Now that the other 25 legends have been revealed and we've seen some big surprises and some obvious choices (I'm looking at you Saberhagen) who do you think the NL West will be?
Diamondbacks- Steve Finley
Dodgers- Eric Gagne
Rockies- Todd Helton
Padres- Tony Gwynn
Giants- Willie McCovey for @TEXAS10PT_PSN
I’m hoping for:
AZ: Luis Gonzalez
Padres: Gwynn
Giants: Christy Mathewson (I like the old timers!)
Rockies: Dante bichette
Dodgers: Duke
@SchnauzerFace_MLBTS said in Last minute NL West predictions:
I’m hoping for:
AZ: Luis Gonzalez
Padres: Gwynn
Giants: Christy Mathewson (I like the old timers!)
Rockies: Dante bichette
Dodgers: Duke
Booo Mathewson’s card is an unusable dust collector. McCovey or riot. I think you are right about Duke though
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in Last minute NL West predictions:
@SchnauzerFace_MLBTS said in Last minute NL West predictions:
I’m hoping for:
AZ: Luis Gonzalez
Padres: Gwynn
Giants: Christy Mathewson (I like the old timers!)
Rockies: Dante bichette
Dodgers: DukeBooo Mathewson’s card is an unusable dust collector. McCovey or riot. I think you are right about Duke though
I'm hoping for McCovey too, but you know we're getting Marvin Bernard! 
AZ- Randy (unless they do a 2001 finest)
COL- Bichette(though they have before so could be Helton.
LA- Gibson (maybe Hersh)
SD- Gwynn( maybe Hoffman)
SF- McCovey
@tybud_PSN said in Last minute NL West predictions:
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in Last minute NL West predictions:
@SchnauzerFace_MLBTS said in Last minute NL West predictions:
I’m hoping for:
AZ: Luis Gonzalez
Padres: Gwynn
Giants: Christy Mathewson (I like the old timers!)
Rockies: Dante bichette
Dodgers: DukeBooo Mathewson’s card is an unusable dust collector. McCovey or riot. I think you are right about Duke though
I'm hoping for McCovey too, but you know we're getting Marvin Bernard!
Now batting number 7 Marvin Bernard lmao that was a while back. Good memory
I really hope Arizona's is Finley. He's always my favorite card in the game. Realistic expectations are the same as yours but swap Gagne for Hershiser
I got a feeling they will go with Orel for the Dodgers but I would love a Gagne to balance all the lefties in my pen. I was hoping the Cards would get Lee Smith but instead they gave us Ozzie Smith. Lol
@Ericulous1_PSN said in Last minute NL West predictions:
Now that the other 25 legends have been revealed and we've seen some big surprises and some obvious choices (I'm looking at you Saberhagen) who do you think the NL West will be?
Diamondbacks- Steve Finley
Dodgers- Eric Gagne
Rockies- Todd Helton
Padres- Tony Gwynn
Giants- Willie McCovey for @TEXAS10PT_PSN
Diamondbacks - Steve Finley
Dodgers - Orel Hershiser
Rockies - Dante Bichette
Padres - Tony Gwynn
Giants - had better be Willie McCovey
Oh Eric a 99 Pablo with secondary C would be awesome. His 97 last year from the Daily path was P5 99 and he stayed in my lineup a looong time. If it’s not McCovey let it be Panda
@Ericulous1_PSN said in Last minute NL West predictions:
I'm gonna be so sad when the Giabts is Pablo Sandoval or Monte Irvin (no offense to him)
Sandoval isn't a legend. The choices are between McCovey, Mathewson, Nen, and Irvin
@the_dragon1912 said in Last minute NL West predictions:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in Last minute NL West predictions:
I'm gonna be so sad when the Giabts is Pablo Sandoval or Monte Irvin (no offense to him)
Sandoval isn't a legend. The choices are between McCovey, Mathewson, Nen, and Irvin
That’s right Panda still has a free agent card. We would be lost without you Dragon
@TEXAS10PT_PSN said in Last minute NL West predictions:
@the_dragon1912 said in Last minute NL West predictions:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in Last minute NL West predictions:
I'm gonna be so sad when the Giabts is Pablo Sandoval or Monte Irvin (no offense to him)
Sandoval isn't a legend. The choices are between McCovey, Mathewson, Nen, and Irvin
That’s right Panda still has a free agent card. We would be lost without you Dragon
Where. Is. My. 95+. Panda.
@the_dragon1912 said in Last minute NL West predictions:
@Ericulous1_PSN said in Last minute NL West predictions:
I'm gonna be so sad when the Giabts is Pablo Sandoval or Monte Irvin (no offense to him)
Sandoval isn't a legend. The choices are between McCovey, Mathewson, Nen, and
Oh yeah, thought he retired like Miller but I guess he's still not a "legend" either. And Juan Marischal right?
I predict that we are not getting these cards.
Diamondbacks- Curt Schilling
Dodgers- Hideo Nomo
Rockies- Elllis Burks
Padres- Roberto Alomar
Giants- Jeff Kent
@Bob_Loblaw1984 said in Last minute NL West predictions:
I predict that we are not getting these cards.
Diamondbacks- Curt Schilling
Dodgers- Hideo Nomo
Rockies- Elllis Burks
Padres- Roberto Alomar
Giants- Jeff Kent
Haha i have a feeling you will be 100% acurate in those guesses. Although i've been asking for a Hideo Nomo card for years now. His windup would was just awesome lol.
@PAinPA_PSN said in Last minute NL West predictions:
AZ- Randy (unless they do a 2001 finest)
COL- Bichette(though they have before so could be Helton.
LA- Gibson (maybe Hersh)
SD- Gwynn( maybe Hoffman)
SF- McCovey
If the pattern continues (meaning they have an existing card as a prerequisite to improve upon) it should be:
Orel Hershiser for LA
McCovey for SF
Gwynn for SD
Gonzalez for AZ
Helton for COL
Personally I’d love to see McCovey get his due. The LS reward card wasn’t anything Special (nor was Gwynn’s for that matter. Honestly I’m pretty underwhelmed by the reveals as a whole.
