Torn between the two. Currently have Bregman at 3rd. Outfield with Cargo is Gallo in lf, yelich in cf, and Reggie in rf. Getting Cargo would move Gallo to 3rd. Thoughts on either two? Have pudge at catcher and hate his bat but love his defense.
I do not have CarGo so I cannot speak on him. I do have Eddie though and I can say he is fantastic, vs both sides too. Defense is serviceable, although not the greatest
Eddie Mathews is an absolute beast at the plate and hits a ton of homers. Haven’t tried cargo
Mathews is my guy.
CarGo all the way
I got Pudge early on this year because I was worried about not having a god catcher for a while. I’m slowly plugging through the AL collections too. I did hit well with signature cargo last year but I’ve actually never tried an Mathews card.
CarGo all day long.
Yelich in CF must be a nightmare. The amount of errors he makes in Lf is bad enough
Definitely go with CarGo. He consistently makes solid contact and plays above average defense in center.
Love Cargo's swing but Eddie just an absolute animal especially at 3B / LF secondary
As much as I love my Rockies, I can never hit with players that have a pronounced leg kick. I want CarGo to be great for me, and I will take him over Pudge, but I won't take him until the Gold level.
Eddie on the other hand is absolutely awesome.
I took CarGo as I have Arenado at 3rd and I don't regret it. Very small sample size but he might have been my best hitter in the first few games I've played with him in ranked.
Eddie is amazing.