Still No Team Captain Update
-
I said it in another thread that I don't want that for very selfish reasons. I don't want Ted Simmons 99 to be a Brewer.
And I'm pretty positive that Red Sox fans don't want to see Clemens as a 99 Blue Jay.
I'm sure there are probably other examples of similar cases where the Jolt legend wasn't on their primary team.
-
I said it in another thread that I don't want that for very selfish reasons. I don't want Ted Simmons 99 to be a Brewer.
And I'm pretty positive that Red Sox fans don't want to see Clemens as a 99 Blue Jay.
I'm sure there are probably other examples of similar cases where the Jolt legend wasn't on their primary team.
Also we just got a nearly maxed hitting 99 Ortiz so the Sox captain would give us 2 99s.
-
Then, it should have been planned better. This year’s game has been a disaster.
-
Then, it should have been planned better. This year’s game has been a disaster.
I’ve enjoyed it. The +6 for a theme team isn’t even that good anyway. Not worth running. Going to guess no captains at all next year, which is a shame because I actually enjoyed them (durability, lefty, and 00s were mint).
-
@Bridge-Piece_XBL said:
Going to guess no captains at all next year, which is a shame because I actually enjoyed them (durability, lefty, and 00s were mint).That seems to be the case, yes.
I enjoyed them last year as by this time i'd started to play with theme teams (on and offline).
If eliminating them was their plan I think taking them out at the start of the year would have been better than what we got, as it just caused frustration for those who loved using them.
-
@Bridge-Piece_XBL It’s not worthless if you want to run a full theme team which is all I want to do. I don’t care about next year. I’m done with this game.
-
@NotesOfJohn_PSN Why take away things that make the game more enjoyable? Every year they take something away and the last few years add very little. The game is getting worse.
-
@GoozeFn_PSN agreed. I don’t understand why they would take away captains. Theme teams were very popular!!
-
I’m genuinely curious why you feel you need a captain for a theme team, especially if your theme team is one of the teams with multiple high diamond flashbacks.
-
@Bridge-Piece_XBL
any sort of communication to that affect would be super difficult for SDS, no?"Hey guys, we are phasing out captains as the year goes on."
Just the usual radio silence from SDS.
-
@Bridge-Piece_XBL
any sort of communication to that affect would be super difficult for SDS, no?"Hey guys, we are phasing out captains as the year goes on."
Just the usual radio silence from SDS.
That I will agree with. But I think because the community gets so toxic over every little thing they announce, they've kept the updates quieter this year.
-
I think not having 99 rated captains for each team is my biggest miss for this year. It's just such an easy win for the content team, which makes their omission a true head-scratcher.
-
@rushmore_NSW 100% correct!!
-
Just so everyone can see potential issues with just upgrading the jolt cards
This is the list of Captains for each team and their best OVR card in the game right now.
MLB THE SHOW 26 - JOLT CARD COMPARISON
ARI
Corbin Burnes - 94 Breakout (MIL)
Luis Gonzalez - No better cardATL
Greg Maddux - 96 All-Star (CHC)
Terry Pendleton - 99 Awards (ATL)BAL
Adam Jones - 99 Moonshot (BAL)
Darren O'Day - 96 Finest (BAL)BOS
David Ortiz - 99 Awards (BOS) / 99 Spotlight (MIN)
Dennis Eckersley - 99 Awards (OAK)CHC
Jake Arrieta - 99 Finest (CHC)
Ryne Sandberg - 99 Field of Dreams (CHC)CIN
Paul O'Neill - 95 Cornerstone (NYY)
Rob Dibble - 96 Summer (CIN)CLE
Corey Kluber - 95 Summer (CLE)
Jim Thome - No better cardCOL
Larry Walker - 99 Finest (COL)
Ubaldo Jiménez - 95 Vintage (COL)CWS
Harold Baines - 98 Field of Dreams (CWS)
Rich Gossage - No better cardDET
Hal Newhouser - No better card
Hank Greenberg - 99 Awards (DET)HOU
Billy Wagner - 99 Finest (PHI)
Jeff Bagwell - No better cardKC
Jeff Suppan - 99 Awards (STL)
Mike Moustakas - 93 Mural (KC)LAA
Jered Weaver - 99 Milestone (LAA)
Wally Joyner - 95 Standout (LAA)LAD
Eric Gagne - No better card
Gil Hodges - 99 Moonshot (LAD)MIA
Al Leiter - 97 Signature (NYM)
Gary Sheffield - 99 Spooky (ATL)MIL
CC Sabathia - 99 Milestone (NYY)
Ted Simmons - 96 Prime (STL)MIN
Johan Santana - 99 Milestone (NYM)
Justin Morneau - No better cardNYM
Mike Piazza - 99 Subway (NYM)
Tom Seaver - No better cardNYY
Andy Pettitte - 99 Awards (NYY)
Derek Jeter - 99 Subway (NYY)OAK
Jason Giambi - No better card
Vida Blue - No better cardPHI
Chase Utley - 94 Vintage (PHI)
Steve Carlton - 96 All-Star (PHI)PIT
Bert Blyleven - No better card
Roberto Clemente - 99 Milestone (PIT)SD
Chase Headley - 95 Summer (SD)
Yu Darvish - No better cardSEA
Cliff Lee - 99 Awards (CLE)
Mike Cameron - No better cardSF
Chili Davis - 99 Milestone (NYY)
Juan Marichal - No better cardSTL
Lee Smith - No better card
Matt Carpenter - 99 Moonshot (STL)TB
Drew Rasmussen - 99 2026 Finest (TB)
Fred McGriff - 99 Hall of Fame (TOR)TEX
Gaylord Perry - 94 Summer (SF)
Rafael Palmeiro - No better cardTOR
Jose Bautista - 99 Moonshot (TOR)
Roger Clemens - 97 All-Star (HOU)WSH
Andre Dawson - No better card
Pedro Martinez - 99 Milestone (BOS)SUMMARY
60 Jolt players
43 have better cards
17 have no better cards
26 have a 99 OVR cardBased on the November 6, 2026 JSON snapshot. Ranked 1000 cosmetic duplicates excluded.
-
@Jeff7407_PSN It’s the only way theme teams can be competitive. Even a Yankees theme team doesn’t come close to God squads. Most teams simply aren’t competitive at all.
-
@Jeff7407_PSN It’s the only way theme teams can be competitive. Even a Yankees theme team doesn’t come close to God squads. Most teams simply aren’t competitive at all.
But would 99 OVR Team captains even really help at this stage against God Squads?
+6 isn't really game changing at this stage.
-
@dolenz_mlbts my point exactly.
Plus I have to believe the reason to use a theme team is to have fun and play with players from your favorite team. It isn’t about ranked season record and beating a god squad nor was it ever. Theme teams have never been the meta of this game (save for the broken switch hitting or durability captains which were way over juiced) -
@Dolenz_PSN Of course it’s not optimal, but yes it at least makes most theme teams somewhat competitive. If it doesn’t make them optimal, what’s the problem? I don’t even care if they get rid of the first 2 lesser player options. Just give us a captain for a full theme team. Why take away fun elements of the game? I just don’t understand people constantly defending SDS needlessly taking things away.
-
@goozefn_psn if they are going to go down this road then I’d rather see them rework captains. Don’t tie it to a single card. If I have 20 Colorado Rockies on my roster then allow a boost. If they are all live series allow a larger boost. If they are above 98 overall don’t count them in the total.
I realize this would never happen as the programming would require changing what currently exists and there doesn’t seem to be any interest in rewriting the game code.