Community Forum

I finished my ALL TIME GREATS roster for MLBTS 20 and uploaded it to the vault.

In addition to the ALL TIME GREATS roster I'm going to make HISTORIC ROSTER 1990-2009, HISTORIC ROSTER 1970-1989, HISTORIC ROSTER 1950-1969, HISTORIC ROSTER 1930-1949, and HISTORIC ROSTER 1900-1929.

Next up is the HISTORIC ROSTER 1990-2009. The following teams will be included:

BAL 1997
BOS 2004
NYY 1998
TB 2008
TOR 1992

CWS 2005
CLE 1995
DET 2006
KC 1994
MIN 1991

HOU 2005
LAA 2002
OAK 1990
SEA 2001
TEX 1999

ATL 1995
MIA 1997
NYM 2000
PHI 2008
WASH 1994

CHC 2003
CIN 1990
MIL 2008
PIT 1991
STL 2004

ARI 2001
COL 2007
LAD 2009
SD 1998
SF 2010

I am in the process of creating an ALL TIME GREATS roster for MLBTS 21.

Unfortunately MLBTS 21 doesn't allow franchises or rosters to transfer from MLBTS 20 to MLBTS 21 so all players will have to be created from scratch. For a 93 man roster we're talking about over 2700 players. Given this unfortunate situation of having to recreate each player from scratch it's going to take several months to complete this roster.

The first cut of this will be 40-50 of the all time greatest players for each team/franchise. As I create the players for each team/franchise I will upload players to the Player vault. When I get 40-50 players for each team/franchise I'll upload an ALL TIME GREATS roster to the Roster vault.

I'll periodically post updates on this message thread. So far I have finished BAL, MIN, and am working on BOS.

@jake98833_psn said in Does Anyone Know:

@biebig2010_psn said in Does Anyone Know:

I think rotmg and wafflejedi3273 are the same guy. They both have some very good classic stadiums. bigklu created a nice Ebbets field. blackshirt has some very nice classic stadiums as well.

I have a couple classic stadiums in the vault as well: Metropolitan Stadium, Candlestick Park, Cleveland Municipal Stadium, and Kansas City Municipal Stadium.

Hey your legends rosters are awesome are you doing them again for 22?

Yes. I'm working on an ALL TIME GREATS where each team has 40+ of the greatest players to play for that franchise (no duplicates). I finished the AL East and AL Central and put a copy in the MLBTS22 Roster Vault a week or so ago. I'm working on the AL West now.

Yet they are going to allow transferring of logos from 21 to 22. I don't believe the "new platform" excuse at all.

I uploaded an ALL TIME GREATS historic roster into MBLTS23 roster vault.

This roster contains 26 or more of the greatest players for each franchise.

The roster is named ALL TIME GREATS uploaded by biebig2010.

I think rotmg and wafflejedi3273 are the same guy. They both have some very good classic stadiums. bigklu created a nice Ebbets field. blackshirt has some very nice classic stadiums as well.

I have a couple classic stadiums in the vault as well: Metropolitan Stadium, Candlestick Park, Cleveland Municipal Stadium, and Kansas City Municipal Stadium.

@eatyum_psn said in no y2y again:

@biebig2010_psn said in no y2y again:

@dolenz_psn said in no y2y again:

No. I am saying that is what is being referred to by Year to Year saves. It was taken out in 21 and I don't expect it to return unfortunately.

@dolenz_psn said in no y2y again:

No. I am saying that is what is being referred to by Year to Year saves. It was taken out in 21 and I don't expect it to return unfortunately.

Exactly. So SDS is making everyone recreate players, rosters, stadiums, and restart their franchise again this year. Again, unacceptable.

Rosters were never able to be carried over, and stadiums are new to this year so you can't really include that in the "again" portion.

That's simply not true. You certainly could carry rosters over from MLBTS 19 to MLBTS 20. You could also carry franchises over as well.

I'm glad you like them. The Bosox, Yanks, Giants, and Dodgers All Time Greats teams are stacked. They have so many Hall of Famers on each team it's ridiculous.

One thing I'll do is to arrange the rosters to have say the 69 Orioles all at the MLB level and have them play the Mets with all their 69 players at the MLB level and relive some of the great World Series of all time. It's a lot of fun.

Another thing that's fun is to create a franchise and do a fantasy draft using the ALL TIME GREATS roster. You can build a helluva team through the draft using that roster.

MLBTS doesn't allow carrying over stadiums from 22 to 23 but I see it has carried over bugs from 22 to 23.

Template stadiums can and will replace your stadium and stadium files get corrupted again just like last year at launch. It's so annoying that the same bugs that were fixed last year show up again this year. Where's the quality control?

@FranciseYearlysaves-_MLBTS said in Can't carry over 22 franchises into 23:

100% AGREED !!! I have bought every version since 2009... I gave MLB the benefit of doubt last year since they expanded to XBox and also the new game console generation...(with very little improvement in graphics... which is a totally different rant and not a "must have" such as year-to-year saves.) I now have NO REASON to continue purchasing from year to year if I have to start from scratch each year. How inconsiderate and disappointing to a once phenomonal experience.

It's a really strange decision on their part. If anything this decision is providing incentive to NOT buy the new version because I want to continue with what I already have. If I can use my current creations (players, rosters, stadiums, franchises, etc) in the new version then it's a slam dunk buy.

I finished the HISTORIC ROSTER 1930-1949 and uploaded it to the vault.

Next up is the HISTORIC ROSTER 1900-1929. The following teams will be included:

BAL 1922
BOS 1915
NYY 1927
TB ---
TOR ---

CWS 1919
CLE 1920
DET 1909
KC ---
MIN 1924

HOU ---
LAA ---
OAK 1929
SEA ---
TEX ---

ATL 1914
MIA ---
NYM ---
PHI 1915
WASH ---

CHC 1906
CIN 1919
MIL ---
PIT 1909
STL 1926

ARI ---
COL ---
LAD 1916
SD ---
SF 1905

@richismushbud_psn said in Historic Rosters 2021:

@biebig2010_psn said in Historic Rosters 2021:

I am in the process of creating an ALL TIME GREATS roster for MLBTS 21.

Unfortunately MLBTS 21 doesn't allow franchises or rosters to transfer from MLBTS 20 to MLBTS 21 so all players will have to be created from scratch. For a 93 man roster we're talking about over 2700 players. Given this unfortunate situation of having to recreate each player from scratch it's going to take several months to complete this roster.

The first cut of this will be 40-50 of the all time greatest players for each team/franchise. As I create the players for each team/franchise I will upload players to the Player vault. When I get 40-50 players for each team/franchise I'll upload an ALL TIME GREATS roster to the Roster vault.

I'll periodically post updates on this message thread. So far I have finished BAL, MIN, and am working on BOS.

You can use mine for help. AP-LEGENDS-LEAGUE is the name. I have about half of them. Probably have to adjust some guys

Thanks but I prefer to create my own players.

I uploaded a new version of the ALL TIME GREATS roster I'm working on. It includes BAL, BOS, NYY, TB, TOR, CWS, and MIN. Up next is CLE.

Roster name is ALL TIME GREATS under user biebig2010.

According to the MLBTS 22 FAQs we will not be able to carry over franchises or roster from MLBTS 21 to MLBTS 22. What a kick in the nuts.

MLBTS 22 will be a no go for me this year because of this unfortunately .

@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in So....when is the MLB 23 cover athlete going to be revealed?:

We'll probably find out the 2nd Tuesday of next week.

Wait, there's going to be two Tuesdays next week? How will that work?

So SCEA gives us an editor to create awesome custom players, and allows us to add these awesome customer players to custom rosters, and allows us to create franchises using these new custom rosters with the custom players. They also give us a stadium editor to create awesome custom stadiums. Excellent idea.

However, once again SCEA requires everyone to rebuild ALL of their custom stadiums, and custom players, and custom rosters and restart all of their franchises in MLBTS 23 because they won't allow us to carry over the 22 custom stadiums, custom players, custom rosters, or franchises from MLBTS 22 to MLBTS 23.

You've got to be f'n kidding. Once again, SCEA screws their customers on Y2Y saves.

Unbelievable

@macdonald433_PSN said in Post patch cleats:

Biebig2010 hi. Just wondering if you were still working on the nl for your alltime greats roster. Appreciate it. Thanx.

Yes I am. I'm finishing the NL Central and then onto the NL West and I'll upload a version to the vault when I'm done.

I'm not even talking about the stadium vault carrying over what's in it. I'm talking about simply allowing us to take a custom stadium built in MLBTS 22 and opening it and saving it in MLBTS 23. A simple transformer of data from MLBTS 22 to MLBTS 23 is all it would take.

Unless they have completely overhauled the stadium creator this is a relatively simple task that a junior computer science major can do. It's not that difficult and doesn't take a lot of time or resources to accomplish. Almost all companies that sell commercial software do this when a new version of their product is released.

Kick in the nuts to all stadium creators, player creators, and roster creators. SCEA is going to require that all stadiums, players, and rosters will have to be re-created again in MLBTS 22. Unacceptable!

I am planning on porting all of my rosters from MLBTS 19 to MLBTS 20.

For MLBTS 20 it will include ALL TIME GREATS, HISTORIC ROSTERS 1990-2009, HISTORIC ROSTERS 1970-1989, HISTORIC ROSTERS 1950-1969, HISTORIC ROSTERS 1930-1949, and HISTORIC ROSTERS 1900-1929.

FYI... I am just about finished with the MLBTS 19 version of HISTORIC ROSTER 1960-1979 and will likely have it up in the vault sometime this weekend.