@yardem-hane_xbl said in How do I reset progress for a new CAP?:
First, choose your ballplayer: from the start menu, go top-left to your profile, click Manage, then select your already created ballplayer.
Next, start a new career: from the start menu, go to the RTTS but click the More Options button, then choose to start a new career.As long as they are position compatible, you can play any ballplayer in any career file.
Did the trick, thank you very much. Not sure why they made switching files so convoluted.