Here is the question: do you build your online team using offline stats, or do you just have to see how players play online?
Some players I seem to do better with online like Jay Buhner, while others I do better with offline, like Ellsbury. Do you have an online team vs. an offline team? Or do you find that if you rake offline with a player, you'll rake with him online too?
I do not make any team decision based on offline stats.
I struggle with Helton and Hornsby offline, but destroy baseballs online with them.
Another good example would be Ruth. I cant hit water if I fell out of boat with hime online, but rake offline.
I also don't consider how a card does offline. I'll play a couple friendlies, league games, or events games with cards I'm considering
Anything vs CPU means absolutely nothing to me.
My CPU stats are ridiculously good. Online... eh... not so much.