read these guys like open books. They sell out on the fastball so desperately, so I just serve up chanegups and curveballs that they will 100% swing through if I could only hit the strike zone. Of course I'm painting corners on the wrong side and they get every single check swing going their way until I have to challenge and they hit an absolute moonshot on a meatball down the middle. Great stuff.
Sounds like mlb the show 20 to me!
-
What happens on your screen may look different to your opponent. Found this out playing friendlies. When i feel slightly early my buddy said i was wayy in front lunging at the ball. Happened alot more than i think is acceptable.
-
@Potawatomi_Kid said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
What happens on your screen may look different to your opponent. Found this out playing friendlies. When i feel slightly early my buddy said i was wayy in front lunging at the ball. Happened alot more than i think is acceptable.
Yeah the networking syncing in this game is in a really bad place, had another large thread about this earlier today.
-
@raesONE said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
Hard to say, but I think my opponent went. What do you think?
Hmm. I think we gotta call the booth in ny for this one. What a shame
-
@raesONE said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
@eatyum said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
@EvylShaun said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
I'm convinced it's just a 50/50 and there's no actual umpiring going on.
There isn't any umpiring going on, check swings are decided by the discipline stat and some mixture (very low of) user input, basically mostly discipline. The animation of the swing has no bearing.
Worst part, I read these guys like open books. They sell out on the fastball so desperately, so I just serve up chanegups and curveballs that they will 100% swing through if I could only hit the strike zone. Of course I'm painting corners on the wrong side and they get every single check swing going their way until I have to challenge and they hit an absolute moonshot on a meatball down the middle. Great stuff.
I 100% feel this, this is me pitching. So many people sell out for the fastball because the game will let them check swing on anything offspeed out of the zone.
-
@raesONE said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
Hard to say, but I think my opponent went. What do you think?
I don't think that picture shows the best angle.
-
@raesONE said in Did he held up in time? He did!:
Hard to say, but I think my opponent went. What do you think?
I love it when my batter twitches at the plate and the replay shows a twitch, but the feed back shows I made a full swing. Lol
-
I just lost a game on a check swing withTrout, with the tying runner on 3rd after a 12+ pitch AB. My check was half that check.
-
Aaaaaaaaaand NO swing says Kenny Janzen. That’s ball four.
Aaaaaaaah and he let him off the hook there. That pitch wasn’t even close!
-
@ComebackLogic said in Did he hold up in time? He did!:
Aaaaaaaaaand NO swing says Kenny Janzen. That’s ball four.
Aaaaaaaah and he let him off the hook there. That pitch wasn’t even close!
Next at bat:
THAT is a MOONSHOT folks
-
I really hate the appeal. Just stop. We all know it will be ruled a no swing. I really hope they tone down that animation next year.
