I Must Be The Only Player in RS That Struggles The Most Filling This Position...

1B.

Yeah, I said it.

I know the community complains that we always have too many 1B options.

And we do. But they're crappy options. (IMHO)

I currently have a revolving door of Eduardo Escobar and Carlos Santana. But they're both performing poorly.

Find me a 1B I'll like!

One major caveat though. It has to be a switch hitter or righty. Otherwise my lineup becomes too lefty dominant.
(P5s Brett, Utley, Cedric Mullins aren't going anywhere)

I've tried all of the usual options (Big Hurt, Pujols, Toglia, etc.) so maybe looking for an underrated guy with a nice, quick swing.

Josh Bell FotF card is pretty good. Cheap too

Ty France did well for me but he’s super slow. He’s got good vision and contact- so you’ll have a big fat pci to play with

Pete Alonso

@mcnuggies5600_xbl said in I Must Be The Only Player in RS That Struggles The Most Filling This Position...:

Josh Bell FotF card is pretty good. Cheap too

I didn't love him offline, but haven't tried him online.

But sometimes I actually like a player online better than off, so maybe I'll give him a shot.

@ibonafidescrub_ said in I Must Be The Only Player in RS That Struggles The Most Filling This Position...:

Pete Alonso, good and quick swing and very balanced attributes
@dbub_PSN

@ibonafidescrub_ said in I Must Be The Only Player in RS That Struggles The Most Filling This Position...:

Pete Alonso

I literally forgot about him. Ill give him a go.

@dbub_psn said in I Must Be The Only Player in RS That Struggles The Most Filling This Position...:

@mcnuggies5600_xbl said in I Must Be The Only Player in RS That Struggles The Most Filling This Position...:

Josh Bell FotF card is pretty good. Cheap too

I didn't love him offline, but haven't tried him online.

But sometimes I actually like a player online better than off, so maybe I'll give him a shot.

Also monthly Alonso, or even goldschmidt LS could be right hand options !

Piazza can play first so can joe mauer etc try someone with a secondry, maybe devers

@thegreatwilliss_xbl said in I Must Be The Only Player in RS That Struggles The Most Filling This Position...:

Piazza can play first so can joe mauer etc try someone with a secondry, maybe devers

OP asked for a RH,or switch hitter. Mauer and Devers are left handed options only. But I get your point, play someone at their secondary position

If Brett can play first, put him there and find a new 3B

Big rizzzzzz

@dbub_psn said in I Must Be The Only Player in RS That Struggles The Most Filling This Position...:

1B.

Yeah, I said it.

I know the community complains that we always have too many 1B options.

And we do. But they're crappy options. (IMHO)

I currently have a revolving door of Eduardo Escobar and Carlos Santana. But they're both performing poorly.

Find me a 1B I'll like!

One major caveat though. It has to be a switch hitter or righty. Otherwise my lineup becomes too lefty dominant.
(P5s Brett, Utley, Cedric Mullins aren't going anywhere)

I've tried all of the usual options (Big Hurt, Pujols, Toglia, etc.) so maybe looking for an underrated guy with a nice, quick swing.

Micheal Toglia I would stick with

@sbevans142_psn said in I Must Be The Only Player in RS That Struggles The Most Filling This Position...:

Ty France did well for me but he’s super slow. He’s got good vision and contact- so you’ll have a big fat pci to play with

This was my 1st basman till I unlocked Babe.

FOtF Bell was solid for a long time. Maybe move Brett to 1st. I know you said switch or righty but Lightning Devers rakes. Send Mullins to the bench. Tons of right-handed CFs.

@mubby_33_psn said in I Must Be The Only Player in RS That Struggles The Most Filling This Position...:

FOtF Bell was solid for a long time. Maybe move Brett to 1st. I know you said switch or righty but Lightning Devers rakes. Send Mullins to the bench. Tons of right-handed CFs.

Yeah that makes the most sense and was my original plan, but for some reason I can't hit with him. I raked with FOTF Devers but not the upgrade, lol.

Only 30+ ABs though so maybe sample size is too small. But it's brutal. I'm hitting like .600 OPS with him when my other starters are all 1.200+.

Rizzo.

I was also happy that I picked Pratto.

There are a few threads about this though. Funny enough we got so many posts about the exact opposite problem last year

Suggestion. If you're not performing with a righty/switch hitter just have a lefty who you hit well with play 1.

If you have Frank just use Frank and stop being weird. His stats are bonkers.