Best C in The Show

SDS

Like 2B, this is one of the weakest positions though there are some really great options. I still need to give Finest Salvy a chance and I never really used his TA3 All Star card (or Realmuto's TA3 card) because their HRD and ASG cards are so great.

Feel free as always to put primary, secondary, anything you want. I will put Primary top 5 in no order.

  1. Adley Rutchman FS
  2. Mike Piazza Signature
  3. JT Realmuto ASG
  4. Pudge Rodriguez Signature
  5. Yasmani Grandal TN

Honorable mention: Buster Posey Finest- I haven't used him for long but starting to love his swing.
Salvador Perez HRD- I know his Finest is better but his HRD has been one of my favorite cards all year.

SDS
  1. Grandal Topps
  2. Piazza Sig
  3. Rutchman Future Stars
  4. Perez Finest
  5. Will Smith Monthly

Top 2 of Piazza and Grandal have performed vastly better than the rest of the catchers for me.

SDS

Posada is the only answer here dudes a fn glitch

SDS

@sportpimpin_xbl said in Best C in The Show:

Posada is the only answer here dudes a fn glitch

Oh yeah. I love both Posadas. Hope he gets a 99 next season but his 95 was great too.

SDS

Been Running Schwarber/Foxx Platoon, but honestly struggling finding consistency from that position on HOF.

SDS

Piazza, Perez, Rutschman, Posada, Grandal

SDS

Realmuto
Biggio
Posada
S. Perez Finest
Piazza

SDS

@virusts_xbl said in Best C in The Show:

  1. Grandal Topps
  2. Piazza Sig
  3. Rutchman Future Stars
  4. Perez Finest
  5. Will Smith Monthly

Top 2 of Piazza and Grandal have performed vastly better than the rest of the catchers for me.

You don’t mind using Grandal with his speed? I love his swing, but hate how slow he is on the bases. Please don’t answer: “Speed doesn’t matter when you’re hitting home runs.” Not here to criticize, just curious about it. I have the same issue with Posey.

SDS

Schwaber all day.

SDS

Primary catcher for me would be between Piazza and Rutchman. I tend to use Foxx a lot in that spot and used Schwarber for a pretty long spell as well.

SDS

@sportpimpin_xbl said in Best C in The Show:

Posada is the only answer here dudes a fn glitch

Early on I thought Posada was always the best. I recently went back to him and he might just be my favorite catcher again. Adley,Foxx, and All Star JT are up there too. The 90 collections Posada is just so clutch.

SDS

@ericulous1_psn said in Best C in The Show:

@sportpimpin_xbl said in Best C in The Show:

Posada is the only answer here dudes a fn glitch

Oh yeah. I love both Posadas. Hope he gets a 99 next season but his 95 was great too.

Crazy to say but I think the 90 collections Posada might be better than the 95. That 120 contact vs righties in elite.

SDS

Schwarber and Schwarber