Everybody in the starting lineup of my Old Farts team debuted in the 40s or earlier. Some of the bench dudes debuted in the 50s, and then the bullpen is just the best I could do with the old farts that we have at our disposal.
1 - Cobb (CF)
2 - Wagner (SS)
3 - Teddy BJ (LF)
4 - Foxx (C)
5 - Snider (RF)
6 - Jackie (3B)
7 - Hornsby (2B)
8 - Musial (1B)
9.- Walter, Hal, Cy Young, Christy Mathewson, Lefty Grove (92 ... hopefully the 99 comes in RIB2)
Bench: Kiner, Doby, Mantle, Mathews, Minnie
Bullpen: (this is admittedly pretty lame) Henke, Wagner, Smith, Eck, Fingers, Goose, Gagne